Chapter 11: The Aftermath

It would have been easier if he’d just kissed me.

Instead, he had stopped just short of it—just short of touching me, just short of giving me something concrete to regret. Which was actually, deeply worse.

“Say it.”

I stared at the ceiling.

“Say you don’t feel this.”

No. Absolutely not. We were not starting the day like this.

I rolled onto my side and instantly regretted it. Too much space. Too much quiet.

Too much room for my mind to replay the exact same moment in humiliating detail.

His hand lifting. Stopping.

Not touching me.

Close enough that I had still felt it everywhere.

My fingers brushed my lips before I caught myself. I froze, then yanked my hand back like I had personally betrayed logic.

“That didn’t happen,” I muttered. A beat passed.

“That absolutely did not happen.”

The room, annoyingly, offered no support.

I sat up, already irritated with myself. This was ridiculous.

He had told me to say I didn’t feel it, and instead I had just stood there looking at him like my survival instincts had briefly left the building.

Not ideal.

But fine actually.

I got out of bed and reached for my uniform with the kind of determination usually reserved for people going into battle or group presentations.

Here was the plan: get dressed, go to class, answer questions, act normal. If I didn’t think about it, it became academically irrelevant.

That was basically psychology.

Probably.

By the time I got to class, I was almost convinced.

The classroom smelled like paper, dry-erase markers, and expensive ambition.

Mrs. Vale was already writing across the board in sharp, unforgiving strokes, which was comforting in a weird way. Class made sense. Class had rules. Numbers did not lean in close and quietly ruin your life.

I slid into my seat, opened my notebook, and focused very hard on being a person who had slept well and was not still haunted by Isaac Fletcher’s voice.

“Page sixty-two,” Mrs. Vale said. “We’re not wasting time today.”

Finally, the language I spoke. I had just started to relax when she turned.

“Clara.” Every nerve in my body snapped to attention.

“If the coefficient shifts here,” she said, tapping the board, “what happens to the rate?”

The answer came instantly, clean and safe.

“It increases proportionally. Assuming the other variable stays constant.” Mrs. Vale gave a short nod.

“Correct.”

And just like that, the world stayed standing.

See? Functioning. Completely fine. Stable.

I looked down and wrote the date at the top of the page in neat, controlled handwriting.

My pen didn’t shake.

So really, I was handling this extremely well.

The fact that my pulse still jumped when I remembered his hand stopping just short of my face felt, at most, like a minor administrative issue.

The bell rang, and the room exhaled all at once.

Chairs scraped back. Bags zipped. Voices rose. I was still packing my notebook when Krizzy dropped into the seat beside mine like she had been waiting for the exact moment I became vulnerable.

She took one look at me and narrowed her eyes.

“Why do you look like you committed a crime?” I kept my focus on my bag.

“I didn’t.”

“That was not convincing.”

“I’m just tired.”

Krizzy leaned closer, studying my face with the kind of intensity usually reserved for medical emergencies and celebrity breakups.

“No,” she said slowly.

“Tired is under-eye circles and questionable life choices. This is different. This is guilt. Or stress. Or you helped dispose of a body before homeroom.”

“I did not help dispose of a body.”

Krizzy narrowed her eyes. “Interesting. Very specific denial.”

I stood, mostly to escape her. “You make everything sound worse than it is.”

“That’s because it usually is.”

Fair.

We stepped into the hallway with the rest of the crowd, shoulder to shoulder with students moving between classes in polished waves of noise and perfume and expensive indifference.

Fletcher always looked the same in the morning—perfect uniforms, perfect posture, perfectly curated lives—but today it all felt slightly off, like I was a second behind everything.

Krizzy bumped my arm lightly. “You’re doing the weird quiet thing.”

“I’m always quiet.”

“You’re usually controlled quiet. This is emotionally suspicious quiet.”

“That is not a real category.”

“It is now.”

I opened my mouth to argue, then stopped.

Because I felt it. Just that sudden, impossible awareness that someone was there.

My steps slowed before I could stop them. Krizzy noticed instantly.

“What?”

I looked up. He was across the hallway.

Isaac stood near the windows, one hand in his pocket, talking to no one. Or maybe people were talking around him and he just didn’t care enough to make it look mutual.

Either way, he was still in that unfair, infuriating way he had of making stillness feel like control. And he was already looking at me.

My heartbeat stumbled. Good, I thought immediately.

Stay there.

Do not come over here.

Do not say anything. Do not look at me like that in public. Do not make this worse.

He didn’t move.

The hallway kept flowing between us—voices, footsteps, laughing girls, boys shoving each other toward class—but it all felt strangely distant, like the whole school had blurred around one fixed point.

He just watched. Calm. Certain. Unreadable.

Like last night had not ended unfinished.

Like he knew exactly why I had gone still.

My throat tightened. Good, I told myself again.

This was good. The distance was good. It was smart and was exactly what I wanted.

So why did it suddenly feel like something dropping inside my chest when he still didn’t come closer?

Why did his restraint feel worse in daylight?

Krizzy followed my line of sight, then went very quiet beside me.

“Oh,” she said.

That was all. Just one word. But it was enough to make heat climb straight into my face.

I looked away first.

Bad decision.

Because the second I looked away, I could still feel him there—still watching, still not moving, still somehow more present because of it.

If he had come over, I could have been angry.

If he had said something, I could have defended myself.

If he had acted like last night meant nothing, I could have hated him for it.

But he didn’t.

He just stayed there.

And somehow, that was worse.

That’s the one I’d choose.