Chapter 93: Cole
We’re on the balcony, and Sofia’s talking about this book she’s been reading. Her voice is soft, animated, every now and then lighting up with this enthusiasm that’s so… Sofia. She’s so immersed in it, and I’m just here, listening, nodding along, completely wrapped up in her presence.
It’s strange, really. When I offered to let her crash at my place, it was just a simple gesture—a way to keep the peace after that mess back at the office. I thought if I could give her some space, let her have a little break, it’d help ease everything with the guys. But now, standing here with her, I’m starting to wonder if maybe I made a mistake.
It’s not that I don’t want her here; it’s exactly the opposite. The truth is, every time she’s near me, it’s like my brain just shuts down. I can’t think of anything else but her—the way her eyes light up when she talks, the way she leans a little closer to me, almost without realizing it. It’s a dangerous feeling, but it’s there. I’m smitten. That’s the only word for it. Completely and utterly taken with her.
And I know I can’t cross that line. She’s not mine to want, and that fact hits harder than I’d care to admit. Because I want nothing more than to keep her safe. Not just from the people out there who seem hell-bent on causing her harm, but… even from the guys. My own friends. They’re protective, sure, but they’re also making a mess of her heart.
“…and that’s why I love it,” she finishes, looking at me with that expectant smile.
I realize I’ve been staring at her and try to shake off whatever spell I’m under. “Sounds like a pretty incredible book,” I manage, hoping it sounds natural.
She nods, looking out over the city. Her expression shifts, the light dimming just a bit. “It’s just nice to think about something simple, you know? Like a world where… I don’t know, people are straightforward, where things don’t get complicated.”
“Yeah, I get that.” I rest my arms on the railing next to her. “Wouldn’t mind a life like that myself.”
She looks up at me, and for a second, it’s just us. No drama, no stakes, no dark clouds looming on the horizon. Just this quiet, calm moment on a balcony above the city lights. And damn, if it isn’t perfect.
Before I can lose myself too much in that thought, I clear my throat. “I’m glad you’re here, Sofia. And… if there’s anything you need while you’re here, you just let me know, okay?”
“Thanks, Cole,” she says, her voice gentle. “For everything.”
I nod, but in my mind, I’m already making a promise. I’ll do whatever it takes to protect her. Even if that means keeping my own feelings buried, right where they belong.
She shivers, the night air a little cooler now, and I can’t help but ask, “Do you want to go inside? It’s freezing out here.”
Sofia nods, and as we step back into the warm light of the condo, I glance at the time. It’s still early morning, but I can tell she needs the rest. “You should get some sleep,” I tell her, “Take my bed; I’ll crash on the couch.”
She shakes her head immediately, and I already know what’s coming. “No way, Cole. You’ve done too much already. I’m fine here on the couch; I’ll sleep right there.” She crosses her arms and plants her feet like she’s setting up for a battle.
“Nice try.” I grin, stepping closer. “But nope, not happening.”
She holds her ground, a stubborn glint in her eye. “Nope. I’m not moving.”
I sigh, looking at her for a second, then, without another thought, scoop her up, hoisting her over my shoulder. She squeals and breaks into laughter, her giggles filling the room as I carry her toward the bedroom.
“Cole, put me down!” She’s still laughing, trying to sound serious, but the laughter betrays her.
“Sorry, princess,” I say, laughing a little myself. “But this is the only way you’re going to listen.” I carry her over to the bed and carefully set her down, her laughter bubbling over as she settles into the blankets.
Turning away with a smirk, I say, “There, it’s settled. Good night,” I try to keep my tone light, casual, but the smile in her eyes as she looks up at me makes something tighten in my chest.
“Thanks, Cole,” she says, still a little breathless.
I nod, hoping she doesn’t notice how fast my heart’s pounding as I head toward the door. “Sleep well, Sofia.”
The second I step out, I let out a deep breath, my heart racing. It’s crazy, but I can’t deny it any longer—I’m completely caught up in her. I go straight to the bathroom, needing a cold shower to settle my nerves and clear my head. I know from the pain I feel down there from the restraint of my jeans that she's got me rock hard, too. I make sure to find a quick release while in the shower, something that proves to be easy after being this close to her.
It takes a second for me to register the scream over the hum of the water. But once I do, I’m out of the shower in a heartbeat, grabbing a towel and wrapping it around my waist as I run toward her room, nearly slipping on the water trailing behind me.
“Sofia?” I’m at her side in seconds, dropping to my knees beside the bed, and I reach for her hand, still damp and chilled from my rushed dash. She’s curled up, her cheeks streaked with fresh tears, her body shaking like she’s trying to hold it all together. “Sofia, what’s wrong? I’m right here.”
Her voice breaks as she tries to speak. “Cole, I—I’m sorry.” Her words spill out between gasping breaths. “I just—I fell asleep, and… I had this nightmare. I didn’t mean to… to disturb you.” Her voice wobbles, her eyes so wide with guilt it nearly floors me. She’s apologizing, and I can barely stand it.
“Hey, no, no. You don’t have to apologize for anything,” I murmur, squeezing her hand gently, like that alone can ease her mind. I can feel her grip tighten a bit in response, and I try to focus on that, ignoring the sting of seeing her in this kind of pain. “You don’t ever have to apologize for this.”
She takes a shaky breath, still looking down, but I reach out and gently tuck her hair back from her face. “Was it the same nightmare?” I ask softly.
She nods, barely lifting her head. “I… I saw them. My parents. And Moretti. They just… wouldn’t leave me alone.”
I feel a surge of protectiveness and anger I can barely contain. “They can’t touch you, Sofia. They’re gone now, and we’re all here to make sure they never come near you again.”
Her breathing starts to slow, just a bit. She takes in what I’m saying, the tension in her shoulders starting to fade. I stay there, sitting on the edge of the bed, just holding her hand and watching as her breathing steadies.
“Thank you, Cole,” she whispers, finally lifting her eyes to meet mine.
As her eyes fully focus on me, I see her expression shift from relief to a new kind of panic. Her cheeks go bright red, and she looks down quickly, trying to hide it but failing miserably.
“Oh my God, Cole, I’m so sorry… I interrupted your shower.” Her words come out in a flustered rush, and she starts to pull her hand back like she’s trying to give me space.
Realizing I’m still in nothing but a towel, dripping water onto the floor, I give a soft laugh, hoping it’ll ease her embarrassment. “Hey, no big deal. You’re a bit more important than a shower, don’t you think?”
She hesitates, her blush deepening. “I just… I feel so bad.” Her eyes dart around the room, clearly trying to look anywhere but at me.
I shake my head, chuckling a bit, and gently bring her gaze back to mine. “Don’t apologize, really. I’m here for you, no matter what I’m doing or—uh, wearing.” I can’t help but smirk a little at that, hoping she catches the humor.
She lets out a small, nervous laugh, her hand still in mine. “Thank you, Cole. Really. I… I didn’t mean to call you in like this.”
“Anytime, Sofia,” I say softly, and I can feel my own face warm a little under her gaze. The way she’s looking at me is making it hard to think about anything but staying right here with her, towel and all.
I smile, then gently squeeze her hand. “Now, how about I throw on some clothes, and we can both get some rest?”
She nods, giving me a shy smile as I reluctantly stand up to leave, half-wishing I could stay with her all night.