Chapter 92: Chapter Seventy-One

Vivienne/First-person POV

I used to think love was enough.

That if I loved Emeline hard enough, fiercely enough, it would overwrite the truth. That I could raise her into someone whole without ever letting her know how she was broken. That the past could be starved out of her, starved out of me.

But that’s not how memory works. It doesn’t die. It hides. And now it’s clawing its way back up through the cracks in our lives—every time she looks at me with those questions in her eyes. Every time Edward says nothing but sees everything.

I watched him from the doorway.

His shoulders hunched in the familiar way they used to when he was painting something that frightened him. I knew that posture. I’d memorized it. Once, I loved him for it. Then I hated him for it. Now I don’t know what I feel when I look at him like this.

The sketches were on the floor. I recognized them instantly. The ones he swore he’d burned.

One of me. One of Emeline.

Neither of us as we are now.

And yet—exactly as we were.

“You kept them,” I said, though it felt like the words belonged to someone else.

He didn’t answer. His hands were ink-stained, trembling, the way they used to be after too many hours alone with his guilt and a brush. I hated seeing him like this. It brought something sharp and old to the surface. Grief? Anger? Love?

No. None of those. Not anymore.

I stepped closer, toward the sketches, toward the box. The metal tin I had thrown into the river a decade ago. Or thought I had. Edward was always good at hiding things—even from me.

I looked down at the drawing of Emeline.

Not the Emeline we had raised—but the Emeline we had lost. Or tried to. Her eyes stared back at me with that same haunted quality that kept me up at night. That scar on her temple. That tilt of her head. I’d seen it before.

In real life.

Not just on paper.

“She remembers,” I whispered, because I could feel it now. Deep in my marrow. “And it’s unraveling her.”

He looked at me then. Like he was seeing me for the first time in years. As if I had been a painting too—one he’d abandoned in a half-finished state, never sure if it was meant to be destroyed or saved.

“She asked about the fire,” I continued. “Not the one we told her about. The real one. The one no article ever published. The one no therapist dared mention.”

Edward’s face darkened.

“She was too young—”

“She wasn’t,” I cut in. “She wasn’t, Edward. We thought she wouldn’t remember, but she did. And you sketched it. You knew.”

He folded the paper in his lap. Gently. Like it was a wound.

“I tried to paint it away,” he murmured. “I thought if I created a new version of her, she could live inside it instead. But the mind doesn’t obey us.”

“No,” I said. “It doesn’t.”

For a moment, we stood there in silence. The air between us thick with things unsaid. The years we had built this lie into something too large to contain.

“She’s seeing the woman again,” I said.

Edward’s head snapped up. “What woman?”

“In the gallery,” I said. “In her dreams. Maybe in mine too. The one you used to draw before we met. Before any of this. She doesn’t speak. But Emeline sees her standing in the mirror. In the corner. Behind the glass.”

I swallowed. My mouth was dry. “She looks just like her.”

Edward’s voice was hollow. “Then it’s happening faster than I thought.”

“What is?”

He stood. And when he did, it felt final. Not like the ending of a conversation, but the beginning of a reckoning.

“She’s not remembering,” he said. “She’s becoming.”

My blood ran cold. “Becoming what?”

He didn’t answer.

Instead, he walked past me, out of the unfinished gallery, sketches in hand.

Leaving me alone with the portrait that wasn’t there.

The outline on the wall. The whisper in the dust.

And the feeling that, somehow, none of this was over.

It was only just beginning.