Chapter 23: Don't Trust the Man You're With
Eveline Shore
First-Person POV
Darkness doesn’t fall.
It floods.
It pours through the shattered lantern like a living tide, swallowing the room in a single, suffocating rush. Every surface, every corner, every hint of shape disappears under an avalanche of black so thick it presses against my eyes. My breath catches. My hands claw instinctively at the floorboards as if I could anchor myself to something solid, but it’s impossible to tell where the room ends and the dark begins. It’s everywhere—inside the walls, inside my lungs, inside the pounding ache behind my ribs.
Somewhere beyond the door Jonas is slamming his full weight into the frame.
Somewhere.
His voice sounds like it’s coming from the bottom of the ocean.
“EVELINE! Step away from the door—do you hear me?!”
I open my mouth to answer, but my voice breaks before it crosses the air. My throat feels wrapped in cold wires, every word tangled and dragged down by the weight of this impossible dark.
“I’m trying!” I choke out. “Jonas—I—”
A breath touches my ear.
I freeze so hard my bones ache.
The breath is cold. Not winter cold. Not storm cold.
Dead cold—sharp and thin, threaded with something unnatural. Something that slides beneath my skin like a whispering current.
I turn my head slowly, barely daring to breathe.
Nothing is there.
But the cold moves with me.
Following.
Shadowing my motion with a presence I cannot see but can feel like a phantom hand pressed against my spine.
I’m not alone.
Not even close.
I stagger backward, searching blindly for any barrier between me and the thing breathing behind me, but the darkness thickens, swallowing my movement. My back hits something—smooth, hard, unyielding. I push against it in panic, thinking it’s the wall, thinking I can retreat—
It moves.
A shape straightens behind me, tall and terrible, unfolding like a figure unpeeling itself from the dark. The movement is too fluid. Too slow. Too wrong.
A strangled sound bursts from my throat. I lurch forward, almost falling. My hands slap against cold wood—
the railing near the lantern window.
I cling to it like a lifeline.
“EVELINE!” Jonas’s voice tears through the crack under the door. “TALK TO ME!”
“I—I’m here!” I cry, voice shaking so hard the words almost crumble. “Jonas, it’s behind me—”
Something touches my ankle.
A single fingertip.
Cold as dry ice.
Cold enough to burn.
I jerk upward so violently I crash to my knees. My palms slam the floor and a shock of icy pain bolts up my arms. Frost blooms outward from my skin, veining across the boards in delicate, deadly lines.
My breath stutters out in a sob. “Jonas, PLEASE!”
His reply is swallowed by the thickening dark—as if the room itself is pulling the sound apart. I can hear him. But faintly. Wrongly. Like he’s shouting through a tunnel that keeps stretching farther away.
The thing near me whispers again.
A voice soft as warm breath.
A voice that should be impossible.
“Eveline…”
Silas’s voice.
My lungs collapse.
No.
No, it can’t—
It can’t be him.
But the whisper moves closer, curling around my ear, coaxing, calm, familiar.
“Eveline… don’t be afraid.”
Tears well instantly—hot and disbelieving, cutting through the cold. “Why—why do you sound like him? Stop. Please—stop—”
“It’s me,” it says gently. “I’m here.”
My chest cracks with grief so fierce it almost knocks the air from my lungs. Silas. My brother. My heart. My regret. My shame. The voice pulls at every wound I’ve buried, every moment I wished I could undo.
I want to believe it.
I want to run to it.
But the cold creeping from the fingers on my ankle is wrong.
Wrong.
Wrong.
Silas’s hand was always warm.
The grip tightens around my ankle—just slightly, just enough to make my breath stutter.
Not Silas.
Not even close.
A sob escapes me.
“LET GO OF HER!” Jonas roars from the hall, slamming into the door with enough force to shake frost from the hinges. “EVELINE! GET AWAY FROM IT!”
I try. I really try. I dig my nails into the floorboards, pulling, dragging myself forward, but the cold climbs my calf, my knee, my thigh—moving like liquid winter, crawling up my bones.
The whisper shifts.
Silas’s voice melts away.
Something older replaces it.
Deeper.
Layered.
Like multiple voices speaking at once, stacked in discordant echoes.
“You are running out of time…”
I try to scream, but my voice catches in my throat. The cold wraps my ribs, squeezing until my breath shatters into broken gasps.
“Eveline…”
The layered voice drips into my ears like molten ice.
“…don’t fight it. He wants you to follow.”
