Chapter 54: Underground Passage

Nathan narrowed his eyes. “Why bring this up now?”

“Because I think Chloe never left this property,” Erika said. “Because I think she’s still here, Nathan or what’s left of her is. Floyd noticed the same thing. And I remember... during that dinner, when Maya poured that wine, she kept glancing at the far hallway. There was a door behind that tapestry. She was hiding something. Something she knew we couldn’t see.”

Nathan looked away, but Erika stepped into his space. “And if Sofia finds out first? If she gets here tomorrow and finds the body before we do... What do you think will happen next?”

“You think I buried Chloe?” he said, quietly.

“I don’t know who did it,” Erika answered. “But I’m not looking away anymore.”

Nathan placed the cup down with more force than needed. “You want to play the hero now, Erika? After everything?”

“No,” she said. “I want to survive.”

Silence fell again.

Then Erika added, “I’m going to Calvin and Maya’s tonight. I’m going to find that door.”

“No,” Nathan snapped. “You’re not.”

She raised an eyebrow. “You planning to stop me?”

His mouth opened, but she cut him off before he could speak. “If Sofia shows up and I’ve done nothing, you and Jesse are the ones who burn. And maybe I go with you. Or maybe I walk away with the truth and leave you both to rot.”

Nathan was breathing harder now, and Erika could see the muscles in his shoulders tense like he was preparing for a fight.

But he said nothing more.

She turned on her heel and walked out, her face unreadable.

Upstairs in the Mansion

Alina moved like a whisper through the hallway, holding a small tray of sliced apples and tea.

She stopped at the room where the surviving twin slept or pretended to. The girl had been quiet all day, eyes fluttering open only for seconds at a time. But Alina wasn’t fooled.

She slipped the door open just enough to step inside, then set the tray on the table. The girl Molly, or Quinn didn’t flinch. Still playing the part.

Alina pulled up a chair and sat by the bed, her voice as soft as a lullaby.

“I brought you something to eat. You haven’t had anything since yesterday.”

No answer.

Alina leaned forward and reached toward the teacup... and knocked it slightly off balance. It wobbled, nearly falling until the girl’s hand shot out to catch it.

Quick. Coordinated.

Not sedated at all.

“Gotcha,” Alina whispered with a smile.

The girl froze.

Alina placed the teacup back and leaned in, her voice low and conspiratorial.

“You’re good... really good. But Molly flinched when she heard thunder. You didn’t. And I’ve been watching that tattoo spot on your back all day, sweetheart.”

Still no response.

Alina stood and walked to the door, pausing before she exited.

“I don’t care if you’re Molly or Quinn,” she said. “But if you’re going to play your sister, at least try harder.”

She closed the door behind her, leaving Quinn alone.

The teacup trembled in Quinn’s hand now, but not from fear. From rage.

The sun blazed high over the hills, but within the estate walls, the air was heavy, suffocating with secrets. Noon fell silently over the grounds as Erika stepped out of the annex. Her ponytail swayed behind her, her steps firm and pointed. Nathan saw her through the glass, his hand clutching the curtain, but he said nothing. He knew that look in her eyes resolve mixed with fury. He didn’t dare stop her.

Jesse, watching from the mansion balcony, noticed too. His eyes narrowed as Erika walked down the dirt path toward the quiet house that once belonged to Calvin and Maya. His hands clenched the railing.

Inside, Quinn sat at Molly’s vanity, brushing her dark hair, the morning light catching the split ends she hadn’t bothered to trim in months. Her reflection stared back at her not Molly, but someone in between. Someone who could still run. But wouldn’t.

She slid open the drawer. Inside: rows of dainty heels, all whites, beiges, soft colors. Molly's favorites. She frowned. She hated heels. Preferred boots, or sneakers. Always had.

The door opened behind her.

Jesse entered, something tense in his jaw. He tossed a thick binder onto the desk beside her with a dull thud. Then, wordlessly, he held out a pen.

Quinn turned slightly. “What’s this?”

He didn’t blink. “A contract. A partnership.”

She laughed softly, but Jesse didn’t move.

He went on. “You sign it we’re engaged. Publicly. That way, you take half of my share of the inheritance. Together, we own almost everything.”

She stared at him, the pen hovering between her fingers.

Then he said it.

“But to seal it… we need to get rid of Erika. She’s dangerous now. Obsessed. She’s onto something.”

Quinn’s blood chilled.

“You’re asking me to kill your sister?” she said slowly, as if testing the words aloud.

He leaned closer. “She’ll get you first, Quinn. She’s smart. She’ll find out who you are.”

The pen felt heavy. Tempting. She held it over the paper. Then paused.

Calvin and Maya’s House

Erika moved with care.

Every inch of the house was eerily spotless. Too clean.

She scanned the room with the tablet she’d stolen or rather, borrowed from Jesse’s storage. Craig’s voice echoed faintly through the speaker, polite and eerily emotionless.

“Recognizing structure… Scanning…”

“Was this house connected to the annex?” Erika asked, voice hushed.

“Yes,” Craig confirmed. “Underground extensions are present.”

She slowed when she saw the photo a large framed image of Calvin, Maya, Gary, and Veronika. All smiles. All carefully arranged. Something about it screamed cover-up.

“Craig. Focus on this wall. Anything unusual?”

A pause. Then: “Irregular density detected. Hollow cavity.”

Erika’s hand trembled as she reached for the edges of the frame. Nothing. She knocked a thud, like wood over a void.

She raced to the kitchen, grabbed a flat metal tray, and jammed it into the wall seam. A click.

The panel gave way.

Behind it a narrow passage, the air thick and cold.

She raised her flashlight and entered.