Chapter 242
Theo's POV
I line up at Natalie's entrance and watch her for signs of fear as I rub my tip in all the cream seeping out of her. She looks down as I rub my tip in her juices, spreading it around. I'm keeping control because I can't afford to lose it and hurt her. I don't want her to fear sex because sex feels awesome if done right.
"Ready, angel?" I look up from her pussy. I keep watching it as I rub my tip on it.
"Yes," she says shyly and with fear, "will it hurt?" I hate her experiences were awful. Nobody should be forced to fuck. Sex should never be forced or painful for the other partner. I begin to ease in but also talk to her.
"I'm going in, Angel; just relax for me. Don't stiffen, and just let me in." She looks at me as I ease in more. A moan leaves her lips, and I smile. I think her heat hit when I marked her, which is also helping because it usually takes a week for heat to hit humans after we mark them.
"Theo," she moans loudly, and I grin. I put more in, and her fingers grip my forearms. She looks at me, and I kiss her mouth softly.
"You were made for me, angel." I kissed her more. "This body was made for me, and I intend to cherish it. Does it hurt?" She nods no as more sinks in, and she moans as I brush her G-spot. Fuck me. I groan as my wolf says to go slower.
"Theo," she moans as I get all of my cock inside, and I hold still. She moans as her pussy clenches on my shaft.
"Want me to move?" She stares up at me and nods. I lean down and kiss her lips, loving the way it feels. She kisses back, and I love how she trusts me to take care of her.
"Please move," she whispers, and I begin an easy but slow thrust, making us both gasp. She digs nails in my biceps as I brush her G-spot, and fuck, I'm in heaven.
"Are you okay, baby?" She nods as tears fill her eyes. When they overflow, I almost stop.
"I never...it never... I mean, this feels... it feels..." I kiss her lips, cutting off her words.
"It feels good, doesn't it? It feels right as well, "I murmur, and she sniffles.
"Yes," she moans as I keep thrusting, and before I can pull out to cum, she explodes, and I kiss her to stop the pleasure-filled scream she lets out. She holds onto me tight, her body arching into mine. She pants as I cum deep inside her, knowing I most likely put our pup in her. I kissed her till we both calmed down, and I eased off her. She started to sob, and I gathered her close.
"You are okay, angel. I soothed, Every time we mate will feel good. "No hurting my love," she nods and sniffles, hugging me tight. I lay holding her when another alarm sounds, and I know it is either her parents or rogues. She stiffens, but I just purr and hold her.
"I'm sorry I keep crying, Theo. It has to drive you nuts. I don't mean to be weak." I move her to face me, and I cup her face.
"You are not weak. Natalie You are extremely strong, and I am so proud you trusted me enough to mate. I would never hurt you or judge you for what happened in the past. I'm happy you're my mate." Her eyes fill again, and I hug her as she starts to cry again.
"Thank you, Theo," she snuggles against me. "I am happy I'm with you and not the masters." I rub her back.
"Any time you want to talk about that, I'm here, angel. I am a great listener, and if you don't want to talk to me, we have great members here who will listen and help. Now about your parents, can you tell me about them?" She sighs sadly.
"I was sixteen when they sold me, and I never saw them after. The night Warren came, I begged and pleaded with them not to sell me because I wanted to go to college, but both turned their backs on me. I hugged her small body.
"College at sixteen?" I question.
"I graduated early and planned to go to college, and both disagreed on it. I was giving them half my paycheck weekly, and if I went to college, that would stop, so I woke to them telling me they sold me for a few million. I begged and begged, but both just walked away. Warren was so violent that my first time was awful and bloody," she sniffles, and I hug her tighter.
"They won't get you back, Natalie. You have my word. We will keep you safe. Warren is dead, and so are many of the other masters. None can get close to taking any of you away. Dad is vigilant, and so am I." She snuggles closer and soon falls into a deep sleep. I cover her and head to the bathroom to shower and message Dad. He responded fast, saying her mom and dad brought rogues and a few men claiming to be masters. I growl as I clean up. Those bastards hurt her beyond what a parent should.
Money—they sold their daughter for money.
"Dad, she was sold at sixteen," I texted.
"Fuck, son, all she has known is rape and abuse. Did she let you mark her?" he texted. We both discussed marking her, so if it's a worst-case scenario, they get her. I can find her.
"Yes, I marked and mated her. She did good, Dad, and no, I didn't force it. She fell asleep a while ago," he sent a thumbs up.
"The rogues at the gate said her parents hired them to get her back. Told them we kidnapped her, and she was brainwashed to stay and serve us. I sent them packing, but I got a feeling they aren't done, son, and will pull out all the stops to get Natalie. We need to basically hide her," he texted a while later, and I sighed as I washed my face.
"Theo," I heard Natalie whimper, and I ran out. She sat up, holding a blanket to her chest, tears falling.
"I'm here, angel. I was just using the toilet and texting my dad. I didn't want to wake you up. What is wrong, my love?" She sniffles.
"I thought you left me," she trembles, and I wipe the tears away. I gather her close, and she snuggles into my arms. I'm rubbing her back as I hold her, and she calms down. I hate that she fears I'm going to leave, and I hope that with time, she will trust me fully. I don't just want her trust in sex but also with her heart.
I kiss her head and lie beside her.