Chapter 55: Clues
The walls grew tighter, the path zig-zagging through stone and dirt, and finally, after a left turn, a cavern opened before her.
Graffiti on the walls. Carved marks. Numbers dozens, hundreds. Days counted. Someone had been trapped here.
Her flashlight froze over a shape.
A skeleton. Curled in on itself.
She fell to her knees, tablet shaking in her hands.
“Craig,” she whispered, “who is this?”
A pause.
“Identity: Chloe Raines. Deceased.”
Erika couldn’t breathe.
Then Craig’s voice echoed again, this time oddly calm. “You have arrived.”
“What?” she blinked, heart pounding. “Where did you arrive?”
“You are directly below your annex,” Craig said. “This is part of the main property’s underground structure.”
Erika looked up. A trapdoor overhead.
“Someone was using this to move through the estate,” she whispered.
Then a sound. Behind her.
A pipe groaned. Something shifted.
Erika dropped the tablet. It cracked, the screen flickering. She scrambled to recover it, thumbs tapping, sending images to her email. Her fingers moved fast, her battery low. 5%.
She turned toward the sound.
Footsteps.
“Who’s there?!” she screamed, voice hoarse.
The flashlight began to die. She switched to her tablet screen, its glow weak but enough.
Then light.
From ahead. Bright and golden.
“Nathan?”
He stood at the mouth of the passage, sweat on his brow.
She ran to him. Nearly collapsed in his arms.
He held her tight. “What were you doing?”
“There’s a path,” she gasped. “A secret path. And someone else is down here. I swear it.
The Walls Whisper Back
The scent of damp stone still clung to Erika’s skin as she leaned against the wall of the secret cavern, eyes locked on Nathan’s face.
She held the cracked tablet in her hands, displaying Chloe Raines’ scanned remains. Her voice trembled, but it was low and certain.
“She died here, Nathan,” Erika said. “And Craig identified her. The maid. Chloe.”
Nathan, still sweating from the scramble down the tunnel, stared at the bones. The numbers etched into the stone around them. The stale air. The truth.
“I... I didn’t know,” he said finally, his voice hollow.
“No one did,” Erika replied. “But someone wanted it that way.”
He shifted, uncomfortable. “Maybe we shouldn’t be here.”
She turned on him. “Nathan. It’s now or never. Don’t play dumb.”
Her eyes didn’t blink.
“Flyod’s gone. Chloe’s body was hidden. And that tunnel leads directly to my annex. Someone’s been using it.”
Nathan’s face crumbled under her gaze. He swallowed hard and finally gave a small nod.
“Let’s go back in,” Erika whispered.
With his torch leading the way, they descended once more into the shadows.
Upstairs – Jesse’s Room
The golden light filtered through the curtains. The air inside was warm, scented faintly with cologne and leather-bound ambition.
Quinn sat on the edge of the bed, the binder still unopened. Her fingers rested on the pen Jesse had handed her. But her gaze wasn’t on the document. It was in the mirror.
Dark hair. Wrong shoes. Wrong posture.
She was slipping into her sister’s skin, but it no longer felt like a disguise, it was a cage.
Jesse stood a few feet away, watching her carefully. Patiently. Like a chess player studying his opponent.
“You don’t need to sign now,” he said. “But think about it. We’d be invincible together.”
She didn’t respond. Just stared at her reflection.
Then he added, “I know you’re not Molly.”
Her breath caught.
He smiled faintly. “The hair gave it away. Too dark. And your mouth, it moves differently when you lie.”
She turned slowly.
“Then why keep me here?”
“Because you’re useful. You confuse them, Alina, Sofia, even Erika. And because… you want this too.”
He stepped closer. “You want power. Control. Safety.”
She finally looked up at him, eyes guarded.
“And what if I ask for something else?” she said quietly.
“Anything.”
“I want to stay dark-haired,” she said first. “If I bleach it again, I’ll lose myself.”
Jesse nodded. “Fine. But you stay out of Erika’s way. And Sofia’s, if she comes. We need to finish the paperwork before anyone gets smart.”
She hesitated again, pen still untouched. Then, softly:
“What if… I like someone else?”
Jesse blinked. “What?”
“I think I’m attracted to Nathan,” she said carefully, studying Jesse’s reaction. “Would that be… a problem?”
He stared at her. Long and hard. Then, to her surprise, he smiled.
“You’re human,” he said. “And strategic. Just don’t get distracted. Nathan’s good-looking, sure but we’re the ones holding the pen.”
He placed a hand on her shoulder. “Sign when you’re ready.”
And then he left her alone.
Beneath the Mansion – The Cavern
Nathan lit the way forward with the dying flashlight as they reached the final stretch.
At the cavern’s end, Erika stopped beneath the hatch. She stared up. The ceiling was closer than she remembered.
“I think this is the exit.”
Nathan knelt down. “Climb.”
With her feet on his shoulders, Erika reached up and twisted the latch and this time, to her surprise, the door gave in easily.
Too easily.
Someone’s been using this, she thought.
She pushed up and emerged in—
The storage room.
Just a thin wall from her annex. Her heart pounded.
She looked back down. “I can’t pull you up,” she told Nathan. “You’re too heavy—"
“Erika?” a voice cut through the silence.
She turned fast. Alina stood at the door, arms crossed.
“What are you doing here?” Alina asked coldly.
Erika froze.
Alina’s eyes flicked between the storage room and the open hatch in the floor.
“Looking for snacks?” she added sarcastically.
They stared at each other, tension as thick as the dust in the walls.
Before Erika could answer, Nathan’s voice echoed from below.
“Erika! Someone’s down here—”
She looked at Alina. Her choice.
“I need to pull him up,” Erika said.
Alina hesitated. Then took a slow step forward.
Her next move... would decide whose side she was really on.
Sofia stood barefoot in her apartment, the faint hum of the fridge the only sound in the quiet. She’d tried calling Flyod again no answer. The last message he’d sent was cryptic: “Bodies… watching… they know.” Then radio silence.
She stared out the window at the skyline, arms crossed. Something wasn’t right.
A soft rustle pulled her from her thoughts.
She turned.
An envelope… slid silently under her door.