Chapter 171
The rhythmic thwack-thwack of the knife against the wooden cutting board was the only sound in the kitchen as Olivia focused on the tomatoes. She was operating on autopilot, her mind still caught in the gray static of the living room conversation. When the heavy, rhythmic thud of footsteps approached, she didn't look up, assuming Isabella or Tessa had followed her to continue the interrogation.
The footsteps stopped abruptly at the doorway. The air changed, and a scent hit her. It was a fragrance that was woven into her most painful and beautiful memories. Olivia’s hand froze, the knife hovering over a half-sliced tomato. She didn't need to look up to know who was standing in the doorway. The very molecules in the room seemed to vibrate with his presence.
Derek stood still, the grocery bags straining against his knuckles. His eyes wide and dark as they locked onto her. Olivia finally risked a glance, and the sight of him made her chest ache.
He was wearing black jeans and a black-and-white striped shirt that looked lived-in, almost rumpled. His beard had grown out into a thick, dark shadow that traced the hard line of his jaw, giving him a rugged, unkempt edge. He looked very different, Olivia couldn't help but observe. Not as put together and overly confident as he usually was. Still hot of course, because he was Derek, still unfairly, infuriatingly handsome, but she couldn't help but notice the change.
“I… Urmm… I didn't know you were in here,” Derek said, his voice a low, gravelly friction that scraped against her nerves.
It took an agonizing second for Olivia to find her breath. “It’s fine,” she replied, her voice sounding thin and hauntingly distant to her own ears.
He didn't move for a long moment, his gaze traveling over her with a starving intensity, as if he were trying to memorize every detail of her face to survive another two weeks of silence… Or however long it'd be before he saw her again.
Finally, he gave a sharp, stiff nod toward the counter. “I’ll just drop these over there and get out of your way,”
He stepped fully into the kitchen, and the space felt like it was shrinking. Olivia tried to return her focus to the tomatoes, but her peripheral vision was betraying her, tracking every move he made and the way his muscles bunched under his shirt as he set the bags down. She felt a sickening, beautiful surge of joy at the sight of him, followed immediately by a crushing wave of hurt, sadness and grief.
Derek dumped the bags on the table with a muffled thud, completely disregarding Isabella’s instructions to put the items away. With Olivia in the room, she'd have to do that herself. He needed to leave. Every second he spent alone in this room with her was a gamble. He was almost terrified that if he stayed, he’d either say something spectacularly stupid that would ignite her fury all over again, or he’d lose his pride entirely, drop to his knees on the linoleum, and beg her for a mercy he knew he hadn't earned. Both paths felt like they would only have the same outcome —drive her further away from him.
He turned to make a break for the door, his heart hammering a frantic rhythm against his ribs, but stopped dead when her voice sliced through the tension.
“Izzy isn't going to appreciate you leaving those on the table,” she said quietly, still not looking at him. “Especially the frozen things. They’ll get soggy.”
When he turned back, he found her watching him, her expression a mask of weary composure. “You don’t have to leave the room because of me, Derek. Izzy is my best friend and she’s your sister, so we're going to run into each other sometimes whether we like it or not. We might as well get used to the sight of each other.”
Whether we like it or not?
The words twisted in Derek’s gut. Hell, he liked it. He was pathetic, he knew it, but he would take a thousand of these awkward, stinging encounters over the void of not seeing her at all. The fact that she wasn't bolting for the exit as soon as she saw him—the fact that she was standing her ground and speaking to him with that devastating, quiet maturity—was just more proof of the irreplaceable woman he’d managed to let slip out of his fingers. He'd fumbled her… Hard.
“Right,” he managed to rasp out, his hand hovering over the grocery bag. “The frozen stuff. I’ll… I’ll put them away I guess.”
Derek began methodically pulling items from the bags—milk, eggs, a carton of juice—his movements stiff as if he were navigating a minefield. Across the marble island, Olivia reached for a red onion, the sharp scent filling the space as she resumed the rhythmic snick-snick of her blade.
He reached up to a high cupboard where Isabella usually shoved the dry goods and tugged the handle, but the contents had clearly been packed with Izzy’s trademark lack of organizational skills. The moment the door swung open, a literal landslide of cardboard occurred. Two oversized boxes of granola came tumbling out in a blur of yellow and blue, bouncing off his forehead with a dull thwack before hitting the counter.
“Fucking hell,” he spat, the frustration in him finally boiling over into a muffled snarl. He swiped a hand over his face, looking utterly defeated by a box of oats.
Olivia bit her inside lip, but it was no use. A small, involuntary huff of a laugh escaped her, and a genuine smile flickered across her lips—quick and bright as a lightning strike—before she managed to flatten her expression back into a mask of neutrality. It was a terrifying realization; even now, even after the wreckage, the sight of him being humanly clumsy was enough to bypass her defenses. Damn, even staying mad at him was hard too.
“There’s an extra cabinet for the overflow right next to that one,” she supplied, her voice a fraction warmer than it had been. “Izzy tends to overstuff the main one.”
Derek glanced at her, rubbing the spot where the box had clipped him. He looked almost sheepish, the fierce "badboy reputation" persona nowhere to be found. “Right. Yeah. Thanks,” he muttered, moving the boxes to their proper home.
Olivia gave a small, jerky nod and pivoted toward the toaster, sliding two slices of bread into the slots. For the next minute, the only sounds were the low hum of the refrigerator and the crinkle of plastic as Derek finished the groceries. They moved in a delicate, unintended dance—stealing short, searing glances at one another whenever the other looked away.