Chapter 56: Nathan helps
She rushed over and yanked the door open but the hallway was empty. Only the long fluorescent glow and a flickering camera above.
She shut the door, locked it, and turned over the envelope.
No name.
Inside: printed photos.
A dead deer with its insides hollowed. A pair of muddy boots outside Maya and Calvin’s house. A still image from a security feed, Jesse and Nathan, shirtless, dragging what looked like a wrapped body by the lake.
But it was the last photo that made her stomach twist:
A blurry snap of a girl with dark hair Quinn? — at the mansion’s entrance. Next to Erika.
Sofia blinked. The timestamp was from that morning.
Attached was a post-it:
“She’s not who she says she is. Ask Veronika what she told you about twins.”
Sofia sat down slowly, hands trembling, the city lights casting sharp rectangles on the floor around her.
Who sent this? Julian? Someone else?
She stood up, her mind made. She had to go back. Tonight.
Back at the Mansion – Storage Room
Erika held Nathan’s hand, helping him climb from the hatch. She turned to Alina, who hadn’t said a word during the whole ordeal.
“Why did you help us?” Erika asked.
Alina brushed imaginary dust from her sleeves. “Because if you’re right… then we’re all in danger.”
“You haven’t told Jesse?”
Alina’s cold gaze flicked up. “No. But I will if I don’t like where this goes.”
Erika narrowed her eyes, then said, “Flyod found the tunnel. That’s all. He didn’t make it far.”
Alina didn’t reply, but Erika could feel the skepticism.
She continued anyway. “It leads under the annex. That means it was built as part of the original design this house is older than all of us.”
“We should leave before we’re caught,” Alina warned.
Erika was already walking. “This is my house too. I shared it with Jesse before you ever stepped foot here.”
They exited calmly, but the air had shifted a storm brewing behind polite smiles.
Mansion – Central Hallway
Jesse spotted them crossing the tiled hall, Erika, Alina, and Nathan. His mouth tightened.
“What are you doing?” he called, striding toward them.
Erika ignored him, walking the long hall until she reached the door. The one none of them had opened since the beginning. It stood oddly pristine untouched by dust or fingerprints.
She turned to Craig’s panel on the wall.
“Craig,” she said, “open this door.”
The interface blinked. Then:
“ACCESS DENIED. RESTRICTED.”
Jesse stepped closer. “That one’s always been sealed. No one has the code. Not even me.”
“Is that true?” Erika asked, still not looking at him.
“Yes.”
She walked past him then, circling toward the glass walls near the pool. Alina followed at a distance.
“What are you looking for?” Jesse asked.
“Proof,” Erika said, not slowing.
Upstairs
Nathan moved quietly through the house. A creak of wood. A flutter of curtain.
Then—
Quinn.
She stepped from a room, hair brushed, lips slightly parted a new confidence in her body.
He blinked.
“You look… different,” he said.
She smirked. “New day. New skin.”
There was something predatory in her gaze. She stepped closer, almost brushing his arm. “You keep watching me. Do you want something?”
Nathan stared but said nothing. Instead, his eyes moved upward… toward the ceiling.
That fight. The moment the twins fell.
His instincts screamed that something wasn’t right.
Back Downstairs
Erika stepped under the ceiling where Quinn and Molly had once fought. She tilted her head.
Nathan joined her. Then Quinn. Then Jesse and Alina.
Erika turned slowly and faced Quinn.
“You never said what happened up there. When you fought… Quinn.”
Quinn’s face froze.
“What was above that room?” Erika pressed.
No answer.
Quinn’s hands clenched slightly.
“I want to pull down the attic ladder,” Erika said, stepping toward it.
Jesse’s arm shot out, grabbing her by the wrist, tight.
“Don’t,” he said. “Unless you want to explain what you found.”
Erika didn’t flinch.
“I will. Maya and Calvin had an underground hallway under their home. It leads here. That’s how someone’s been moving around.”
She studied each face.
“I used it. So could anyone else.”
They all went silent.
Except Alina.
She rolled her eyes. Cold. Almost bored. But Erika remembered, she already knew.
And that made Erika even more suspicious.
Erika stood beneath the slanted ceiling, gaze lifted to the untouched attic door, her voice low but firm.
"Something’s going on in this house. And I’m going to find out what."
Jesse stepped forward and shoved her not hard, but enough to provoke.
“You’re paranoid,” he spat. “You always were.”
Nathan moved instantly, stepping between them. “Back off.”
Jesse’s stare darkened. “You won’t dare. You’re supposed to be on my side.”
They stood toe-to-toe.
Then Jesse rage flaring grabbed a nearby paperweight and hurled it at Nathan, barely missing his shoulder.
“How dare you!” he roared.
Nathan kept his calm, his jaw clenching. But when Jesse lunged for him, fist raised, Nathan didn’t hold back this time. He tackled him with full weight, and the two of them crashed into the corner table, sending papers flying.
“Stop!” Quinn yelled from across the room, watching helplessly.
While the chaos distracted them, she darted toward the attic ladder, seized the moment, and pulled it down. The stairs creaked loudly as she began climbing.
“Quinn, no!” Alina shouted, moving toward her.
But Quinn was already halfway up.
Nathan broke free from Jesse’s grip and sprinted after her, calling out, “Wait—Erika—don’t go alone!”
But it was too late. Erika had already slipped into the attic.
The air above was stale, thick with dust and time. The narrow space stretched out into a claustrophobic crawlway lined with beams and dark crevices. Erika moved slowly, careful not to place her feet on any weak boards. She spotted the jagged hole in the floor — the very spot where Molly had fallen to her death.
She swallowed hard and inched forward.
A sound.
Breathing?
No. Watching.
From the left, a faint creak.
She turned her head.
A small door. Barely visible behind a support beam.
And behind it… an eye.
Wide. Staring directly at her.
Then—gone.
“Wait!” Erika shouted, crawling faster toward the door.
But as she shifted her weight, her foot slammed through another rotted plank, she slipped, her legs dangling above the broken wooden banister below where Molly had fallen.
“Shit—!” she cried out, scrambling for anything to grip.
The support beam creaked again under her.
“Erika!” Nathan’s voice echoed as he scrambled up the stairs.
She was slipping.
A second more—
and then Nathan’s strong arms grabbed her around the waist and yanked her up just as the beam collapsed beneath her.
Erika fell into his chest, breathing hard. Her fingers trembled.
“There was… someone up here,” she said, her voice shaking. “I swear, I saw”
“Time to get down,” Nathan said. “Now.”