Chapter 43 What the Night Conceals - Chapter 7
Three days had passed since Samuel had taken flight. Alyssa counted every hour, every minute, while Kaio kept her distracted with tantalizing stories and touches that left her skin aflame — but he never crossed the line. It was as if they both knew that any step taken without Samuel would amount to a true betrayal.
When the front door finally creaked open that night, Alyssa was ready.
"Where have you been?" Alyssa materialized in the entrance hall like a ghost, clad only in a sheer nightgown.
Samuel halted in the middle of the hallway, his suitcase dropping to the floor with a dull thud. His face was etched with fatigue and something deeper - could it be regret?
"Work," he muttered, avoiding her gaze.
"You ran away."
He finally turned his gaze to her, his dark eyes ablaze with a blend of anger and desire.
"You're my stepdaughter, for God's sake."
"You didn't raise me. We're not related by blood."
Samuel let out a scornful laugh.
"Do you think the world will care about these details?"
"I only care about how YOU feel!" Alyssa burst out, her voice echoing throughout the house. "What am I to you now?"
The ensuing silence was deafening.
Kaio appeared at the top of the stairs, clad only in a pair of torn jeans, observing the scene with calculating eyes.
"Drama worthy of a soap opera," he remarked, descending the stairs with the grace of a predator. "But I think we all know the answer, don't we?"
Samuel turned to him with a snarl.
"Don't start."
"The only obstacle is your antiquated conscience."
Alyssa felt Samuel's body stiffen, but he remained still.
No one needs to be aware.
"You're insane," Samuel spat out.
"It would be insane to waste this," Kaio closed the gap between them, his body barely missing Samuel's. "How often do we get opportunities like this, buddy?"
Alyssa observed the tension between the two men, feeling the air crackling with electricity. When Kaio lifted his hand to touch Samuel's face, she held her breath.
"I've always wanted both," Kaio confessed, his thumb tracing Samuel's bottom lip. "But you never allowed it."
Suddenly, Samuel pulled away, his eyes wild.
"Damn it, Kaio!"
"Listen, Samuel," Kaio persisted, his voice unexpectedly serious. "You can spend the rest of your life pretending you don't feel anything. Or you can have everything you want, on your terms."
Alyssa watched the conflict play out in Samuel's eyes — duty versus desire, morality against passion. When he finally spoke, his voice was unrecognizable.
"Never outside this house."
Kaio smiled, slow and victorious.
"Sure. The secrecy is part of the fun."
Alyssa, however, was not satisfied.
"And when we're alone?" She challenged, her gaze fixed on Samuel. "Will you touch me without any guilt?" Will you be able to look me in the eyes when I call out your name?
Samuel closed the gap between them in two swift steps, his hands clenching her face with an intensity that caused her to shudder.
"You want the truth?" He snarled, his warm breath brushing against her lips. "I'm going to have you until you forget your own name. Until your clever tongue can do nothing but moan. And then I'll tidy you up and send you off to your room as if nothing ever happened.
Alyssa felt her knees buckle.
"Promise?" She murmured.
It was Kaio who replied, chuckling as he pulled Samuel into an intense kiss before turning to Alyssa.
"Oh, princess..." He grinned mischievously. "The night has just begun."
Alyssa lay in the center of the bed, naked under the intense gaze of the two men now approaching from opposite sides. Samuel, his muscles taut under his sun-kissed skin, and Kaio, his body chiseled like a weapon.
"Are you certain?" Samuel rumbled, his fingers digging into the mattress next to her head.
Alyssa responded by pulling him into a passionate kiss by his hair. Her teeth nipped at his lower lip, causing him to moan.
"Less talk," she commanded, arching against him.
Kaio let out a soft chuckle, his hands gliding up Alyssa's parted thighs.
"She has such a beautiful way with words when she's impatient," he remarked before delving his tongue into her navel.
Samuel took one of her breasts into his mouth, sucking on the nipple until Alyssa let out a scream. Kaio didn't waste a second — his fingers found her already engorged clitoris, massaging in precise circles while he watched Samuel explore her body.
"She's so ready for us," Kaio murmured, smearing his glistening fingers across Samuel's lips. Evidence.
Samuel complied, drawing the fingers into his mouth with a look that sent a shiver down Alyssa's spine.
It was Kaio who made the first move. He pushed Samuel back onto the bed and straddled his face, offering his pulsating cock to Alyssa.
"Service him while I pleasure you," Kaio commanded, positioning himself between her legs.
Alyssa didn't hesitate. She took Kaio into her mouth, tasting the fluid already seeping from him. Samuel gripped her hips, pulling her closer as his tongue explored her.
Kaio let out a deep moan when Alyssa took him in fully.
"That's it, sweetheart. Just like that," he growled, his fingers tangling in her hair.
Samuel quickened his pace, his tongue finding the exact spot that made Alyssa writhe. She moaned around Kaio, feeling her climax building like a freight train.
"I'm about to..." she tried to warn, but Kaio thrust forward, deepening their connection.
Samuel didn't let up. Instead, he captured her clitoris between his lips and sucked until Alyssa erupted, her body violently arching between the two men.
Kaio yanked her hair, forcing her to watch Samuel as he climaxed in her mouth.
"Swallow it all," he commanded, rubbing his member against her swollen lips. "Show him how good you are."
Alyssa complied, cleaning every drop with her tongue while Samuel watched, his eyes dark with pure lust.
That's when Samuel flipped her over, aligning his body with hers from behind.
"Now it's my turn," he growled, before penetrating her with a thrust that made the bed quiver.
Kaio positioned himself in front of her, guiding his manhood to her lips while Samuel penetrated her with increasing intensity.
"That's it," Kaio encouraged, fondling her breasts. "Show us who you choose."
Alyssa didn't respond verbally. Instead, she sank her teeth into Kaio's thigh as her next orgasm overcame her, causing both men to roar in satisfaction.