Chapter 21: Lies Feed Us
Eveline Shore
The moment Jonas shouts my name, something inside me collapses.
Not a small collapse, not the momentary stagger of fear, but a complete inward buckling—ribs shivering inward like a struck bell. His voice isn’t distant. It isn’t muffled. It isn’t uncertain.
It’s terrified.
I’m already moving—halfway to the stairs before my mind catches up to my body. The lighthouse floor is freezing beneath my bare feet, the boards vibrating faintly under each step as though the entire tower is holding its breath.
“Jonas?”
My voice cracks, splintering against the walls.
The silence that follows is wrong.
Heavy.
Bottomless.
A silence with weight, like something pressing down from above.
I grip the railing of the spiral staircase so tightly my knuckles blanch, but the cold metal grounds nothing. Every inch of me is trembling with an instinct deeper than thought—an instinct that says: you are not alone in this tower.
I force myself down one step.
Then another.
“Jonas, please answer me.”
Nothing.
My heartbeat is everywhere—behind my eyes, humming in my teeth, pulsing in my wrists. The shadows between the spiraling bars seem to breathe, expanding and contracting with every flicker of lantern light above.
I swallow hard. “If you can hear me… just—say something.”
A faint whisper rises from below.
Not Jonas.
Not even close.
A voice shaped like mine.
“Eveline…”
I stop breathing.
The whisper floats upward like a cold current, sliding along the metal railing and curling behind my ear. Its tone is soft—too soft—like someone trying to mimic calmness but missing the temperature of it entirely.
My fingers clutch the compass. The warm metal shivers against my palm. The needle spins, stuttering in tiny jerks as though something—some electromagnetic pulse, some invisible presence—is distorting the very air around me.
“Come down…”
My voice—my stolen voice—drifts upward again.
No.
No.
Jonas warned me.
Stay upstairs.
Don’t come down unless I call you.
But that voice…
That ghost of my own voice…
It drags something out of me I don’t want to feel: memory.
Silas’s face the night he vanished.
The way my voice broke when I begged him not to go over the ridge.
The echo of myself in the screaming wind.
The mimic’s voice matches that exact tremor.
It shouldn’t be possible.
Fear, old and marrow-deep, crawls into my chest like an old injury awakening.
I take another step down before my brain catches up.
“Jonas?” My voice climbs into a plea. “If you’re there—just let me know you’re okay.”
On the next step, a new sound rises.
A hand.
Slamming against the lighthouse door.
I flinch back with a sharp gasp, my knees almost giving out beneath me.
Then—
“Eveline!”
Jonas’s voice.
Real. Raw.
Alive.
“Thank God—Jonas, I thought—”
“Get back upstairs NOW!” He’s shouting, breathless. “It’s not me at the door—do you hear me? It’s not—”
The thing outside interrupts in a perfect imitation:
“Eveline, it’s me. Open the door.”
My stomach plummets.
No.
It copies him.
Perfect pitch.
Perfect cadence.
Perfect fear.
The identical voices clash—one muffled behind the door, one floating through the cracks like mist.
“He’s lying,” the imitation murmurs, smooth as oil. “He’s hiding Silas from you.”
The ache that name still carves through me makes my chest collapse inward.
Silas.
Always Silas.
Always the ghost in the fog.
The compass jerks violently in my hand. The needle snaps to a dead stop, pointing straight downward—toward the closed door at the bottom of the stairs.
Toward the mimic.
Toward whatever is waiting just beyond that thin sheet of metal.
I don’t know whose voice to believe.
But I know one truth:
I am not opening that door.
Not again.
Not for anyone.
I take one step back.
Two.
My breath shakes the air in front of me.
Then—
A new silence rises.
Colder.
Sharper.
Wrong.
The mimic stops imitating. Stops speaking.
Stops pretending.
I can feel it shift.
Feel it move.
Not toward the door.
Up.
Up the side of the lighthouse wall.
