Chapter 28 Reunion
Nora didn’t think. She didn’t plan. She just moved.
She burst out of the coffee shop, the bell above the door jangling violently. The barista called after her about the spilled coffee, but Nora was already on the street, running toward the figure in black who was walking away.
“Ben!” she shouted.
The figure stopped. Turned slowly. And even with the hood back up, even from this distance, Nora knew it was him. She knew it in her bones.
“Ben!” she called again, closing the distance between them.
He didn’t run or try to hide. He just stood there, frozen, as Nora approached. When she was close enough to see his face clearly under the hood, she stopped, suddenly unsure what to do. What to say.
They stared at each other for a long moment. The morning crowd flowed around them like water around stones. Car horns blared. Sirens wailed in the distance. But in that moment, they were the only two people in the world.
Ben’s face registered shock. Pure, complete shock. His mouth opened but no sound came out. His eyes went wide, scanning her face like he couldn’t believe what he was seeing.
“Nora?” he finally managed, his voice hoarse. “Is that really you?”
“You’ve been following me.” Nora’s voice was harder than she expected. “For weeks. You’ve been watching me.”
“I… I didn’t know if it was really you. I thought I was going crazy.” Ben took a step toward her, then seemed to think better of it and stopped. “I saw you leaving that bank three weeks ago and I thought I was seeing a ghost. You were declared dead, Nora. Years ago. Everyone thought you were dead.”
“You declared me dead.”
“Because you were gone! You disappeared! There was no trace, no sign, nothing!” Ben’s voice rose, drawing looks from passing pedestrians. He lowered it, stepping closer. “Please. Can we talk? Really talk? There’s so much I need to tell you. So much you don’t understand.”
“I don’t want to talk to you.”
“Nora, please.” Ben’s eyes were desperate now, pleading. “I’ve been looking at you from across the street for weeks, trying to work up the courage to approach you. Trying to figure out if you were real or if I’d finally lost my mind completely.”
“Why were you watching me instead of just talking to me?”
“Because I was scared! I was terrified you’d run, that you’d disappear again, that I’d lose you before I even got you back!” Ben ran his hand through his hair, a gesture so familiar it made Nora’s chest ache. “Please. Just give me an hour. One hour to explain. To tell you everything. And then if you never want to see me again, I’ll respect that. I’ll disappear. But please, Nora. For what we had. For what we were. Just talk to me.”
Nora looked at him. Really looked at him. He’d aged in the five years she’d been gone. There were lines around his eyes that hadn’t been there before. Gray at his temples. He looked thinner too, like he hadn’t been eating properly.
He also looked genuinely devastated. Genuinely shocked to see her. Like a man who’d been mourning his dead wife and just found out she was alive.
But Nora had learned not to trust appearances. Had learned that the most convincing lies often looked like truth.
“I don’t know if I should,” she said.
“I’m begging you. Please. I’ve searched for you for so long. Had so many questions. So much guilt.” Ben’s voice cracked. “I thought you were dead, Nora. I mourned you. I grieved you. And now you’re standing here in front of me and I don’t understand how or why but I need to know. I need to understand what happened to you.”
Nora thought about Noah back at their apartment. About the life they were building. About how this conversation could destroy everything.
But she also thought about her children. About the questions she’d never gotten answers to. About the life she’d lost and never fully understood why.
“My children,” she said, her voice barely above a whisper. “Where are my children, Ben?”
Ben’s face crumpled. “That’s one of the things we need to talk about. Please. Just an hour. There’s a café two blocks from here. Public place. Safe. Just you and me and answers to the questions we both have.”
Nora looked back toward the coffee shop where she’d been hiding. Toward the direction of the subway that would take her home to Noah.
Then she looked at Ben. At the man she’d once loved. At the father of her children. At the husband who’d declared her dead and moved on but was now standing in front of her begging for a chance to explain.
“One hour,” she finally said. “That’s all you get.”
Relief flooded Ben’s face. “Thank you. Thank you, Nora. You won’t regret this.”
