Chapter 10: The Almost
I could have left.
That was the part my brain kept dragging back like it wanted to personally ruin my night.
Ryker had given me an exit—clean, easy, painfully reasonable, and I had stayed exactly where I was like my self-preservation had taken the night off.
Which was annoying, because now I had to live with the fact that doing nothing had still become a choice.
A stupid one.
A revealing one.
By the time I got outside, the air had gone cooler, the estate washed in soft gold from the path lights and tall windows. Somewhere near the dorms, students were still laughing, sounding normal in a way I found deeply offensive.
I was not having a normal night.
I was walking around Fletcher like a girl who had just made a terrible emotional decision and was trying to pretend it had been an administrative error.
This should be simple, I thought.
That was almost funny.
Because nothing about Isaac Fletcher had been simple. Not the way he looked at me. Not the way silence got louder when he was in it. Not the fact that staying had felt easier than leaving.
And that was the part I hated.
Because I knew better.
I knew what attention cost here. I knew what this school could do to people who stepped out of line.
I knew my scholarship was not designed to survive bad judgment, rich boys, or whatever this was becoming.
And still, I stayed.
Because some reckless, humiliating part of me had wanted to.
Which was rude, honestly. I preferred my problems academic.
When I looked up, the garden gates were already in front of me.
Of course.
The garden was quieter than the rest of the estate, hidden from the main paths and softened by low lights along the stone border. At night, it felt less like Fletcher and more like a secret.
The fountain murmured somewhere ahead. Roses shifted above the archway in the breeze.
I hated that this place mattered now.
The first time I came here, it had just been somewhere to breathe.
Now it felt like a place that remembered things.
I stepped farther in, trying to loosen the knot in my chest.
“You don’t have to stay.”
Ryker’s voice still echoed in my head.
Isaac hadn’t told me to.
“Great,” I muttered. “So this is where I come to lose perspective.”
“Good to know.”
I stopped.
His voice came from behind me, low and calm and already too familiar.
I turned and found Isaac a few feet away beneath the archway, one hand in his pocket, tie loosened just enough to make him look unfairly human.
For a second, neither of us spoke. Then I said,
“You need to stop doing that.”
“Doing what?”
“Appearing out of nowhere like some kind of expensive haunting.”
That almost got a smile out of him. His gaze stayed on mine.
“You came here.”
The words landed harder than they should have.
“This garden exists independently of you,” I said.
“And yet here you are.” I exhaled.
“You really enjoy being annoying.”
“You’re here too.”
There was no good answer to that.
I should have walked away. That was the smart move. The safe move.
The move most likely to protect my future, my sanity, and my remaining brain cells.
Instead I stayed exactly where I was.
Again.
“You need to stop acting like this is normal,” I said.
His expression didn’t shift. “What part?”
“This. You showing up everywhere. Looking at me like—”
“Like what?”
I looked away for half a second.
Mistake.
When I looked back, he was still watching me with that same controlled focus that made everything inside me feel louder than it should.
My grip tightened around my arms.
“You’re ruining everything for me.”
The words came out sharp. Too sharp to take back.
Isaac went still.
The fountain kept running behind us. Somewhere far off, laughter rose and faded. The whole garden felt suspended.
I swallowed. Because that was only part of it.
He was ruining my focus. My plans. My ability to think like someone who still had self-control and a future to protect.
And the worst part was—I was letting him.
“You make everything harder,” I said, quieter now. “You know that, right?”
His gaze didn’t leave mine. “Then why did you stay?”
That landed so directly it almost knocked the air out of me.
Of course he had noticed. My throat tightened.
“I don’t know.” It was the truth.
His eyes dropped to my mouth for the briefest second before lifting again, and that tiny movement did something deeply unhelpful to my breathing.
“You do,” he said.
I let out a breath that sounded closer to a laugh than I meant it to.
“You are unbelievably irritating.”
“And you’re avoiding it.”
“Oh, sorry,” I said. “Was I supposed to have a clear, organized emotional response to whatever this is?”
Something shifted in his face.
I hated that I noticed.
I hated more that I liked noticing.
“This is exactly what I mean,” I said, my voice thinner now. “I don’t understand you.”
He took one slow step closer.
Not enough to touch. Enough to matter.
The garden seemed to shrink around that single movement.
My body reacted before my brain could file a formal complaint.
I should have stepped back.
I didn’t.
The space between us thinned into something fragile and dangerous, all sharp breathing and silence. The fountain sounded farther away now.
My pulse didn’t.
His eyes dropped once—quick, devastating to my mouth, and that tiny movement nearly undid me.
“This is a bad idea,” I said, but it came out quieter than I meant it to.
Isaac’s gaze held mine.
“Then stop.”
That should have made it easy.
Instead, it made everything worse.
Because this was the moment where everything changed.
I could feel it there, between one breath and the next, between leaving and staying, between every smart decision I had ever made and whatever this was.
I should stop this.
I wasn’t stopping this.
His hand lifted like he was going to touch me, then stopped just short of it—close enough that I felt the threat of it anyway.
That restraint hit harder than if he actually had.
My breath caught.
“Say it,” he whispered.
I couldn’t move.
His eyes held mine, calm and wrecking me at the same time.
“Say you don’t feel this.”