Up the stone.
Up.
Toward me.
My muscles lock.
The air temperature drops so fast I choke. My breath spills out of me in pale fog. Every strand of hair on my arms stands upright.
The lantern above flickers.
My voice barely scrapes out.
“Jonas… something’s inside.”
A sound splits the tower.
The metal door downstairs EXPLODES open, slamming back with a bang so violent it rattles through the entire structure.
“EVELINE!” Jonas screams—
And the lantern lights above me SNAP out.
One by one.
Pop.
Pop.
Pop.
Darkness swallows everything.
The dark in the lighthouse isn’t empty. It’s listening.
I grip the railing so hard it cuts into my palm. The compass trembles in my other hand, needle spinning madly in the dark like it’s trying to tear itself free.
“Jonas?” I whisper.
A floorboard creaks below me.
Not Jonas.
Too heavy.
Too slow.
Too… wrong.
I freeze, barely breathing.
Something drags itself along the wall—metal scraping stone, like claws raking slowly down the lighthouse interior.
My blood runs ice-cold.
The voice comes again.
Soft. Breathless.
Right behind my ear.
“Eveline…”
I spin, but the dark is thick, impenetrable. I can’t see anything—can’t even see my own hands.
Two more lanterns pop.
Glass shatters down the stairs in glittering drops.
“Jonas!” I choke out.
Something moves below—fast.
Too fast.
The sound rushes up the stairs toward me in a blur of scraping, breath, and weight.
I stumble back, grabbing the rail, nearly missing a step—
A hand catches my ankle.
Human-shaped.
Cold as seawater.
I scream.
The grip tightens, nails digging into my skin. I kick wildly, hitting metal, stone, anything—but the grip doesn’t loosen.
“Eveline…” The voice croons through the dark, too close. “Come back. Silas is waiting.”
“LET GO OF ME!”
My heel slams into something hard—bone?—and the grip finally slips.
I jerk my leg free and bolt upward, two stairs at a time, heart battering my ribs so violently I can barely see straight.
Something claws after me.
Skittering.
Scraping.
Breathing.
The dark bends around its movement like fabric around a weight.
I leap the last three steps and burst into the lantern room, slamming the iron hatch shut behind me. My hands fumble desperately for the locking bar.
Something hits the hatch from below.
Hard.
The whole lighthouse shakes with the impact. The hatch almost caves inward.
I slam the lock into place.
Metal scrapes metal.
The hatch holds—barely.
The thing below drags its nails across the underside of the metal, slow and eager, as though savoring the sound.
My breath shudders out of me.
I stumble back, chest heaving, back hitting the cold glass of the lantern room wall.
Below the hatch—
A voice hums.
This time, not mine.
Not Jonas’s.
Silas’s.
“Eveline… open the door.”
My legs buckle.
No.
No, it’s lying.
It has to be lying.
But the voice—God, the voice—is exactly right.
The same gentle rasp. The same softened consonants. The same melodic lilt he used only when speaking to me.
My body shakes violently, my hand clamping over my mouth to stifle a sob.
“Eveline…” it murmurs through the metal hatch. “You left me. Don’t leave me again.”
Tears sting my eyes.
“Silas?” I whisper, hating myself.
The compass in my hand snaps—
Not breaks.
Snaps into stillness.
The needle freezes straight ahead.
Upward.
Toward the lantern.
Toward the ridge beyond the cliffs.
My heart plummets.
Because the last time the compass acted like this—
Silas had died.
Or disappeared.
Or something worse.
I don’t know what to believe anymore.
But something is out there.
Something is coming.
Something wants me alone.
The hatch below falls silent.
Silent—but not empty.
I back up until my shoulders hit the window frame. Outside, the fog presses against the glass like a living thing.
The lighthouse groans under some unseen weight.
Footsteps rise from the stairwell again. Slow this time. Heavy. Deliberate.
It’s coming back up.
