Chapter 24: Eyes on Me

(Eden’s POV)

The morning air was thick with salt and warmth, the kind of heat that clung to your skin before the sun even fully broke the horizon. I wasn’t trying to see them. I just wanted air… and distance.

But there they were.

Luca and Levi.

On the beach, barefoot, shirtless, bodies already slick with sweat from what looked like an early morning sparring session.

And they looked… unreal.

Luca’s build was lean but sculpted, with a smoothness to his movements that reminded me of something feline—dangerous but fluid. His chest rose and fell with steady control, every line of his abdomen catching the early light. His dark hair was tousled and damp, just long enough to fall forward when he ducked or pivoted, then flicked away with a sharp jerk of his head.

Levi was broader, more solid—his muscles thick and pronounced beneath golden skin. He fought with brute power, grinning every time he landed a hit or blocked one from his brother. Tattoos ran down both arms, creeping over his shoulders like inked temptation, a story written on skin I hadn’t read yet.

They circled each other in the sand, fists raised, grinning like boys and gods at the same time.

I froze behind a palm tree like a total creep, coffee forgotten in my hands. The way their bodies moved—raw, effortless, intimate—wasn’t just athletic. It was primal.

When Levi lunged and Luca dodged, laughing, it felt like watching foreplay. Every hit. Every smirk. Every near-touch that ended in a tumble of tangled limbs in the sand.

And then… Levi looked up.

Right at me.

His smile was lazy, slow. A smirk that crawled across his face like he’d just caught me in the act—which he had.

My breath caught in my throat. I turned so fast I nearly tripped over my own feet, heart thundering, skin flushed.

By the time I reached the deck, my phone buzzed in my palm.

Unknown:

Did you enjoy the show?

You looked like you were imagining what it’d feel like to be pinned between them.

Would you let them fight for the right to make you scream first?

I stood there, trembling.

Every part of me pulsed.

Was it Levi?

Was it Luca?

Was it both?

Or was I completely losing it?

I walked inside, the air cooler, but I was burning from the inside out. I stopped in the hallway, bracing myself against the wall.

Me:

Tell me who you are.

Now.

This has gone far enough.

Are you one of them?

The typing bubbles appeared instantly. Then nothing.

Then again.

Unknown:

You want it to be one of them.

You want it to be both.

What if it is?

What if they know everything?

What if they’ve been waiting for you to stop pretending you’re not made to be ruined by them?

I stared at the words, my entire body aching.

Me:

Stop playing games.

Unknown:

Games? Oh, sweetheart.

We haven’t even started.

The message disappeared.

Not saved. Not archived.

Gone.

Deleted from existence like it had never happened.

But the ache it left behind?

That was very, very real.

And for the first time… I wasn’t sure who I wanted more.

Or if I even had to choose.