Chapter 22: Below
Jonas Hale
The moment the lantern shatters, the dark swallows everything.
Glass explodes against the floor, scattering like ice across the metal landing. The sound echoes up the stairwell, swallowed instantly by the suffocating black. For a fraction of a second, sparks flare—brief, frantic—then die. And in that silence, in that wild, breathless absence of light, I feel the lighthouse shift. Not the stone, not the metal—something deeper. As if the dark itself has weight now, filling the air like thick fog, pressing against my skin.
I can’t see.
I can barely breathe.
And Eveline is trapped on the other side of that door.
“Eveline!” I reach blindly, my hand closing around the icy railing.
No response.
My heartbeat punches inside my chest, the pulse loud enough that it drowns the storm outside. I force my feet to move, to find the next step, despite the blind vertigo of darkness. The cold is so sharp it burns, a biting edge that eats into my lungs with every breath.
Then—
A whisper.
Soft as breath on glass.
“…Jonas…”
Not hers.
Not mine.
Something in between.
That unnatural, careful imitation.
My skin crawls violently.
“I know you can hear me,” I rasp, my voice hoarse with panic and frost. “You stay away from her.”
The stairwell absorbs my words like they never existed.
Lightning flickers somewhere beyond the lighthouse windows, but it barely reaches this far. Only the faintest ghost of light bleeds through the gaps in the metal, enough to outline the railing in a thin silver line. My eyes strain, aching for anything more.
I step toward the lantern-room door.
One step.
Another.
The cold intensifies—like walking toward the open mouth of winter.
“Eveline?” My voice cracks. “Say something. Please.”
A breath, faint and broken, reaches me from the other side.
“…I’m here.”
Relief slams into me with such force my knees nearly buckle. I press my palm to the door—then yank it back instantly. Pain shoots through my hand. The metal is so cold it feels almost molten in reverse, like touching dry ice.
“Don’t move,” I whisper fiercely. “I’m getting you out.”
The shadows beyond the frost-rimmed seam shift. The hair on the back of my neck rises.
Something is in the room with her.
Something that mimicked her voice.
Something that mimicked mine.
Something that wants me close.
I force myself not to think about what it looks like.
Not to imagine the shape I glimpsed for only a heartbeat earlier, bent and patient like a figure waiting in an interrogator’s corner.
Lightning flashes again—brighter this time—and for that fraction of a second, the thin line of space beneath the door flickers bright.
I see movement.
A limb?
A shadow?
Something pale and long?
It exists only for that split instant, but it’s enough to turn my stomach inside out.
I brace my shoulder against the door.
Something moves on the other side, matching my movement perfectly.
Too perfectly.
Mirroring.
Like it’s studying the way a human prepares to force a barrier.
“Jonas…”
My name again, but this time the voice is neither mine nor Eveline’s. Something new. Somewhere in the uncanny valley between mimicry and self-discovery.
I grit my teeth.
“You won’t touch her.”
Then—Eveline’s voice:
“Jonas—it’s not looking at me. It’s waiting for you.”
A cold worse than winter knifes through me.
Fear is instinctive.
This is something deeper.
Something primal.
Something that bypasses everything rational and roots itself straight into survival memory.
“What do you mean it’s waiting for me?” I ask, fighting to keep my voice steady.
A small sound escapes her—somewhere between a breath and a sob.
“It hasn’t moved since the lights went out. I can feel it. Standing in the corner, facing the wall. Like it’s listening.”
Listening.
For me.
A crackling sound splits from the other side—ice breaking, or bone shifting, or wood freezing in place. The frost on the door spreads again, crawling toward the hinges.
I slam my shoulder into the door. The shock of cold jolts through me hard enough to make my teeth clench.
“Step away from it!” I shout. “Get as far from it as you can!”
“No,” she gasps. “I can’t—not without it hearing me move. Jonas—I can’t risk that.”
The door trembles beneath my hand.
Not from me.
From something pressing gently, experimentally, against it.
I force myself to breathe.
“Okay,” I whisper. “Walk me through what you see.”
Another pause.
But not long enough to be hesitation.
Long enough to be fear.
