Chapter 91: Chapter Seventy
Edward /First-person POV
I used to believe memory was a choice.
A sequence of impressions we could mold, discard, burn. I was wrong. Memory is a parasite. It gnaws, burrows, and breeds—until even silence screams in its own voice. I had silenced a thousand echoes, but lately, they’d begun to speak all at once.
Tonight, the museum felt colder than usual.
I walked the upper mezzanine with my hands tucked into my coat pockets, boots heavy on the marble. The air carried that particular stillness that only arises when the building has exhaled its last living breath. When all that’s left are shadows.
And memories.
I don’t know why I kept returning to the unfinished gallery—the one we sealed off before the new curation. The room with dust-covered pedestals, half-hung frames, forgotten plans. Perhaps I thought I could find the thing I lost there. Or the version of me that had once believed beauty could save the world.
The lights buzzed overhead. Dim. Flickering.
I stepped toward the back wall, toward the blank space that used to house her portrait. Not Vivienne. Not Emeline. The other her. The one I stopped painting the night I lost my name.
I traced the edges of the wall with my eyes, trying to recall where I’d placed the first stroke. The shape of her jaw. The hollows beneath her cheekbones. She had never spoken a word in life, but in that painting, her mouth had always looked on the verge of whispering something.
Edward, I could almost hear her.
A scraping sound startled me. I turned—but saw nothing.
Just air. Shadows. Dust.
I reached into my pocket and pulled out the folded page I’d hidden from Marlowe. The one Emeline had returned to me during our last encounter—though she hadn’t known what it was. It wasn’t just a sketch. It was a map. A loop. A coded memory.
In the center: three dots.
And below it, her eyes.
Not just drawn—but remembered.
I pressed my thumb to the ink. It smeared slightly, like it had never fully dried. My fingers trembled. My breathing stuttered. I wasn’t losing my mind—I was recovering it, piece by bloody piece.
I should’ve died that night in Florence.
The fire should’ve erased me.
But I didn’t. And ever since then, something—or someone—has been trying to remind me why.
I knelt by the far wall, pulled up a loose floorboard. Beneath it, the tin box remained. Locked. Rusted at the edges. I hadn’t opened it in twelve years.
I clicked it open with the key I still wore on my wrist. Inside, beneath a folded letter and an old cufflink, were the last two remaining sketches from my original collection. The ones no one ever saw.
I held them up to the light. And for the first time in years, I allowed myself to look.
One was of Vivienne.
But not as I knew her now.
Younger. Softer. Unmarked by grief.
The second was of Emeline.
But not the girl the world knew.
This version had eyes like her mother’s.
And a scar across her temple.
The kind I never gave her.
My stomach sank.
Because if this sketch was real—if this wasn’t some fragmented hallucination—then it meant I wasn’t the only one painting false memories.
It meant someone else had rewritten her.
The wall creaked behind me.
I turned slowly.
And this time, I wasn’t alone.
Vivienne stood at the threshold. Pale. Barefoot.
Eyes unreadable.
“You kept them,” she said, voice thin.
I said nothing.
She walked closer, staring down at the sketches. At the woman with no face. At the version of Emeline I had tried to forget. Her hands were shaking, but she didn’t try to hide them.
“She remembers,” Viv whispered. “And it’s unraveling her.”
I looked at her then. Really looked.
And for a split second, I saw the truth we’d buried.
She wasn’t protecting Emeline.
She was trying to replace her.