Chapter 9: The Interruption
Tutoring should have felt routine by now.
It didn’t.
I should not have been nervous about a study session. That was the first problem.
The study room door was right in front of me, and I still hesitated with my hand on the handle like I was about to walk into something worse than homework. Which, knowing my life lately, was not impossible.
This was just tutoring.
That was the lie I went in with.
Not normal in the universal sense, obviously. There was nothing normal about being publicly escorted through school by Isaac Fletcher like I was some kind of academic hostage. But normal enough for Fletcher, apparently. Tutoring. Notes. Silence. Emotional instability disguised as education.
If that were true, my pulse probably wouldn’t have been acting like I was about to break into a bank.
When I stepped inside, Isaac was already there.
He sat at the far end of the table with one arm hooked over the chair, a notebook open in front of him like he had every intention of being a serious student today.
“Late,” he said.
I looked at the clock. I was early.
“You’re welcome,” I said, dropping my bag onto the table.
Something almost shifted in his mouth. Not a smile. Isaac didn’t really do smiles. He did tiny facial changes that felt medically concerning.
I sat across from him and pulled out my notes, trying very hard not to think about the hallway. About Ryker. About Isaac saying, “She is”, like that was somehow a complete sentence.
This should’ve felt familiar by now.
Instead, it felt worse.
Because now I knew what easier felt like.
And Isaac Fletcher was not easier.
For the first few minutes, we actually tried.
Which was generous phrasing.
I explained a problem. Isaac looked at the page, then at me, then back at the page like he was humoring the concept of effort.
“You skipped a step,” he said.
“I didn’t.” He tilted the notebook toward me.
“You did.”
I leaned closer automatically, already ready to prove him wrong, and stopped when I realized how little space was suddenly left between us.
Right. Great. Excellent. Very educational.
I straightened too fast. “I skipped nothing.”
“You’re defensive.”
“You’re annoying.”
His gaze stayed on me half a second too long.
Then the door opened. The whole room shifted before I even turned.
Ryker stepped inside like he hadn’t just interrupted the weirdest air pressure in the history of tutoring, one hand still on the doorknob, expression easy, eyes flicking from me to Isaac and back again.
“Oh,” he said lightly. “Bad time?”
The worst part was how quickly my shoulders loosened.
Like my body had answered before I did.
“No,” I said too fast.
Isaac looked at me, which honestly felt rude considering I was already suffering.
Ryker noticed.
“I was looking for Jake,” he said, stepping farther inside. “He said he left his charger in here.”
“That feels unlikely.”
Ryker glanced at me. “Exactly.”
I frowned. “So you knew he was lying?”
“Jake lies recreationally.” That got me.
A laugh slipped out before I could stop it—small, but real—and the whole room changed.
Lighter. Safer. Less like one wrong breath could become a life decision.
Ryker smiled, looking unfairly pleased with himself.
“There she is.” I narrowed my eyes.
“That sounded weirdly supportive.”
“It was. You looked like you were being held here against your will.”
“I’m tutoring,” I said. Ryker looked at Isaac.
“That’s what we’re calling it?”
“Do you need something?” Isaac asked.
His tone wasn’t sharp. It was calm. Flat. Controlled in a way that made it feel like all the edges were hidden on purpose.
Ryker, to his credit, didn’t look bothered.
“I was just checking,” he said, then looked back at me. “You okay?”
And that was the problem.
Because I was. Or I was closer to okay when someone asked me like that.
I looked down at my notes to avoid both of them and found myself smiling anyway, which was irritating on several levels.
The part I didn’t understand was why something that felt easier also felt more dangerous.
The silence after that felt different.
Like the room had suddenly become aware of itself.
Isaac leaned back in his chair, one hand near the open notebook, his expression unreadable in that deeply irritating way of his.
He wasn’t looking at Ryker.
He was looking at me.
Not obviously. Not enough for anyone to call it out. But enough that I could feel it.
Ryker followed my line of sight and seemed to understand exactly what had changed.
“You know,” he said lightly, “I can come back.”
“No,” Isaac said.
Ryker’s brows lifted.
I looked at Isaac.
His voice was calm, but something underneath it had sharpened.
“You already interrupted,” he added. “Stay or leave.”
That should not have sounded as personal as it did. Ryker shifted his weight.
“Are you always this welcoming, Fletcher?”
Isaac didn’t answer. Which somehow answered everything.
My fingers tightened around my pen.
This was ridiculous. It was a study room. A table. A notebook. Not the emotional Hunger Games.
And yet there I was, stuck in the middle of something I could feel but couldn’t name out loud.
Ryker made things easier.
Isaac made everything harder.
So why did harder still feel impossible to walk away from?
Ryker looked at me again, and this time the humor in his face faded.
“You don’t have to stay,” he said.
The words were simple. That was what made them dangerous.
The room went still.
I could leave. That was the obvious answer.
I could pack up my notes, walk out with Ryker, and step back into the easier version of my life—the one where breathing came naturally and conversations didn’t feel like traps.
It should have been simple.
It wasn’t.
I looked at Ryker first.
At the steadiness in him. The openness. The way being near him made everything feel less sharp.
Then I looked at Isaac.
Still sitting there. Still quiet. Watching me with that controlled expression that gave away almost nothing and somehow too much.
He didn’t tell me to stay.
If he had, I could have fought him on it. I was good at anger. Good at resistance. Good at pretending I still had control.
But he said nothing. He just looked at me like this mattered.
Like my answer mattered.
My bag was still open. My notes still spread across the table.
The unfinished equation between us was suddenly the least complicated thing in the room.
“This should be simple,” I said quietly.
“Yeah,” Ryker said. Softer this time. “It should.”
But leaving with Ryker made sense. And staying with Isaac didn’t.
Lately, that seemed to be the exact problem.
I looked between them one last time— at safety, at danger, at ease.
And whatever impossible thing kept pulling me back even when every smart part of me knew better.
Then I made the worst decision available to me.
Or maybe the most honest one.
I didn’t move.
And somehow… that felt like an answer.