My chest tightens so sharply I can’t breathe.
I press my back to the glass and whisper into the dark:
“Jonas… please find me. Please.”
Because whatever is walking up those stairs—
It isn’t him.
Not even close.
The footsteps grow heavier.
Slower.
Each one a deliberate press of weight against the metal stairs, the kind of tread that isn’t searching or unsure—it’s confident. Patient. Certain of where I am, what I fear, and how close it’s allowed to get before I break.
The dark hums. Not with sound, but with pressure—air thickening, like the tower’s walls are shrinking inward, compressing the space between us.
I press my back harder against the lantern room window until the cold bites through my shirt.
“Jonas…”
My voice is barely breath.
Barely sound.
Barely hope.
The thing on the stairs stops.
I know, without any logic, any reason, that it is listening.
Waiting for me to move.
Waiting for me to choose wrong.
Then—
A slow tap echoes against the underside of the hatch.
Once.
Twice.
Three times.
Like a knock meant only for me.
I clamp my hand over my mouth.
The tapping stops.
A faint rasp scrapes along the metal. It’s not claws this time. Not nails. Not the sharp scrape of something unnatural.
It’s the sound of skin.
Human skin.
Dragging slowly.
Almost tender.
Then a voice—soft, coaxing—flows upward through the thin crack between the hatch and the stairs:
“Eveline… answer me. Please.”
Silas’s voice again.
Perfect.
Impossibly perfect.
My throat tightens until I can’t breathe.
“No,” I whisper, shaking my head even though no one can see me. “You’re not real. You’re not him.”
A faint chuckle drifts up—one I recognize too easily.
“I know what you’re afraid of.”
That stops me cold.
Everything inside me goes still.
The voice leans into the silence, savoring it.
“You’re afraid he didn’t die. You’re afraid he suffered. You’re afraid he called your name, and you never heard him.”
My stomach caves inward.
Stop.
“Even more than that…”
The voice softens into a murmur.
“You’re afraid Jonas knows something you don’t.”
Something hot and sharp flashes through me.
Jonas.
Where is he?
Is he hurt?
Did the creature drag him off?
Is he alive?
Or—
God, no—
Is he the one screaming and pounding on the door earlier?
The thought makes tears prick my eyes.
“Eveline…”
The voice at the hatch deepens.
“Open the door before he gets you killed too.”
A chill tears straight down my spine.
Too.
Before he gets me killed too.
The words land with impossible weight.
The thing below has stopped trying to imitate someone who loves me.
It has stopped pretending it wants to help me.
It wants to break me.
And it’s close.
So close I can feel the change in the air every time it breathes.
I take one step back until my shoulders press to the cold lantern window again.
The fog outside swirls harder, smearing across the glass like hands searching for a way inside.
No.
No, think.
Jonas wouldn’t leave me.
Jonas warned me.
Jonas told me to stay upstairs.
Whatever is beneath that hatch…
it wants me confused.
It wants me isolated.
And Jonas is the only person it needs to remove to make that happen.
My heart slams violently against my ribs.
I steady my voice as best I can.
“STOP using his voice.”
The thing goes silent.
Then something laughs—low, guttural, wet, nothing like Silas, nothing like Jonas, nothing like anyone human.
Every hair on my neck rises in a violent wave.
So that’s its real sound.
That’s the thing beneath the mimicry.
That’s what’s hunting us.
My breath shakes out.
I force my eyes to scan the lantern room for anything—anything at all—I can use as protection.
The oil can.
The metal rod used to steady the rotating lens.
The broken wrench Jonas used earlier.
My gaze snaps to the compass in my hand, the metal trembling faintly.
The needle, frozen before, starts to twitch—
Left.
Right.
Left.
Then it jerks toward the window behind me.
Not the hatch.
Not the stairs.
Something outside.
My blood runs cold.
I turn slowly.
Through the thick fog, the shape of a figure stands motionless on the cliff’s edge, barely visible through the milky veil. A human outline.