“Silas is dead,” I whisper, barely audible. “He’s—he’s gone…”
Silence follows.
A silence that feels like a held breath.
Then—
“No…
he’s calling you.”
The dark thickens. I choke on it. Panic claws through my chest.
Jonas slams the door hard enough to crack wood. “EVELINE HOLD ON! I’M COMING—DON’T LET GO!”
But the cold surges upward, gripping my shoulders, crawling into my hairline, seeping into the roots. My skin burns with numbness.
The whisper leans closer. I can feel it smiling without a face.
“Follow him. Follow him down.”
Something in me snaps.
“No!” I scream, voice breaking. “Get away from me! Get—”
The door behind me EXPLODES inward in a rain of splintered wood.
Light—
Real light, Jonas’s lantern flaring from outside—breaks through the cracks for one desperate, flickering second.
Then goes dark.
Everything collapses into chaos.
“Eveline!” Jonas lunges into the room, grabbing for me in the dark. His hands crash around my arms, hauling me off the floor. “I’ve got you—come on—come on—”
But the cold yanks back, claws of frigid pressure hooking around my waist, trying to drag me deeper into the black.
I scream and cling to Jonas’s jacket with both fists. “DON’T LET GO!”
“I won’t!” he roars, voice cracking with raw panic. “I won’t—Eveline, stay with me—”
The darkness shrieks.
Not sound.
Not air.
A vibration that tears through the floorboards and into my bones, rattling my teeth, shaking the room like something enormous is shifting in the walls.
The cold on my waist tightens—
And then hurls me backward.
Jonas rips me toward him with a ragged shout, throwing his full strength into the pull. The force knocks us both off balance. We hit the floor hard, rolling across the boards as something enormous slams into the opposite wall.
Frost sprays across the lantern window like shattered glass.
The dark surges—thickening, tightening, compressing the room like a throat closing.
“Get up—get up—MOVE—” Jonas pulls me toward the doorway, stumbling on broken wood. “Eveline RUN—”
“I—I can’t—my legs—”
“I’ve got you—just hold on—”
He drags me toward the steps.
But the dark follows.
I hear its movement—
not footsteps—
a slide, like something dragging itself across the floor without touching it.
It gathers behind us.
A tide ready to crash.
We stumble through the broken doorframe. Jonas hauls me against his chest, half-carrying me down the first steps—
A blast of freezing air SLAMS into the back of my skull, pitching me forward.
Jonas twists his body, shoving me against the wall to shield me. “DON’T STOP. MOVE—MOVE—MOVE—”
The stairs groan beneath us. A deep, bending creak—metal strained to breaking.
We descend another step.
Another.
Every lantern on the staircase flickers wildly.
Then dies.
One.
By.
One.
Pop.
Pop.
Pop.
Darkness spirals down after us.
Something scuttles across the ceiling—so fast the air whips against my cheek.
I gasp. “Jonas—Jonas it’s—it’s—”
“I know.” His voice is shredded. “Keep your hand on the rail. Don’t look behind you. Don’t ever look behind you.”
The dark presses closer, a choking weight against my back.
We reach the halfway landing.
The temperature plummets again.
Breath crystallizes.
The rail burns with cold under my fingers.
“Jonas…” I choke, panic ripping through my chest. “It’s right behind us. I can feel it—”
“Don’t look,” he says again, pulling me faster. “Just down the stairs. We’re almost—”
Something moves below us.
My heart stops.
“Jonas.”
He hears it too.
His grip tightens around my wrist.
A second presence moves at the base of the stairs.
Blocking the exit.
Trapping us between two impossibilities.
The dark behind us shifts, tightening like a net.
The cold below rises with equal malice.
We are caught.
The room holds its breath.
Jonas moves first.
He shoves me behind him, placing himself between me and both directions of danger—even though there is no safe direction at all.
His voice drops to a whisper.
“Stay right behind me. And whatever happens—don’t let go.”
My trembling fingers find the back of his coat.
I clutch it.
Hard.
A sound rises from below.
Not a growl.
Not a whisper.
Something in-between—a broken, clicking exhale.
Jonas lifts the broken lantern by its handle, using it like a club. “If you want her,” he snarls into the darkness, “you come through me.”
The thing above us moves.
The thing below us moves.
The staircase moans under the weight of something unseen.
Jonas takes one step down.
Then another.
I follow, hand locked on his coat, heart thundering.
The darkness shifts with us.
