Chapter 170
"Let her be, Izzy," she said, her voice flat and brittle. "If she found someone who actually knows how to show up, she should go. Good for her." She shifted in her seat, smoothing the fabric of her jeans with a robotic precision. "I, for one, have a very detailed itinerary. I plan on fighting the crowds for groceries, cooking myself a nice meal, and sitting all day in my living room."
She leaned her head back, a dark, cynical shadow crossing her face. "I'll be eating, drinking a very expensive bottle of wine, and spending the day cataloging every spectacularly bad decision I’ve made this year. It’s a full schedule. Very busy."
Isabella’s playful expression faltered. She looked at Olivia, seeing the dark circles under her eyes that no amount of concealer could truly hide. The "bad decisions" were a clear reference to a certain dark-haired man with a granite profile—her brother, but Olivia’s tone made it clear that the topic was a closed borders policy.
"Liv..." Isabella started, her voice softening with concern.
"Don't," Olivia cut her off, forcing a tight, practiced smile that didn't reach her eyes. "Please… You really don't have to,”
“Oh yes, I do,” Isabella sat up straighter, the energy she’d been trying to cultivate finally snapping under the weight of Olivia’s cold indifference. “You know, you’ve been like this for two weeks now,” she said, her voice dropping the performative cheer and replacing it with a raw, sharp concern. “Both of you. You and Derek.” She lifted her hands, palms up as if searching for an explanation in the air, before dropping them heavily against her thighs. “Is either one of you ever going to tell me what actually happened that night? Because I am exhausted, Olivia. I’m tired of the atmosphere changing every time one of you is mentioned.”
Olivia's jaw tightened, a small muscle jumping in her cheek. She finally turned away from the window, her gaze flat and guarded. “I don’t want to talk about it, Izzy. Truly. Because he's your brother, and the last thing I want is for you to feel like you have to start taking sides in a fight you didn't start.”
The word ‘sides’ hit Isabella like a physical slap, and her expression crumbled from frustration into genuine hurt. “Take sides?” she repeated, her voice rising with a frantic, wounded edge. She shook her head. “You know, this is exactly why I was so worried when I found out about the two of you. This is the nightmare scenario I played out in my head—that I’d end up standing in the wreckage, watching my best friend and my brother tear each other apart until I’m stuck in the middle of it. And just like I feared, here we are. Look at us.”
Tessa leaned forward, her brow arched in a sharp line. “Are you saying you’re choosing, Izzy?”
Isabella pivoted to glare at her, the hurt flashing into a brief, defensive spark. “Of course I’m not choosing, Tess! I couldn't even if I wanted to.”
She turned back to Olivia, her shoulders slumping as the fight drained out of her. “All I’m saying is that I miss my friend. And I miss my brother. It’s written all over your faces that you’re both miserable. You’re both starving for each other, but you’re so damn stubborn that you’d rather sit alone on Christmas and catalog your 'bad decisions' than pick up a phone and admit you’re human.”
The silence that followed was heavy with the truth Isabella had just laid bare. Olivia looked away, her throat working as she swallowed hard, the "stubbornness" Izzy mentioned acting as the only thing still keeping her upright. She couldn't do this—couldn't sit here and let Isabella’s genuine grief over their friendship act as a mirror for her own.
“Please, Izzy, don't ever feel like you have to pick a side between me and your brother,” she said, her voice softening, losing its defensive edge for a fleeting moment of sincerity. “That’s the last thing I ever wanted, and I’m so sorry I made you feel like you have to.”
She stood up abruptly, the movement a clear, non-verbal period at the end of the conversation. She needed a wall, a door, a different room—anything to stop the interrogation. “I’m going to go make myself a sandwich. Hope your kitchen is full.”
She walked away toward the kitchen, leaving Isabella and Tessa anchored in a heavy, contemplative silence.
“Do you think she’s going to feel better soon?” Tessa whispered the second Olivia was out of earshot, her eyes darting toward the hallway. “Or is this just… the new normal?”
Isabella shook her head, her expression a clouded map of uncertainty. “I have no idea. I just…” She trailed off, her sentence cut short by the distinct thud of the front door unlocking. Her brows shot up, a spark of pure, chaotic mischief lighting up her eyes. “Well. Speaking of the devil.”
Derek stepped into the foyer seconds later, looking like a man who hadn't slept since the last time they’d seen him. His shoulders were set in a weary line, and he was carrying two overflowing brown paper bags. “Got your stuff,” he grunted, his voice a low, rough rasp. He caught sight of the armchair. “Oh. Hi, Tessa.”
“Hi, Derek,” Tessa replied, waving a hand while giving Isabella a pointed look.
Derek turned his focus back to his sister, dropping the bags onto the nearest table with a heavy thud. “I have no idea when I officially became your personal grocery shopper or delivery service, Izzy. But just so you know—I’m deleting the next list you text me without reading it.”
Isabella didn't look even remotely repentant. She leaned back into the cushions, crossing her arms with a smug tilt of her chin. “If you want to keep showing up here and eating my food whenever the mood strikes you, you’ll do exactly what I tell you to do. Now, don't just leave them there. Take them into the kitchen and put them away.”
Derek narrowed his eyes, a flicker of his old irritation sparking, but he didn't have the energy to argue. He grabbed the bags, the plastic handles straining against his grip, and began heading toward the kitchen with the heavy, rhythmic gait of a man just trying to get through the day.
Tessa turned to Isabella, her eyes wide with a mix of horror and disbelief as she watched his back disappear around the corner. “Are you seriously not going to tell him Olivia is in there?” she hissed.
Isabella’s lips curled into a slow grin—the first real smile she’d worn all afternoon. “Not a chance in hell,” she whispered.