Chapter 22: Don’t Look at Me Like That

(Eden’s POV)

The eggs on my plate were overcooked.

Or maybe they weren’t, and I just couldn’t taste anything through the lingering fog of that dream. I shifted in my chair, crossing and uncrossing my legs for the fifth time, hoping no one noticed the full-body blush I hadn’t managed to shake off.

“Eden, you okay?” Harper asked, plopping into the seat beside me with a fresh cup of coffee. “You look like you ran a marathon.”

I smiled too quickly. “I’m great. Just… hungry. And maybe a little warm.”

Camille smirked over her juice. “Still glowing.”

I stabbed a strawberry like it had personally offended me.

Across the patio, Levi stood at the open dock shed, shirtless and laughing as he packed a cooler. His back muscles flexed with every movement. His swim trunks sat just low enough on his hips to be illegal in certain countries. Luca walked out behind him, tossing fishing rods into a duffel, his eyes scanning the patio.

Then, for a beat too long, they both looked at me.

Luca’s mouth tugged up at the corner. Levi arched an eyebrow like he knew. Like he’d seen the whole damn dream reel in my head and was just waiting for me to combust.

Nope. Not today.

I grabbed my water and took a long gulp, pretending to be fascinated by the condensation running down the glass. Harper leaned in.

“The guys are heading out for a little fishing trip this morning. You wanna tag along or stay back and relax?”

Relax. In a house with vibrating group chat notifications and the ghosts of twin tongues trailing down my body?

“Stay back,” I said quickly, too quickly. “I could use a book and some alone time.”

Camille snorted. “More like alone time and a battery-operated boyfriend.”

“I heard that,” I muttered through gritted teeth.

Levi lifted the cooler and slung it into the boat like it weighed nothing. Luca threw a towel over his shoulder and shouted something to Joe, then turned his head slightly—just enough to look at me again.

My thighs clenched. Reflex.

“You sure you don’t want to come?” Luca called. “It’s peaceful. We could use the company.”

“I’m good!” I said, practically yelling. “Fish scare me.”

He smiled like I’d just admitted something far more scandalous.

Levi stepped onto the boat, sunglasses shielding his eyes but not the wicked curve of his lips.

“Catch you later, sweetheart,” he said, and I didn’t know if he meant the fish or me.

The boat engine started, loud and low, drowning out my thoughts for a blessed moment. I stared at the dock until they disappeared past the trees, pretending my skin wasn’t tingling where his voice hit.

My phone buzzed again.

Unknown:

So who was it this time?

The one in your mouth… or the one between your legs?

Or did you beg both?

Don’t be shy. I want to know everything.

I set the phone down carefully like it was made of fire. Then stood.

I needed a shower.

A cold one.

With the door locked.

And maybe holy water.

——————————————

I wasn’t sure how I made it up the stairs.

The second I shut my bedroom door and clicked the lock into place, I pressed my back against the wood like it could hold me upright. My legs were shaking, my breath shallow.

My dream still clung to me like salt water on skin. The way their hands moved, the feel of their lips, the heat… It had felt real. Too real.

But the message on my phone?

That was worse.

So who was it this time?

The one in your mouth… or the one between your legs?

Or did you beg both?

My fingers trembled as I typed back.

Me:

I dreamed of them both.

Their mouths. Their hands.

I didn’t finish. I woke up too soon.

A new message popped up before I could blink.

Unknown:

Then finish now.

Slide your hand between those thighs. Let me hear how wet you are.

Middle finger only. Slow, lazy circles. No rush. Let the pressure build like it’s one of them teasing you.

I swallowed hard, a low moan slipping past my lips as I kicked off my shorts and climbed onto the bed. I left the window cracked, the breeze cool on my skin as I leaned back against the pillows.

My hand slid between my thighs, fingertips gliding over slick heat.

“Fuck,” I whispered.

Unknown:

Are you dripping for me, baby?

You know they’d love this. Watching you unravel.

One would suck on your tits while the other played with your pretty pussy.

Take your time. Rub your clit. Slow.

Pretend one’s tongue is there, tasting every inch of you.

My body arched, breath stuttering. I followed his commands like they were law, like the very air I breathed depended on it.

My thumb found my clit, and I moaned, slow circles spiraling my mind into lust.

In my head, I saw Levi gripping my thighs, pushing them apart while Luca pinned my wrists above my head, his mouth trailing fire down my chest.

Unknown:

I bet you’re close. Let me take you over the edge.

Slide two fingers in now. Imagine how tight you’d feel around them.

One watching, stroking himself while you fall apart for the other.

Moaning their names. Crying out for more.

Come for me, Eden. Now.

I bit my lip so hard I tasted blood, hips rolling against my hand. My walls fluttered around my fingers, and heat exploded behind my eyes.

I came hard, clenching and pulsing, breath caught in my throat as my orgasm rocked through me in waves. I writhed into the sheets, thighs trembling, mouth open in a broken moan I didn’t even try to hide.

It took me a full minute to come down.

Sweaty. Panting. Boneless.

My fingers were soaked, glistening with everything I’d just felt.

Then the next message lit up the screen.

Unknown:

Now send me a photo.

Be a good girl.

Show me what I made you do.

I hesitated—just for a second. Then I lifted my hand and took the photo, my soaked fingers against my bare thigh.

Send.

A response came moments later.

Unknown:

Look at you.

Absolutely filthy.

If I were there, I’d lick your fingers clean… and then make you come again with my tongue buried so deep you forget your own name.

This won’t be the last time.

You’re mine now, Eden.

My core pulsed all over again.

And this time, I didn’t even try to deny that I wanted more.