“…Jonas,” she whispers, “it’s turning.”
My breath stops.
“What?”
“It’s… turning toward the door.”
A brittle crack echoes through the wood—sharp enough that I flinch.
Glass falls inside the room—something knocked over.
“Eveline!” I slam the door again. “Move! Get away from—”
A whisper interrupts me—smooth, controlled, eerily calm.
“Jonas.”
Not Eveline.
Not me.
A voice with too many tones layered into it.
As if learning how vocal cords work in real time.
Something slides across the floor inside the room. A long, dragging sound. Too light to be footsteps. Too heavy to be anything small.
“Open the door,” the voice murmurs.
I nearly break it.
But Eveline’s scream snaps me back.
“Don’t open it! Jonas—DON’T—”
The thing speaks over her.
“She wants you to.”
“No I DON’T!” Eveline sobs.
I step back, my pulse a violent drum inside my ears.
The thing seems amused.
“Jonas… open the door.”
“Go to hell,” I growl.
Lightning tears across the sky again, flooding the stairwell in white.
And in that instant—
I see a hand through the seam.
Thin.
Long.
Skin stretched too tight.
Blue veins glowing like cracks in ice.
Fingers that move like they’re remembering how joints should bend.
The breath leaves my body.
My brain flashes with one primal command:
Run.
But Eveline is in that room.
And it’s turned toward her.
I plant my feet.
“Eveline,” I say through gritted teeth, “I’m breaking this door down. Tell me exactly where the thing is standing.”
Her breath shudders in the dark.
“The right corner. Closest to the window.”
“Is it close to you?”
“I…” A trembling swallow. “It’s about six feet away.”
“How big is it?”
Another pause.
Too long.
“Eveline?”
Her voice is faint.
“I don’t know. It’s… wrong. Like its height keeps changing when it moves.”
My jaw tightens. “Okay. When I say move, you—”
The thing speaks in my voice.
Perfect.
“Move.”
Eveline screams.
“THAT’S NOT ME!” I roar.
Something slams the inside of the room—hard enough that the vibration shudders through the door and into my spine.
I grab the handle.
It bites into my skin.
A freezing shock that shoots up my arm.
The frost keeps spreading.
I pull anyway.
The metal burns me raw.
Outside, the storm growls harder, waves smashing the cliffs. But the cold inside the lighthouse is a different kind. A suffocating cold. A deliberate cold.
“Eveline,” I whisper, forcing my own panic down deep, “tell me where you are.”
“…I’m near the shelves. The old navigation charts. I—Jonas, I think I can reach the emergency flare—”
“DO IT.”
A soft, wet sound moves across the floor.
Something dragging closer to her.
“No,” she whispers, horror leaking into her voice. “It heard me.”
My lungs seize.
“Don’t move. Do you hear me? Don’t.”
A sound like cracking knuckles echoes softly.
But too many joints.
Too many cracks.
Then—slow, deliberate exhale from the other side of the door.
Not breathing.
Imitating breathing.
Lightning flashes.
The shadow through the seam shifts.
It’s closer.
Too close.
“Jonas…” the thing whispers. “We’re waiting.”
Not I.
Not she.
We.
My stomach drops.
“Eveline.” My voice barely works. “It’s learned to use plural.”
Another sound—something like fabric stretching—rises in the room. The temperature drops again, so severe that frost slithers across the floor under my boots.
I throw myself against the door.
It shudders.
But doesn’t open.
The thing hisses—not angry, but curious.
“Why do you hit the wall?”
My voice.
Bent wrong.
“I swear to God,” I whisper, “if you hurt her—”
A slow chuckle.
Bones in a blender.
I slam the door again.
Then again.
The hinges crack.
The frost splits.
The wood groans.
I can do this.
I will do this.
“Eveline! If you can hear me—cover your head!”
I step back, brace myself, and—
“Jonas.”
This time, the voice is hers.
Perfect.
Cold.
Empty.
“I’m fine. You can stop.”
Every cell in my body recoils.
“That’s not her,” I whisper.
A scraping sound inside—like something standing, straightening its spine inch by inch. Slowly. Deliberately.
