Chapter 79 The Price of His Choice
POV Scarlett:
“Of all the decisions you’ve ever made, Damian, this one is—with fucking certainty—the worst,” Liam said as he opened the door for Noah to walk through, carrying me in his arms. “From this moment on, you’re nothing to Scarlett, other than a brother-in-law, of course. So stay away from her.”
A stab of sadness tore through my body. Ethan kissed my forehead. Receiving their affection eases the emptiness I’m feeling inside, just a little. I throw one last look at Damian, and what I see breaks my heart. Damian stays calm, as if nothing important is happening. His partner gently touches his arm, but Damian does nothing but look at me. I turn my face away, freeing Damian from what he doesn’t want.
Me.
...
A few days later…
The moment I open my eyes, I find two bodies pressing me in.
I smile, mischievous, feeling their hard cocks against me. Ever since we decided to move forward with our relationship, Liam, Ethan, and Noah decided they wouldn’t touch me until I’m 100% better. They don’t want me to act up and end up needing the crutches longer, which is an exaggeration on their part—I’ve barely been using them.
While we haven’t chosen a house to live in, we’re still living with Damian, and it hasn’t been easy. Even though I know I’m doing the right thing, that for the first time I’m thinking about myself and my happiness, seeing him every day doesn’t help me forget him, much less stop loving him. Our routine has changed drastically. Damian doesn’t eat with us anymore. His relationship with his brothers, which used to be harmonious, took a different turn a week ago. Ethan, Noah, and Liam are jealous of Damian; they no longer see their brother as my partner. Damian made his choice, and like Liam told me, now he’ll have to live with it.
Pulling myself out of my depressive thoughts about Damian, I focus again on Noah and Liam, who are still asleep. Last night, when it was my turn to sleep with Ethan and Noah, I almost convinced both of them to have sex with me, but Liam showing up to wish me good morning ruined my plans. Every night they rotate: two sleep with me while the other sleeps in his own room. It’s worked for us, even though I want to be with all three at the same time.
I feel the pressure of Noah’s cock against my ass, and shamelessly, I push back. My insides ignite, craving something I’ve gone so long without I’ve almost forgotten what it is. I slide to the foot of the bed, getting on all fours, and I don’t think too much. I slowly pull down Noah’s underwear. His cock rests against his abdomen, and the veins make me swallow hard, my mouth watering, wanting to taste him on my tongue.
I lower my head and lick where a little pre-cum leaks out. The taste bursts in my mouth, and the desire I’ve avoided for so long takes over every one of my impulses. I grip his cock, applying just the right pressure, making Noah moan. I take him into my mouth, closing my eyes to savor every second. I feel a hand stroking my head, and when I glance to the side, I’m surprised to see Liam awake.
“He thinks he’s dreaming.” I look at Noah, who’s still asleep. “Suck harder,” Liam asks, rough, and I obey with pleasure, drawing more moans from Noah with my mouth.
My panties are soaked. I suck Noah’s cock without taking my eyes off Liam, who pulls his cock out of his underwear and strokes it slowly. Enchanted by his unhurried masturbation, I angle my ass toward him, giving him the view of my ruined panties.
“Fuck.”
His fingers are on me over the wet fabric in no time, and with my mouth full, my moan gets smothered as Liam tears my panties. I suck harder and faster, making Noah’s hoarse groan sound far too loud. His eyes open, confused, but the moment they land on me, a filthy smile spreads across his mouth.
“Princess… fuck.”
“Is that good, Noah?” Liam asked, sliding two fingers into my pussy, which clenched around them, so sensitive I am. “Because Scarlett’s pussy is paradise—so soaked and tight.”
I moaned loud. Liam’s fingers drove deeper at the same time Noah made me take more of his cock. I rolled my eyes, desperate to come. I ground down on Liam’s fingers. A sharp slap landed on my ass, spiking my excitement even more.
“Liam…”
“Squeeze my fingers with your tight little pussy.” I got another slap.
“Scarlett, I’m close.” I stopped sucking Noah, and he scolded me with his eyes.
“I need you to fuck me, and I need it… now,” I moaned after I felt Liam’s tongue strike my clit from behind, his hands on my waist holding me still. “Oh, shit.”
“Come on my tongue,” he ordered, gripping my waist harder, not letting me escape his hungry mouth. The restrained arousal surged inside me, and when release hit, I came hard, screaming Liam’s name.
I didn’t have time to fall back onto the bed to steady my breathing. Noah pulled me into his lap, grabbing a condom from I don’t know where, sheathing his cock and sliding into me right after. The penetration was fast; as wet as I was, I wasn’t prepared to feel Noah’s cock inside me. Noah’s size hit exactly the right spot, making me close my eyes and surrender to the pleasure he’s giving me.
“Open your eyes. I want to see your eyes drunk on arousal when my brother makes you come.” It wasn’t a request. During sex, Liam doesn’t ask—he orders. “Noah, fuck Scarlett’s little pussy, no mercy. We’re going to let her feel us all day.” Liam’s words hit me hard—I love hearing his dirty mouth.
“I want both of you.”
“Scarlett, don’t tease, fuck.” Liam looked at the ceiling, murmuring something I couldn’t make out. “Do you know how gently we’ve been taking it with you since we met you?”
They’d been taking it gently?
“Ride, Scarlett. Fuck my cock with that tight little pussy.” I sped up my movements. Noah toyed with my hard nipples while Liam worked his cock, making my mouth water.
“Come on, Liam.” I bit my lower lip, my eyes locked on the motion of his hand. “Fuck me good. I want both of you inside me.”
“Fuck, Scarlett.”
“That’s right—I want your cum on my ass.”
Liam smiled, pulling a condom from the nightstand drawer and rolling it down his cock with no hurry at all, savoring my desperation to have him inside me. Noah withdrew, in a silent exchange with his brother that I didn’t understand. Liam tested my pussy, coating his fingers in my arousal and bringing them to the cleft of my ass. His fingers slid in slowly, sending a delicious shiver through my body. I love anal sex—the pleasure double penetration gives me is unlike anything else.
“Liam… I need…”
“Greedy to take two cocks?” I moaned the moment I felt two of Noah’s fingers push into my pussy. Liam and he worked me at the same time, another orgasm building.
“No. I’m eager to take your cocks.”
A hard slap landed on my ass. Noah pulled me, then drove into me with a single thrust. Liam positioned himself behind me, the tip of his cock testing how ready I was. I relaxed, giving consent for him to go deeper. The pleasure that flooded my body at feeling both of them inside me made me close my eyes and surrender to the pleasure and love they could give me.