Tall.
Still.
Facing directly toward the lighthouse.
A sharp gasp escapes me.
No.
No, that can’t be—
“Silas?”
It slips out before I can stop it—small, desperate, a fragment of hope carved out of grief.
But as the fog shifts, the figure doesn’t move.
Doesn’t breathe.
Doesn’t blink.
It only watches.
And the compass needle—
God—
it points to him.
A violent shudder tears through me.
Then—
BANG.
The hatch nearly breaks off its hinges.
I stumble back.
Another impact.
Louder.
Faster.
The thing below isn’t pretending anymore.
It wants in.
“Eveline!”
Jonas’s real voice—this time unquestionably real—shouts from somewhere outside the lighthouse. “GET AWAY FROM THE HATCH!”
A sob bursts out of me.
“Jonas!”
“Move! NOW!”
I leap away just as the hatch SPLITS inward, the metal bending like paper. A pale arm—too long, too thin—forces through the opening, fingers clawing blindly for me.
I scream, scrambling toward the opposite wall.
“GET DOWN!” Jonas yells from outside.
Something heavy crashes against the lighthouse from the outside—Jonas must be trying to force the thing back through the hatch by brute force, because the creature shrieks, arm jerking back abruptly.
Then—
A silence so sharp it rings.
“Eveline!” Jonas’s voice again. “Stay there! I’m coming around—hold on!”
I don’t move.
I can’t move.
I’m shaking too hard.
Through the shattered hatch, I hear the creature retreat—slowly, dragging itself down the stairs with a sound like wet rope.
Then—
Nothing.
Just the distant wind screaming through the cracks of the tower.
My breath comes in shallow bursts.
I crawl to the lantern room window and press my forehead against the cold glass. The fog outside churns with unnatural force, swallowing the cliff edge.
The figure I saw moments ago is gone.
Vanished.
The compass needle spins again.
Jonas’s footsteps crunch outside on the gravel, fast and frantic.
“Eveline? EVELINE, answer me!”
I slam my palms against the glass.
“Jonas! I’m here!”
His shadow breaks through the fog below. Relief hits me so violently my knees almost give out.
But as I back away from the window, the compass slips from my shaking fingers and rolls across the floor.
It stops.
Perfectly still.
Pointing—not toward the door.
Not toward the cliff.
Not toward where the creature vanished.
But toward the center of the lantern room floor.
Toward me.
My breath stutters.
A cold realization spreads through my spine.
The creature wasn’t trying to lure me downstairs.
It wasn’t trying to pretend to be Jonas.
It wasn’t even trying to break in.
It was trying to get me alone
in this room
at this exact moment
so the compass would point here.
Because something
is already in the lantern room with me.
The floor behind me creaks.
Very, very softly.
I turn—
Slow.
Frozen.
A shape stands in the far corner of the lantern room, where the rotating shadows hid it until now. Its outline is human.
But too still.
Too tall.
Too wrong.
Its head tilts slowly, like it’s studying me.
The lantern light flickers—
and the shape steps forward.
The figure steps forward.
One slow, deliberate movement.
Its feet make no sound on the metal floor—just the faintest shift of weight, like fabric dragging across air. My spine goes rigid. My breath catches so sharply it hurts.
I can’t see its face.
The shadows bend around it, swallowing its features. But its silhouette—long, humanoid, impossibly still—moves with an unnerving precision. Like it has all the time in the world. Like the chase is over and the waiting is the part it enjoys most.
The metal rod Jonas left earlier lies near the broken hatch. Too far. I’d never reach it before the thing reached me.
My mind races.
Fog outside thickens, smearing into pale streaks against the glass as the storm gathers strength. Lightning flickers distantly, painting the fog in brief flashes of blue-white. With each flicker, the shape appears closer—another step forward, another subtle shift of shadow like it’s rearranging itself to look more human.
Except it isn’t.
Its proportions are wrong.