Becoming taller.
Lightning flares again.
In the seam beneath the door, I see—
A foot.
Bare.
Human-like.
But wrong.
Too pale.
Toes too long.
Skin stretched taut like thawing ice.
I slam the door with every ounce of strength I have, roaring from the bottom of my lungs—
“GET AWAY FROM HER!”
The wood finally splits. The top hinge screams. The door shifts inward.
“Jonas!” Eveline cries—her real voice this time—high and thin and terrified.
I slam the door one last time and it bursts inward.
The cold hits me like a wall.
The room is almost unrecognizable—frost crawling across the windows, books coated in white, the air shimmering like frozen fog.
Eveline is pressed against the far wall, hands braced behind her, eyes huge with terror. Her breath fogs in rapid, panicked bursts.
And standing between us—
The thing.
For a second, I can’t understand what I’m looking at.
It’s tall—too tall.
Shoulders hunched as if it hasn’t learned how to stand upright yet.
Its skin is colorless, stretched thin around long bones.
Its head is turned slightly—as if listening—though I can’t see its eyes.
It stands facing the far wall.
Just like she said.
But its neck twists, vertebrae snapping like icy twigs, turning toward me even though its body doesn’t move.
A slow, unnatural rotation.
One degree at a time.
Crack.
Crack.
Crack.
Until its head is fully turned, staring at me with a face that is almost human—almost—but stretched, unfinished, features forming and unforming under the frost.
Its lips move.
Too many teeth pressing beneath thin skin.
“Jonas,” it whispers.
My voice.
Perfectly.
Eveline shakes her head violently. “Don’t come closer!”
But the thing shifts—its body creaking like thawing ice—taking one long, testing step toward her. Its limbs move out of sync, like it’s learning anatomy as it goes.
I move without thinking.
“HEY!” I shout, grabbing the nearest heavy object—a rusted storm lantern—and hurl it.
It hits the creature squarely in the shoulder.
The lantern shatters.
The creature doesn’t flinch.
Instead, it turns its head back to the wall—like the blow never happened—then resumes turning its body one careful joint at a time until it faces me fully.
And then—
It smiles.
Not human.
Not animal.
Something in between.
A smile made of recognition it should not be capable of.
Eveline screams my name.
And the creature moves—
Faster than anything that tall should move.
Faster than anything should move in this cold.
It lunges for her.
I don’t think.
I don’t breathe.
I throw myself across the room and collide with it mid-motion.
It’s like slamming into frozen stone.
The impact knocks the air from my lungs. My shoulder explodes with pain. The creature skids back, not from my strength but from the surprise of being touched.
Its head jerks toward me in a broken whip motion.
Crack.
“Jonas…” it sighs.
I stagger to my feet, grabbing Eveline and dragging her behind me.
The creature crouches.
Like an animal preparing to spring.
My heart is a thunderstorm.
“Run,” I whisper to her.
“Jonas—”
“RUN!”
She bolts for the door.
The creature lunges.
I grab its arm.
My hand burns with cold so vicious it feels like knives.
The thing twists, its limb rotating far too many degrees, but I don’t let go.
“GO!” I roar.
Eveline disappears into the stairwell.
The creature opens its mouth—
Too wide.
And the sound that comes out is not mine, not hers, not human.
A scream made of wind and ice and something ancient, something hungry.
It throws me backward with the force.
I slam into the wall so hard my vision explodes with white.
The creature surges past me—going after Eveline.
“No—NO—” I choke, clawing at the icy floor, forcing my body to move despite the cold tearing into my muscles.
I launch myself forward—
Just as the creature reaches the stairwell.
Eveline is already halfway down, sprinting into the dark.
The thing pauses at the top step.
Its head turns back toward me.
Slowly.
Deliberately.
Its lips pull back in another impossible smile.
“Run,” it whispers.
Using my voice.
Mocking me.
Then it begins descending the stairs after her.
And I go after it.
Blind.
Frozen.
Terrified.
But unstoppable.
Because fear is nothing compared to losing Eveline.
And I will tear this thing apart with my bare hands before I let it touch her.