Chapter 23: Hook, Line, and Suspicion

(Eden’s POV)

The scent of grilled fish and citrus filled the open-air dining room, the evening breeze ruffling napkins and tousling hair. Everyone was sun-kissed and glowing, cheeks pink from the ocean and laughter.

“—And then this tiny-ass fish,” Joe was saying through fits of laughter, “like the size of my hand, just yanked me straight off the dock. I hit the water so fast, I swear I saw God.”

Camille snorted into her wine. “You’re six foot three and got bodied by a guppy?”

“It was feisty!” Joe protested, grinning at Harper, who looked equally amused and mortified.

Luca was wiping his hands on a towel, his shoulders still damp from where Levi had splashed him while cleaning the fish. “I told you not to lean too close to the edge, man.”

“I was helping!” Joe declared. “That fish had something to prove.”

The table roared with laughter again. Even I couldn’t help but giggle, despite the fact that I was still recovering from what I’d done just hours ago with only my phone, my fingers, and a stranger’s filthy instructions.

Or not-so-stranger.

I shifted in my seat, sipping slowly from my lemonade.

I could feel them—Luca and Levi—without even looking. The way they took up space without trying. The weight of their presence. And right now, the warm way they both glanced at me like I’d always belonged at this table.

Levi turned toward me, his arm slung loosely along the back of his chair.

“You have a good day?” he asked, casually.

I blinked. “Yeah. Quiet. I finished my book.”

Luca quirked a brow. “The spicy one you had on the boat?”

I blushed. “Maybe.”

“That book’s practically softcore porn,” Camille chimed in. “Didn’t even know Eden read stuff like that.”

“Well,” I muttered, stabbing a roasted potato with my fork, “I’m twenty-five. I read what I want.”

Levi leaned in just a little, and said it casually—too casually.

“What chapter were you on again? Twenty-six?”

My fork paused halfway to my mouth.

That voice. That line. The exact same one from the dock.

He’d asked about chapter twenty-six that morning.

Right before I got the message.

My gaze flicked to him, and he just smiled, cocky and unreadable, like he hadn’t just spun my stomach into knots.

“What was chapter twenty-six about, anyway?” he added, tone perfectly innocent.

I studied his face, trying to read between the easy charm and golden skin.

It could’ve been coincidence.

Or not.

Across from me, Luca reached for the lemon wedges, looking far too focused on his plate. But the smirk ghosting his lips?

Yeah, he knew something too.

I swallowed hard and finally took the bite of food I’d forgotten I was holding.

“Wouldn’t you like to know,” I said, my voice breezy despite the wildfire burning in my chest.

Levi grinned but didn’t press further.

The conversation moved on, back to Harper’s wedding playlist and Joe’s fear of dancing in public. But the tension in my stomach didn’t fade.

My phone buzzed in my lap.

Unknown:

Did you think about me during dinner?

Or were you too busy wondering which twin knows how you taste when you come?

I didn’t move. Didn’t breathe. Just looked across the table…

Straight into Levi’s eyes.

He winked.