Its posture too fluid.
And it stands in the one corner of the room where shadows shouldn’t be thick enough to hide anything.
This is what the compass wanted me to see.
This is what it pointed to.
This is what has been inside the lighthouse with me.
Waiting.
“H-How long…” My voice is a thread of sound. “How long have you been here?”
The figure tilts its head—not slowly, not naturally, but in a sharp jerking angle, like breaking a neck sideways.
My lungs seize.
Then—
a whisper.
Soft.
Barely audible.
The exact pitch of my own voice.
“Long enough.”
My knees nearly buckle.
It sounds like me. Exactly like me. Not distorted. Not stretched. Not hollow.
Me.
But with no breath behind the syllables. No warmth. No humanity.
Cold mimicry.
My stomach twists violently.
“Say something else,” I whisper, even though every part of me is screaming not to engage.
The shadow’s spine straightens in one slow sequence, vertebra by vertebra, as if remembering how a human stands. Then my own voice leaks from its silhouette again:
“Silas is calling you.”
My chest cracks open.
My hand flies to my mouth.
The creature takes another two steps forward—silent, gliding, wrong.
“No.” I shake my head, backing toward the window. “You’re not real. None of this is real.”
The figure lifts its arm.
Something long and pale slides forward, stretching the shadow into a distorted smear on the floor.
I can’t breathe.
I can’t think.
I can’t—
“EVELINE!”
Jonas’s voice slices through the room like a thrown blade.
My head snaps toward the hatch.
He’s climbing in—struggling, scraped, panting—forcing himself through the twisted metal even though fresh blood drips from his forearm.
“Get away from her!” he roars.
The creature doesn’t turn.
Doesn’t even acknowledge him.
Its attention stays pinned to me.
Jonas lunges forward and grabs the metal rod. His movement jolts the creature—it turns its head sharply toward him, in a motion too fast to follow.
Jonas positions himself between us, breath ragged.
“You’re not touching her,” he growls.
The creature moves.
Not toward him.
Not toward the hatch.
Toward the window—toward me.
I stumble back. The glass presses against my shoulder blades, freezing cold.
“Jonas,” I whisper, “please—”
He swings the rod.
The creature flickers.
One second it stands three feet away.
The next it’s on the opposite side of the room.
As if it simply chose a new place to exist.
Jonas’s swing hits nothing but air.
His momentum nearly sends him crashing to the floor. He regains balance, eyes wild.
“Get behind me!”
“I—I can’t move!”
My legs are shaking so hard I can barely stand.
The creature’s head tilts again, studying Jonas this time. Its shoulders rise and fall, almost curious. It takes one step toward him, then stops as if listening to something inside itself.
Then it speaks.
Not in my voice.
In Jonas’s.
“Hurt her, and you die.”
Jonas’s face goes white.
“That’s not what I said,” he whispers.
The creature repeats it. The same threat. The same tone. Down to the rasp in his breath from climbing into the room.
It’s mimicking him now. Not me.
“No,” I breathe, panic flaring bright. “Stop—stop using us—stop—”
The creature flickers closer.
Jonas pushes me behind him and raises the rod again, jaw clenched, trembling.
“You’re not taking her,” he says through his teeth.
The creature steps forward.
Jonas swings hard.
This time—
He connects.
The metal rod hits the creature’s shoulder with a sick crack.
Except—
The metal goes through it.
Like cutting through fog.
The creature’s body ripples around the impact, not breaking, not recoiling, simply absorbing the blow like liquid shadows.
Jonas stumbles backward, horrified.
“Oh God,” he whispers.
The creature turns its head toward me again.
Its outline trembles, distorts, reshapes—like it’s trying to find the right form, the right size, the right face to wear.
Lightning flashes outside, and for half a second—
Its face becomes Silas’s.
Only wrong.
Eyes hollow.
Jaw too wide.
Features stretched into a grotesque echo.
