Mercy

Andrius slapped his cock on my cheek and Levi’s heavy breathing could be heard over the speaker. I only came minutes ago, but I’m still so wound up. The resounding smacks of skin against flesh have my pussy once again clamping around nothing. His tip teased my back entrance.

“Dear God,” I cried.

“You’re going to hurt her if you put it in like that. You gave her three fingers. That’s nothing compared to your wide girth,” Levi choked out.

He was trying to defend me, but I could hear it in his voice. He was both worried and turned on. The idea of Andrius stretching me wide open around his cock affected him, but being on the phone while he watched him do it, turned him on, too. He wanted to see Andrius try to make it fit as much as I did. It only made me wonder if he’d taken Andrius before. And that thought alone was enough to turn me feral.

“Poor Amia. Her vampire daddy doesn’t think she can take an alpha’s cock in the ass,” Andrius taunted.

“I-I can. I-I just need a minutes. You… you just finger fucked it. I haven’t slept with that many people and…”

I hadn’t meant to ask for a few minutes. Not at all. What I was going to say was that I couldn’t take him. My brain told me I needed to explain that last night with the two of them was the first time I’d had sex. Of my own choice. A shuddering breath escaped as I tried to close off the onslaught of memories of Dylan. He had no place here.

“It’s okay. You don’t have to explain. He’s not going to, are you?” Levi asked expectantly. His voice soothing, as if he knew where my thoughts strayed. Andrius scoffed.

“The last thing you want to do while I’m moments from claiming you, is remind me of the fact you’ve been with another,” Andrius growled. His grip on my hip was punishing and I flinched.

“Enough,” Levi snapped.

“It’s okay, L,” I whispered.

“It’s not. Tell her, Alpha.”

“I won’t say what I don’t mean,” Andrius teased.

I bit my lip to stifle a giggle. He was challenging him and I loved it. Levi was silent on the other end.

“I just need…” I trailed off.

“Time. She’s asked for mercy. We’re lenient. Our mistress needs ti—”

“See, that’s the thing. I don’t need her to tell me. I know her wants and needs. Other than this cock, Amia has already asked for punishment. She doesn’t think I’ll fuck her until the sun comes up, and she doesn’t think I’ll make her cum until she’s begging me to let her go.”

“Fuck. You can’t. She’s not… Last night was our fir—”

“Excuses, bloodsucker. You coddle her, and from what I can see, you’re not here. You’ve left her in my care, and I’ll decide what our bad little mistress can or can’t take,” Andrius taunted, cutting him off.

He was right.

A shiver ran down my spine. I’d caught on to what Andrius was doing, and Goddess, I agreed. He was trying to provoke Levi. I jerked as he slapped his cock on my ass again. This was a game and he had the upper hand. After all the bickering back and forth with Levi was done, he’d feed me his cock. I searched deep within me for fear, nerves, or anxiety, but found excitement. I liked this. I wanted him to give me what I needed. I loved Levi and everything he did for me, but Andrius wasn’t him.

What I got from our alpha was… freedom. I didn’t have to decide with him. I didn’t have to think or tell him what I needed, he just knew. I could let go with him and he’d take care of it. I didn’t have to worry about anything. And Andrius knew that. I smiled as Levi huffed. He was getting to our vampire and Andrius loved getting what he wanted. What was that? Levi. Angry. A smile spread across my face, but Andrius couldn’t see it. This might make Levi hurry what he was doing and come back to us. I’m down for whatever will bring him home.

“Do you trust me to give you what you need?”

“Yes,” I breathed.

His tip pressed against my hole.

“What are we going to do?” he taunted.

“About?” I whispered. He didn’t move and I wanted him to.

“There’s no one here to help you.”

His words should have triggered my trauma, but they didn’t. It only served as an aphrodisiac to my already wet pussy. Levi cursed and I loved that he struggled with wanting to protect me and see this play out.

“Alpha,” Levi spat.

At this point, Andrius paid my best friend no mind. I liked that he was ignoring him.

“I’m claiming this hole tonight, and there’s no one here to stop me, is there?” he growled. When I didn’t answer, he grabbed my hair and yanked it back, forcing my back to arch, my chin to tip, and my eyes to meet his.

“Yes, there’s no one here to stop you from fucking any hole you’d like,” I moaned.

“Mm, look who’s pretending to be a good girl,” Andrius chuckled.

Releasing me, my gaze lowered before darting to my left as movement caught my eye. I kept my back arched because I remembered how this position had helped me yesterday. I turned as Andrius placed the phone on our left. Levi watched us as our alpha faced me. My lips parted as I watched Levi track his movements. His hand cupped and squeezed my ass.

“I’ll either show you mercy, or I won’t. And you like that, don’t you, Amia?” he growled.

“Yes,” I hissed.

“You like knowing it’s just the two of us. Your sweet Levi can’t do anything to help you.”

His hand disappeared and came down with a smack on my ass. Hard.

“Say it,” He growled.

“I like that Levi isn’t here to stop you from fucking me,” I cried out.