But as they walked toward the café, side by side but not touching, Nora wondered if she already did.
\-----
The café was small and quiet, tucked away on a side street. Ben ordered coffee for both of them, remembered how she took hers even after all these years. Two sugars, no cream. The familiarity of it made Nora’s throat tight.
They sat at a corner table, away from the other patrons. For a long moment, neither of them spoke. They just looked at each other, years of questions and pain and loss sitting heavy between them.
“I don’t even know where to start,” Ben finally said.
“Start with the truth,” Nora replied. “Start with what happened after I disappeared. Start with why you declared me dead so quickly.”
Ben flinched at the accusation in her voice. “It wasn’t quick. It felt like an eternity. You disappeared without a trace, Nora. Your car was found abandoned in a grocery store parking lot. Your purse was still inside. Your phone. Everything. But you were just gone.”
“And?”
“And the police investigated. For months. They searched everywhere. Put out alerts. Checked security footage. Interviewed everyone we knew. But there was nothing. No leads. No evidence. It was like you’d just vanished into thin air.”
Ben’s hands wrapped around his coffee cup like he needed something to hold onto. “I looked for you. God, Nora, I looked everywhere. I hired private investigators. I put up flyers. I went on the news begging for information. I did everything I could think of.”
“For how long?”
“Three years. I looked for three years before I finally accepted that you might be gone forever.”
“The neighbors said you remarried a month after I disappeared.”
Ben’s head snapped up, his eyes flashing with something that looked like anger. “The neighbors lied. They’re wrong. I don’t know who told you that, but it’s not true.”
“Mr. Patterson said—”
“Mr. Patterson was always jealous of what we had. He and his wife were miserable together, and they couldn’t stand seeing us happy.” Ben leaned forward. “I didn’t remarry for three years, Nora. Three years of searching and grieving and slowly accepting that I’d never see you again. And even then, even when I finally tried to move on, it never felt right. She was never you.”
“She?” Nora’s voice was sharp. “So you did remarry.”
“Eventually, yes. But it was years later, not a month. And it didn't feel right. How could it? She wasn’t you.” Ben reached across the table like he wanted to take her hand, then pulled back. “Where have you been, Nora? What happened to you?”
Nora didn’t answer immediately. She studied his face, searching for signs of deception. But all she saw was genuine confusion.
“I was taken,” she said slowly. “Kidnapped. Held captive for five years.”
Ben’s face went white. “What? Kidnapped? By who? Where?”
“Does it matter?”
“Of course it matters! Someone took my wife, held her for five years, and you’re asking if it matters?” Ben’s voice rose again, then dropped to an urgent whisper. “Nora, we need to call the police. We need to report this. Whoever did this needs to be caught, needs to be punished—”
“No police.”
“What? Why not?”
“Because it’s complicated. Because getting the police involved would make things worse, not better.” Nora wrapped her arms around herself. “I escaped. I got away. That’s what matters.”
“But—”
“No police, Ben. I mean it.”
Ben looked like he wanted to argue but finally nodded. “Okay. No police. But Nora, you need to tell me what happened. Where you were. How you got away. I’ve spent five years wondering, and now you’re here and I need to understand.”
“I need to understand some things too. Like why our neighbors think you remarried immediately. Like where our children are. Like how you found me here in Toronto.”
Ben took a deep breath. “The neighbors are lying. I don’t know why, but they are. Maybe they’re confused. Maybe they’re trying to hurt you by making you think I gave up on you too quickly. But I didn’t. I swear to you, I didn’t.”
“Prove it.”
“How can I prove something that didn’t happen? I can show you the private investigator bills from the first two years of searching for you. I can show you the police reports, the news interviews, everything. I have documentation, Nora. Proof that I looked for you. That I never stopped loving you.”
He looked so earnest. So honest.
But Nora had learned that the best liars always looked honest.
“What about the children?” she asked. “Where are they?”
Ben’s expression changed.