Chapter 94: Cole

After I throw on some clothes, I head to the living room and switch on the TV, flipping through channels absently. I settle on some old sitcom reruns, but my mind’s not really in it. Every so often, I find myself glancing back down the hall toward Sofia’s room. She seemed so worn out earlier, and I can only hope she’s finally getting some rest.

After about half an hour, I decide to check on her one last time. I get up, leaving the TV on low, and head down the hallway to her room. I nudge the door open quietly, planning just to peek in, but then I hear it—faint, broken words drifting up from where she sleeps.

“Please… don’t hit me… please stop.”

My chest tightens instantly. The words are so soft, almost whispered, but they cut deep, a quiet plea echoing out of her memories. The ache in my heart is immediate, and I’m rooted to the spot, unsure whether to wake her or let her be. She stirs slightly, her face showing hints of distress, and I make a quick decision, stepping back out into the hallway and dialing Nate.

It rings a few times, and I wonder if he’s even up. But then he picks up, sounding a bit drowsy. “What’s up, Cole? Everything good?”

“Yeah… I mean, no.” I sigh, running a hand through my hair. “Sofia’s having nightmares. Bad ones. She’s mumbling things in her sleep, things like… ‘please don’t hit me,’ and ‘please stop.’ I didn’t want to wake her, but I don’t know if letting her go through it alone is the right move either.”

There’s a heavy pause, then a sigh from Nate’s end. “Yeah, that happens sometimes. She’s had nightmares like that, especially after everything that’s happened… they usually come out more when she’s alone.” His voice is low, weighted with frustration. “Look, if you need to stay with her, do it. Do whatever you think will make her feel safe, Cole. She needs to rest, and if you can help her, then… just be there for her.”

I nod, even though he can’t see it. “Alright. Thanks, man.”

“Take care of her, okay?” Nate’s voice is softer now, almost vulnerable.

“Of course,” I reply, and we hang up.

After ending the call with Nate, I head back into her room, heart heavy but determined to ease whatever she's going through. I lower myself carefully onto the bed beside her, not too close but close enough for her to feel I’m here. I reach out, gently taking her hand in mine, and start brushing my fingers through her hair, slow and steady, until she begins to settle.

“Shh… you’re safe, Sofia,” I whisper, my voice barely a murmur in the quiet room. "I’ve got you."

Gradually, her breathing evens out, her tense expression softening, the broken words fading away. I keep my hand in hers, stroking her hair with my other, grounding her, hoping my presence can pull her fully away from whatever nightmare she’s trapped in.

Eventually, her breathing becomes deep and calm, and I feel my own shoulders relax. Before I know it, exhaustion gets the best of me. My eyes start to close, and I don’t fight it. Still holding her hand, I drift off, keeping her fingers laced with mine for the rest of the night.

When I wake up, a few faint rays of morning light are slipping through the blinds, and Sofia is curled up against me, her head resting on my chest, her soft breathing steady and calm. I can’t help but smile down at her, my heart beating a little faster just taking in this moment. Her scent, warm and faintly like vanilla, fills the air, and I stay still, savoring the quiet.

But then she stirs, her eyes fluttering open, and when she realizes where she is, she jolts back, her cheeks going bright pink. “Oh my gosh, I—I’m so sorry!”

I chuckle, sitting up and meeting her eyes. “Don’t worry about it. You were having a nightmare,” I explain gently. “I called Nate to see what I should do. He mentioned you don’t like being alone, so I stayed.” I shrug, trying to keep it casual, though the truth is I’d do it again without a second thought.

Her expression softens, and she gives a small, grateful smile. “Thank you, Cole…"

“Anytime,” I say, watching her relax a bit. “Just glad I could help.”

Sofia’s sleepy yawn fades quickly as she glances at her phone, her face going as pale as a sheet, her mouth parting in shock. She stares at the screen, blinking as if she can’t quite believe what she’s seeing. Then, almost instantly, her eyes well up, and a tear slips down her cheek.

“Sofia, what’s wrong?” I ask, concern spiking through me as I reach for her phone. She doesn’t answer, just stares at the screen like it’s burned her. I gently take the phone from her, and as soon as I see the text, a mix of anger and disbelief rises up in me.

The message reads: “You’ve been replaced, skank.” Attached are photos of Brittany curled up in Leo’s bed, practically clinging to him like he’s her lifeline, and another one of Lindsey nestled against Riley, looking way too comfortable. It’s like they’ve staged it to hurt her as much as possible, to make her feel like she’s lost everything.

She’s trying to hold it together, but I can see it’s tearing her apart.

“Sofia,” I say softly, my heart breaking seeing her like this. “This isn’t what it looks like. You know the guys—there’s no way they’d let those girls anywhere near them, let alone in their beds.”

She shakes her head, wiping at her tears but they just keep falling. “But the pictures, Cole… they’re there. In their beds.” Her voice is a broken whisper, filled with pain and confusion.

I can’t stand seeing her like this. I reach out and pull her close, wrapping my arms around her as she buries her face against my shoulder. “I know, I know it looks bad. But you have to trust them. Those girls are ruthless, they’d do anything to hurt you. And this? This is just another one of their dirty tricks.”

I hold Sofia close, feeling her tremble against me, each of her soft cries pulling at something deep in my chest. I can’t stand the thought of her going through this alone, not for one second more.

Gently, I keep one arm around her and pick up my phone, dialing Nate and Danny in a group call. The ringing feels like it lasts forever, but finally, I hear Danny’s groggy voice, still thick with sleep. “Cole? It’s like—what time is it, man?”

I don’t answer his question, keeping my voice steady. “Check on Leo and Riley. Now.”

There’s a pause, then Nate’s voice, sharper, awake. “Is that… is that Sofia crying?” He asks, worry filtering through his tone.

I don’t say a word, just keep my jaw tight and stay quiet, my hand rubbing slow, soothing circles on Sofia’s back as I wait.

On the other end of the line, I hear some shuffling, footsteps, then—

“What the fuck!” It’s Riley, his voice furious, loud enough that even Sofia can hear. “Get your filthy hands off me! What are you even doing in here?” There’s more shuffling, chaos in the background, and then I hear Leo’s voice breaking through the noise, equally enraged. “Are you kidding me? Get out of my fucking room!”

There’s a flurry of panicked voices, Brittany and Lindsey pleading as they’re ordered out, the guys barking at them to leave. The whole thing is like a loud, tense storm of confusion and anger, and then I hit ‘End Call.’

I look down at Sofia, who’s watching me, her tear-streaked face holding a glimmer of hope. “See?” I say, my voice gentle but firm. “They didn’t have a clue those girls were even there.”

She lets out a shaky breath, the tension slowly easing from her shoulders as she leans into me. I hold her tighter, feeling her start to relax just a bit in my arms, her head resting on my shoulder.

“You’re the only one they want, Sofia,” I murmur, brushing my hand lightly over her hair. “And I’ll keep reminding you of that until you believe it.”