I lightly pursed my lips and started kissing Catherine's neck, slowly making my way down to her shoulder.
Catherine's neck seemed to be her weak spot. The moment I touched it, she flinched a bit but quickly got used to it.
As I kept kissing, her breathing got heavier, and she clung to my clothes, looking all tense, nothing like the confident Grace.
I couldn't help but ask, "Why so nervous? Haven't you done this before?"
Catherine turned her head away, eyes shut tight, not daring to look at me. She just said, "Stop saying that. Just do it."
"Alright, you said it. Don't regret it later." I lifted her skirt to her waist and saw that she was wearing a very ordinary pair of panties, which were pink and looked quite adorable.
To help her get used to it, I lightly touched her over the panties.
The moment my fingers made contact, she clamped her legs shut, making it hard to move.
I struggled a bit, barely able to move my hand. "Relax, if you're too tight, I'll think you're really desperate."
"No way!" she denied, then opened her legs.
But as soon as I touched her again, she closed them right back up.
I figured her private part was super sensitive.
At this rate, we'd be here all night, and I still wouldn't get anywhere.
I sat on the edge of the bed, and used my hands to spread her legs, holding her thighs apart, her panties in full view.
I gently touched her over the panties a few times. At first, she tried to close her legs, but I kept them open, and she gradually got used to it.
But even after several touches, her panties stayed dry.
Weirded out, I poked her entrance lightly through the panties. It slid out slowly, not sticking like Mia and the others.
This odd situation just made me more determined. I started rubbing up and down with three fingers over the panties.
Catherine couldn't help but moan.
Maybe my rubbing made her feel itchy deep inside, her hips moving up and down, pushing against me.
But still, her panties stayed dry, which was really strange.
I wondered, 'How hasn't she been wet? Perhaps because her panties are waterproof?'Curious, I pulled her panties down.
No moisture at all. I touched her, not a drop.
It was crazy, how could she be so sensitive but dry?
I kept rubbing her pussy, using both hands, one rubbing up and down, the other pressing at her entrance, trying to get some moisture. After ten minutes and still no wetness, I was losing my patience.
I wanted to be gentle with her, but this wasn't working, and I couldn't be bothered to keep pretending.
I knelt between her legs, her plump, pink private part right in front of me. After a quick look, I slid my middle finger inside.
Catherine winced, a pained look on her face.
But man, she was tight. Just one knuckle in, and it felt like my finger was getting crushed.
I tried to go a bit deeper.
It felt like something was blocking the way, like a wall.
A super tight private part, no wetness, and something in the way? My gut told me this was her hymen.
Surprised, I looked up at her, "You're a virgin?"
"Is that really so surprising?"
"Yeah, it is. You're almost twenty, right? Not many women your age are still virgins."
"I didn't plan on keeping it this long, but there aren't many men worthy of me."
She had high standards. But now, I was kinda grateful for her pickiness. A virgin? That was a rare find, and I even wanted to marry her right now!
Even though I'd been with many women, a virgin felt different, even more special than Scarlett.
Women with boyfriends or husbands were skilled, sure, but their skills were taught by other men. Their favorite positions were honed with their partners.
Like how I loved having a woman's legs together, sitting on them, and feeling that tight sensation.
With a virgin, I could mold her into what I liked. I could train her to please me in the ways I wanted.
"It's okay, I'll teach you. It'll feel good." I couldn't wait any longer. I took off my pajamas and underwear, positioning my hard penis against her pussy.
But as soon as I tried to enter, it was so tight I could barely breathe.
"Wow, you're really a virgin... it's so tight."
"Please, pull out, it hurts!"
"It's normal to feel pain the first time." I held my penis and tried to push in a bit more.