Chapter 95: Leo
I’m seething, pacing around the room, the fury rolling off me like heat. Lindsey stands there with that stupid, smug expression, and I can hardly believe she’s acting like this was some kind of victory. My hands ball into fists as I glance over at her phone, which she stupidly left unlocked on the edge of the bed.
“Get the hell out of here,” I growl, snatching the phone. The nerve of her. As if the guys and I don’t have enough on our plates without her stirring up drama just to mess with Sofia. I thumb through the photos Lindsey took, each one snapping the edge of my patience tighter. Photos of her, sleeping on the very bed I share with Sofia. I can feel my blood boiling.
“Why do you care so much, Leo?” Lindsey has the audacity to say, tilting her head in that innocent way she probably thinks is seductive. “Sofia’s just some girl. We could’ve had a lot more fun if you gave us a chance.”
I can barely think through the red haze clouding my thoughts. “Some girl?” I snap, chucking her phone at the wall so hard it shatters, pieces scattering across the floor. “Sofia is everything to me. She’s worth more than you’ll ever be, Lindsey.”
She recoils, startled, but I’m not done. “And get this straight—I wouldn’t want you or Brittany in my bed if you paid me.”
With that, I storm out of the room, my heart racing with the need to shake off this whole revolting situation. I catch sight of Riley dragging both girls out, his jaw clenched, his face cold with barely restrained anger. He’s silent, fuming in a way that makes it clear he’s on the edge.
He doesn’t say anything as he drags them down the hall to the gym, tossing them an apple and a bottle of water. He practically throws them inside and slams the door shut, locking it before spitting out, “That’s your last meal as far as I’m concerned. Consider yourselves warned.”
Then Riley and I just stand there, both of us breathing hard, sharing a look of mutual disgust. I can tell he’s as shaken by this as I am, even if neither of us will say it out loud. He mutters something I can’t catch and stalks off to clear his head.
I need to get rid of the feeling of her presence clinging to me. I go to the bathroom, cranking the shower as hot as it’ll go, and start scrubbing. And I don’t stop, not until my skin’s red and raw.
Once I’m out of the shower, feeling a little less like my skin’s crawling, I throw on some clothes and make my way to the living room. The guys are there, sipping their coffee, looking like they’ve barely slept. Danny glances up, brow raised, but he doesn’t say anything. I drop onto the couch across from them, still feeling the heat of anger simmering under my skin.
I take a deep breath. “Look, I messed up. Inviting Brittany and Lindsey here—that was a mistake.” I rub a hand over my face, not wanting to look any of them in the eye. “I just wanted the quickest way to get answers about their parents’ calls to Moretti’s guys. I didn’t think...I didn’t think it’d push Sofia away like this.”
Riley narrows his eyes a little but doesn’t say anything. Nate, who’s always calm, just lets out a sigh.
“But now look at us,” I continue. “She’s pissed, she’s staying with Cole, and he’s...” I trail off, reluctant to put words to what I’ve been feeling. “He’s in love with her.”
The guys’ heads snap up, Danny’s eyebrows shooting skyward. Riley’s jaw tightens, and Nate looks down, clearly chewing over what I just said.
“Oh, come on. I know you’ve noticed it too,” I mutter, running a frustrated hand through my hair. “Cole practically worships her. And now she’s over there, alone, pissed at us, and he’s right there to comfort her. In his place, in his bed, whatever.” The last words come out with a little more bitterness than I mean them to.
“Didn’t think you’d call him out like that,” Danny says, a smirk almost appearing before he shakes his head. “But yeah, now that you mention it, he does have that look when he’s around her.”
“He loves her.” I say again, as if saying it out loud makes the knot in my chest feel any lighter. “Cole’s the type who’d never cross a line, but I can’t deny he feels it. We all can see it.”
Riley leans back, eyes flicking to each of us, his face thoughtful. “Maybe we should’ve handled it differently.”
Nate clears his throat, glancing around at each of us before he speaks. “Look, there’s something you guys should know.” His voice is low, almost hesitant, which immediately puts me on edge.
“What’s up?” Riley asks, giving Nate a curious look.
“Last night… Cole probably slept in the same bed as Sofia.”
A heavy silence falls over the room. Danny’s coffee mug freezes mid-air, and Riley’s expression shifts from calm to something a lot closer to pissed. I can feel my jaw clench involuntarily.
“What?” Danny finally blurts, his voice laced with confusion and anger.
“Look,” Nate says quickly, holding up a hand, “nothing happened. I know it sounds bad, but hear me out.”
I try to keep calm, to not let the thoughts racing through my head make me jump to conclusions. “Why would you tell him that was okay?” I ask, my voice quieter but no less tense.
Nate sighs, rubbing his temples like he’s been dreading this. “Last night, she was having nightmares. Cole called me—said she was talking in her sleep, all kinds of painful stuff.” Nate swallows, his face serious. “I know what it’s like. She has a hard time sleeping alone after… everything. So yeah, I told him to stay. He respects us. He wouldn’t cross a line.”
Riley scoffs, running a hand through his hair. “You really think that makes it any easier to stomach?”
Nate holds his gaze steady. “He was worried about her. I was worried about her. We all know Cole has feelings for her, but I know he’s not the type to disrespect what we have. I thought you’d want to know—thought you deserved to know.”
I clench my fists, forcing myself to breathe slowly. "So he spent the night taking care of her while we messed up with Brittany and Lindsey right here." The weight of everything hits me harder than I expected, a bitter reminder of how badly we’ve handled this whole situation.
Danny, who’s been quiet this whole time, finally speaks up. “We have to make this right, and fast. I’m not about to let Cole, of all people, step up for her in ways we’re not.”
Danny leans back, folding his arms, a tense look on his face. “Look, I’m just gonna say it. What if… what if Sofia gets attached to Cole? I mean, he’s already there for her right now. And he’s been there for us for years. The guy’s one of our best, and you can’t deny he cares about her.”
Riley groans, rubbing his face. “You’re seriously suggesting that we should be okay with her wanting Cole, too?”
Danny shrugs, but his expression is more serious than indifferent. “We’re already four guys in this. We know she has enough love for us. If it makes her happy and she needs him… who are we to say it’s not okay?”
There’s a long pause as everyone absorbs that, and the atmosphere gets tense. Nate’s lips press into a thin line, and he shakes his head. “Look, I get it—Cole’s a great guy. He’s practically family. But bringing in another guy like it’s no big deal? It’s different.”
Leo leans forward, his eyes serious but thoughtful. “But what if it’s not different? She’s with four of us already. Maybe one more doesn’t change much in the big picture.” He sighs, like he’s wrestling with his own thoughts. “And if Sofia wants it, if she needs it? Who are we to deny her?”
Riley throws his hands up. “This is insane. I care about Cole, but how is that not crossing a line?”
Danny shoots Riley a look, his voice calm but firm. “Look, we’re all on edge, and we’ve handled things badly. But Cole? He’s always put us and her first. He wouldn’t even think of crossing that line without knowing it’s okay with us.”
Leo nods slowly. “Think about it. We’re all here to protect her and care for her. Adding Cole… might mean she’s even safer. More loved.”
Nate crosses his arms, but he looks uncertain now. “Let’s see what she wants. If it’s him too… then maybe. If it makes her happy, makes her feel secure... I guess we'll have to have a conversation with him.”