"Nope, I don't want it either." Catherine was still being stubborn, covering her mouth tightly to keep herself from making any noise.
Even though she wasn't playing along, I felt a thrill I'd never felt before. Sure, I loved getting it on with Grace, Sophia, and Mia—their moans and eagerness were super satisfying.
But it always felt like just going through the motions, like clocking in at work. I was mostly doing it to satisfy their needs, and sometimes to get a little relief myself.
But with Catherine, even though she was a newbie and the pleasure of having sex with her wasn't even close to Grace and the others, I was still genuinely happy. It felt like we were doing something we both wanted, like we were in it together.
We could chat while we were at it. The vibe wasn't super romantic or anything, but it was cozy. It even made the cold hotel room feel a bit warmer.
For someone like me, who didn't get much love growing up, it felt like a touch of family warmth.
I felt something similar with Scarlett too, but with her, it was more like hanging out with a family member. But with Catherine, it felt more like being with a lover. We were together because of love.
Overall, it was a really nice feeling.
So when Catherine didn't want to moan for me, I didn't push her. I just kept thrusting into her, not changing positions for a long time, and I didn't get bored.
But this time, I noticed a change in Catherine's body.
Her breasts got hard, her legs clamped around my waist, her body stiffened, and the arms holding my back started to lose strength.
Then her tight little spot started to contract rapidly, like it was trying to hold onto my cock, not wanting me to pull out.
I knew Catherine was about to climax, so I decided to stay put.
I pushed my hips harder, thrusting into her, aiming for her sensitive spot.
Her contractions sped up, her lower abdomen shaking uncontrollably.
Catherine couldn't hold back anymore and started moaning.
After she climaxed, I felt my own release coming. My cock, buried deep inside her, released a thick load, filling her up.
But she was so tight, hugging my shaft with no room for anything else, and the semen couldn't come out.
In no time, Catherine wrapped her arms and legs around me, her chest heaving, breathing quickly.
I gently loosened her grip, got off her, and lay down, pulling her into my arms.
Catherine naturally snuggled up to me, her arms around my waist, one leg still draped over me.
It was a pretty intimate position.
I knew she was relaxed, and it seemed like women liked to sleep like this, finding it comfy.
But I couldn't resist teasing her a bit.
I placed a hand on her butt, gently caressing and kneading it, and with a playful smile, I whispered in her ear, "With your little spot right in front of my cock, you want to go for another round?"
Hearing my words, Catherine quickly let go of me as if I was a beast, and scooted back to put some distance between us.
Her eyes went wide with anxiety. "I didn't mean that, don't talk nonsense."
"Oh really? But it sure seems like you want it," I teased, moving closer to her.
In no time, I had her backed up to the edge of the bed. One more move and she'd be falling off.
Her upper body was already hanging off the bed, and she was straining her neck to keep her head from dangling.
I leaned over her, one hand under her butt, holding her up, and the other around her back, cradling her neck to keep her relaxed.
"Don't... don't come any closer!"
Catherine pushed at my chin with both hands, trying to shove me away, even if it meant leaning back more to avoid me.
If I hadn't been pressing her down, she would've fallen off the bed by now.
"Don't be so quick to say no, think about it."
"No! I'm all wet down there because of you, it's uncomfortable. Don't come any closer," she shot back without hesitation.
"Is that so?" I reached down and touched her pussy, my fingertips coming away slick with moisture, like thick yogurt, warm to the touch. I held my hand up, showing her the sticky essence between my thumb and forefinger. "This is all my essence, it's good for your skin, you know."
Catherine rolled her eyes. "I don't believe that. Get your hands off, it's gross."
She pushed my fingers away, clearly worried the semen might drip on her.
If this were Mia or Grace, they'd be more than happy to swallow it down.
But Catherine, sweet and innocent, found it repulsive.
This reminded me of something important! We hadn't used protection during our hour-long romp, and I hadn't even opened the new condoms I bought.
What if Catherine got pregnant? What would I do then? I'd have to take responsibility, right?
Even though Catherine seemed like a great marriage partner, I wasn't ready to settle down and have kids just yet!
I still wanted to have some fun, and sleep with more women before tying the knot!
Thinking about this, I quickly let go of Catherine and got up from the bed while grabbing my clothes from the floor to put on.
Catherine turned over, lying on the bed, watching me with a confused look. "Are you leaving right after sleeping with me?"
"No, I'm just going to buy some emergency contraception. We didn't use condoms, and what if you get pregnant? You wouldn't want to be a mom so young, right?"
And I definitely didn't want to be a dad so young either.
"But it's so late, where can we find emergency contraception now?"
"That's why I need to go out and look for it. It's best to take it right after sex for maximum effect."
After thinking for a moment, Catherine got off the bed, took my hand, and led me back.
"Don't worry about that, I'll have my assistant get it for us." She pulled me back into bed.