Chapter 57: Sofia is back

Downstairs, Jesse was wiping blood from his lip, eyes wild. He turned to Quinn, trying to compose himself.

“We move forward now. No more delays.”

Alina stood near the window, her breath catching as she saw a familiar dark vehicle pulling up.

“Oh, my God…” she whispered. “She’s here.”

Everyone froze.

Sofia’s car slowed at the edge of the property.

Quinn descended the attic stairs, her hands tight around the binder Jesse had given her. Her face is calm. Her voice is like cold water.

“I signed the papers,” she said, looking directly at Jesse. “I’m your fiancée now, right?”

Erika was halfway down the stairs, pausing when she heard Quinn’s voice.

Something in her shifted.

“What are you two up to…?” she murmured.

The doorbell rang.

Jesse exhaled deeply and walked to the foyer, smoothing his shirt. Alina rushed to move the ladder and shut the attic before Sofia could see it.

Quinn adjusted her blouse, brushing off dust from her escape.

Nathan wiped his face, still flushed from the fight.

And Erika?

She stood frozen halfway down the stairs, eyes burning into Quinn, her mind a clockwork of suspicions.

Sofia stepped through the door, sunglasses still on, crisp and composed, a phone in her hand and a satchel slung over her shoulder.

Her eyes scanned the faces.

Quinn. Jesse. Alina. Nathan. And finally, Erika, coming down behind them.

Sofia removed her glasses slowly.

“Surprised to see me?”

No one spoke.

Not yet.

Sofia Blackwood stood just inside the foyer, her sunglasses folded in one hand, her phone buzzing in the other. She looked every bit the woman in control calm, sharp, unreadable. But the air around her was different this time. Heavier.

Everyone stood still.

“Where’s Floyd?” she asked casually, brushing imaginary dust from her black tailored coat.

Jesse shifted beside Quinn. His voice cracked slightly. “He left. Said he needed a break.”

“Oh?” Sofia said. Her voice didn’t rise, but it didn’t need to. “Because I received a voicemail. From Floyd. About bodies, strange movements, and you, Jesse.”

Jesse blinked.

Alina stiffened.

Sofia turned to the group slowly, then raised her phone and tapped the screen. An image blinked to life — grainy footage of Jesse and Nathan dragging something heavy through the brush near the lake.

“You thought there were no cameras outside the property?”

Erika leaned silently against the banister. For once, she didn’t rush to Jesse’s defense. She crossed her arms instead, watching as Jesse floundered.

“Listen, Sofia,” he said, holding up his hands, “It’s not what it looks like.”

“It never is with you.” She tucked the phone away.

Then her gaze turned to Quinn.

The girl stood steady but behind her composed posture was a storm of nerves. Still, she didn’t flinch.

Sofia stepped closer, eyes narrowing. “You’re not Molly.”

Quinn’s lips parted, barely.

The room froze.

Nathan glanced at Erika, who remained impassive.

But then Sofia’s expression softened not out of ignorance, but decision. “You’re not Molly. But I trust you more than the rest of them.”

Jesse’s head snapped toward her. “What?”

“I’ve known for a while,” Sofia added, circling the group like a lioness. “When Floyd went missing, when Erika grew cold… something in this house changed. You’re playing your sister, aren’t you?”

Quinn said nothing.

“I’m not here to accuse,” Sofia continued. “I broke the rules by coming early. The final phase isn’t until tomorrow. But after what I received… I needed to see this place.”

Her voice dropped.

“See you.”

Alina looked away, nervous.

Sofia glanced at Erika. “And you — you said nothing.”

Erika met her stare. “I didn’t trust anyone. I still don’t.”

Sofia nodded once, as if that was enough to answer enough.

Then she walked further into the living room and faced them all.

“This is the last phase,” she announced. “I’ll be back in five days. Results will be delivered. Until then, the rules stay. No outside calls. No guests. No lies” she glanced directly at Jesse, “—or at least not sloppy ones.”

Then Quinn, quiet until now, stepped forward.

“There’s something you should know,” she said calmly.

Everyone turned.

Quinn reached into the folder Jesse had given her, the one with the agreement, Gary’s signatures, the old will.

“Gary’s inheritance included this entire estate, and an offshore account. But the catch…” she let the silence build, “...was that the one who becomes his heir must be engaged before the final evaluation.”

Sofia raised an eyebrow.

“I’ve signed the contract,” Quinn said. “As Jesse’s fiancée.”

Jesse swallowed hard, watching her unsure now if she’d just helped him or set the trap.

Quinn turned to Sofia. “I thought it was about survival. About honesty. Turns out it was always about position. You want heirs? Now you have one.”

The air shifted. Even Erika blinked.

Alina let out the faintest gasp.

Sofia didn’t speak immediately. She moved to the window, staring out over the property.

Then, with her back to them, she said quietly:

“Then may the best one win.”

She turned on her heel and walked toward the door.

“I’ll be back in five days. I suggest you all stay… alive.”

And with that, Sofia was gone.

As Sofia’s car rumbled down the gravel road, a sharp tension lingered in the mansion like a fog. The heavy silence cracked like glass as Erika stormed past the main hallway, her boots slapping the tiled floor. Nathan called after her but she didn’t stop.

By the time he caught up, she was already slamming the annex door behind her.

“Erika,” he said, breathless.

She whirled around. “You want to defend Jesse again? Go ahead. But do it without me this time.”

Nathan closed the door. “It’s not like that—”

“Oh, it is. You follow him like a loyal dog, Nathan. Even after Floyd, after the lies, after everything—”

Nathan’s face hardened. “And what? You think you're the saint of this house?”

Erika’s eyes burned. “At least I’m not complicit in burying bodies.”

Silence. The word hung between them like smoke.

“I trusted you,” she whispered. “And you chose him.”

Nathan moved closer, voice sharp. “Because he didn’t treat me like I was disposable. Like I was some shadow you could use when you felt like it.”

Erika stiffened. “Is that what you think this was?”

“No,” he snapped. “That’s what you made it.”

They stood there, breaths jagged, neither saying what needed to be said. Then Nathan turned away, grabbed his jacket.

“I’m going for a walk,” he muttered.

The door slammed behind him.