Waiting.
Watching.
And then—
Halfway down the final curve—
Something brushes my back.
A fingertip.
Cold.
Familiar.
Impossible.
“Eveline…” it whispers behind my ear.
Silas’s voice again.
Soft.
Desperate.
Breaking.
“Come back. You left me. Don’t leave me again…”
My knees buckle.
I start to turn.
“NO!” Jonas shouts, yanking me forward so violently my shoulder burns. “DON’T LOOK AT IT—DON’T LISTEN—KEEP MOVING—”
But the voice behind me cries out—
“Evie—please—don’t go—”
It sounds like Silas.
It sounds exactly like Silas.
My brother.
My heart.
My ghost.
Tears stream down my face.
“I—I have to—Jonas, what if it’s—”
“It’s NOT HIM!” Jonas roars. “That thing is using your grief—don’t let it in—don’t let it—”
The voice behind me changes mid-sentence.
A fracture.
A crack.
A slip of something monstrous beneath the mimicry.
“Evie… don’t—leave—me—”
The tone dissolves into a chorus of layered voices.
Too many.
Too uneven.
Silas’s voice flips inside-out and becomes—
“Follow him down.”
My blood turns to ice.
The whisper is so close I can feel its lips brush my skin.
I scream and shove myself down the stairs.
Jonas grabs me, steadying my stumble as we hit the bottom floor. We crash into the entryway just as the shadows above us surge downward in a violent rush—hitting the staircase so hard the entire lighthouse shudders.
Jonas grips my shoulders. “RUN!”
We bolt across the room, slipping on frost-slick floorboards. My breath tears at my lungs. Jonas reaches the front door, grabbing the handle—
It won’t move.
Frozen.
A sheet of ice locks the hinges, crawling up the frame in jagged webs.
“Try the side—” I gasp.
He drags me toward the storage entrance—but before we reach it, a shadow spills across the doorframe, stretching like ink across paper, rising, rising, rising—
Blocking it.
The presence behind us closes in.
Two paths.
Both dead ends.
Jonas pushes me behind him again.
I clutch his shirt, sobbing.
“Jonas… what do we do—what do we—”
He swallows hard.
Then whispers—
“We don’t open any doors.”
The darkness shifts.
A sound rises—slow at first, then building—something like an inhale traveling through every wall, every board, every breath of air in the lighthouse.
A deep, rattling intake.
It fills the entire room.
And then—
Something unseen exhales.
A blast of cold erupts through the space, shattering the last lantern overhead. The glass rains down like glittering shards. The temperature plunges so sharply I feel the moisture in my lungs freeze.
Jonas pulls me against him, shielding me as wind roars through the lighthouse with impossible force.
The darkness moves.
It circles.
Trapping us in the center of the room.
“Eveline…” the layered voices breathe, weaving into one unbearable word.
“Follow.”
I press my forehead against Jonas’s shoulder, trembling uncontrollably.
“I’m not going with you,” I whisper through my teeth. “You can’t have me. You can’t—”
The darkness laughs.
Soft.
Chilling.
Echoing from every corner.
Jonas grips the compass on my wrist—the one that has become our warning, our line between safety and disaster.
The needle spins.
Wild.
Aggressive.
Convulsing like it’s trying to tear itself free from the metal.
Jonas’s voice breaks. “Eveline… don’t listen to it. Stay with me. Stay right here.”
I nod.
But I can barely feel my limbs.
The cold is sinking deeper.
The dark is tightening.
The voice whispers—
“You were always going to follow him. You already know the way.”
I press my hands against my ears but the sound pours straight into my skull.
Jonas lifts my chin, forcing me to look at him instead of the darkness. “I won’t let anything take you. Do you hear me? Not this thing. Not anything.”
I believe him.
But the dark moves again.
Faster.
Closer.
The room seems to shrink around us—walls bending inward, ceiling lowering, air thickening, pressing us together in a space too small to hold breath.
My trembling voice breaks from my throat—
“Jonas… I don’t think it’s letting us leave.”
He steps in front of me as the shadows curve around us like a closing fist.
“I wasn’t planning on leaving,” he says quietly.
The dark rises.
The cold deepens.
The whisper returns—so close it might as well be inside my head.
“Follow him down. Time is almost gone.”
And something in the darkness reaches forward.
A hand.
Or the memory of one.
Stretching toward me—
Jonas lunges between us.
And the lighthouse plunges again into total, crushing black.