Chapter 93: Chapter Seventy-Two

Edward — Flashback

Sixteen Years Ago

The house was too quiet after Vivienne left. She had gone to her sister’s in the countryside to “clear her head,” but I knew what that really meant. She needed time away from me. Time away from the silence that hung in every corner of this place like mildew.

I didn’t blame her.

I had already painted the same woman seventeen times by then. In charcoal. In oils. On napkins, on canvas, on the back of receipts. Each version more distorted than the last. And each time, I was convinced I was capturing her final form—until I woke up the next day and realized I hadn’t even come close.

She didn’t have a name. I never gave her one.

But she came to me in the same dream every night.

A pale hallway. Wet floor.

A child’s cry in the distance.

Then her silhouette, just standing there.

Watching me.

Not malevolent.

Not benevolent.

Just… there.

It started after the fire. The first fire. The one we told no one about. The one that didn’t make the papers because it wasn’t supposed to exist. The one I blamed myself for even though I didn’t light the match.

That was the night the baby stopped crying.

And the night I first saw the woman.

She was at the end of Emeline’s nursery hall, bathed in shadow. I remember stumbling toward her, half-awake, half-frenzied, thinking maybe someone had broken in. But by the time I reached the hallway, it was empty. Smoke curled around my ankles. The wallpaper was blistering.

The crib was untouched. But Emeline… wasn’t breathing.

We never talk about that part.

We don’t talk about how long it took me to revive her. How I screamed for Vivienne, but she was frozen in the doorway, trembling like a leaf. How, when Emeline gasped back to life, she didn’t cry like she used to.

She just stared at me.

Like she recognized me for the first time.

Like she knew something I didn’t.

And then came the dreams.

The sketches.

The woman.

No matter how hard I tried to draw Emeline’s smile, I couldn’t capture it without the shadow behind her. She haunted every canvas. Every brushstroke.

I started locking the studio.

Not to keep Vivienne out.

To keep her in.

Sometimes I thought I heard Emeline giggling at the door. But when I opened it, there was nothing but the hiss of turpentine and the unfinished canvas with eyes that weren’t hers. Eyes that followed me.

One night, I buried all the sketches in a tin box and drove to the edge of town. I meant to burn them. I meant to let them go. But when I saw the water beneath the bridge, I realized I couldn’t. Fire wasn’t enough. I needed her to sink.

I thought that would be the end.

I was wrong.

Because months later, when Emeline began to speak again, her first word wasn’t “Mama” or “Dada.”

It was “her.”