A sound tears out of me.
“No,” I sob. “No—Silas—Silas, no—”
It steps toward me.
Jonas doesn’t hesitate.
He throws himself between us, slamming into the creature with full body weight. They crash into the lantern housing, shattering glass and sending shards across the floor.
“RUN!” Jonas shouts, gripping the creature even though his hands sink through its torso like wet sand. “GO!”
“I won’t leave you!”
“GO!”
The wind howls outside, shaking the lighthouse violently. A bolt of lightning strikes so close the entire tower shudders.
I grab the closest weapon—one of the broken glass shards—and I rush forward.
“Eveline—NO!”
But too late—
I slash.
The shard slices through the creature’s neck.
It doesn’t bleed.
It doesn’t recoil.
But its form collapses inward, folding like collapsing fabric. The shadow warps, then splits—two shapes peeling away from each other like torn paper.
Jonas yanks me back before the second shape can reach for me.
“MOVE!”
We run.
The hatch is busted open. Metal twists inward like melted wax. Jonas grabs my arm, pulling me down the stairs two at a time. The lighthouse sways under the force of the storm, each lightning strike strobing the world in violent bursts of white.
Behind us—
A scraping sound follows.
Soft at first.
Then faster.
Then impossibly fast.
I choke on a scream.
“Jonas, it’s coming!”
“I know!”
We reach the main door—a battered metal thing Jonas barricaded earlier. He rips the wood beam free and shoves the door open. Rain slams into us like ice. The ground is slippery with seawater and mud.
“Run,” Jonas orders.
I do.
I sprint into the storm, lungs burning, bare feet slapping cold earth. The fog swallows the lighthouse behind us, but the scraping grows louder.
Closer.
Jonas grabs my wrist, pulling me into the trees bordering the cliff path.
Thunder splits the sky.
Lightning hits the lighthouse.
A deafening crack.
The lantern room EXPLODES in a burst of fire and glass.
I scream, covering my head. Jonas shields me with his body as debris crashes down around us.
When the light dims, I look up—
The lighthouse top burns like a torch.
And through the flames—
A figure stands at the broken window.
Not falling.
Not burning.
Just watching.
Jonas pulls my face into his chest.
“Don’t look at it.”
But I do.
For one horrible second—
It tilts its head.
Just like before.
Fog swirls around its legs.
And then, with a flicker of lightning—
It vanishes.
The storm rages.
The ground trembles.
Jonas grips my shoulders, turning me toward him.
“Eveline—listen to me—are you hurt? Are you bleeding? Can you move?”
His voice shakes, but his eyes are sharp, scanning me for wounds.
“I’m—I’m okay,” I whisper, though my body trembles uncontrollably. “Jonas… what was that? What did we see? What did it want?”
He hesitates.
Too long.
My heart freezes.
“Jonas.”
His jaw tightens.
“It wasn’t trying to kill you,” he says quietly.
My breath stops.
“Then—what?”
He looks back toward the burning lighthouse.
“It was hunting you.”
My pulse stutters painfully.
“Hunting me for what?”
Jonas inhales sharply.
Wind whips his wet hair across his forehead.
His hands tighten on my arms.
“It wasn’t copying you,” he says slowly. “It wasn’t copying me.”
I stare at him, confused.
“It was learning you.”
My blood runs cold.
“Trying to understand your voice. Your reactions. Your fear. How you move. How you breathe.”
He swallows hard.
“It’s preparing for something.”
My heart cracks painfully.
“What? Jonas—what is it preparing for?”
He meets my eyes, and the fear in his expression is something I’ve never seen on him.
Not once.
Not ever.
“Eveline…”
He speaks like the words cut him open from the inside.
“It’s preparing to become you.”
The wind howls violently across the cliff.
Lightning cuts the sky.
And somewhere—far beyond the flames, beyond the fog—
a voice that is not mine
whispers my name
with perfect, horrifying clarity:
“Eveline…”