Chapter 172
Derek finally folded the empty paper bags with obsessive neatness, but his boots stayed rooted to the floor. The exit was right there, but the gravitational pull of the woman three feet away was too strong to break.
He leaned back against the counter, his large frame suddenly making the kitchen feel intimate instead of crowded.
He waited until Olivia could no longer pretend to be fascinated by the bread, until she finally looked up, her eyes wide and shimmering with a mix of apprehension and something that he couldn't place.
“How are you, Liv?” he asked with a terrifyingly gentle sincerity that made her heart skip.
“I’m fine,” Olivia replied. The words were a soft shield, brittle and translucent. She watched him with the wary intensity of someone tracking a storm on the horizon, watching him closely, as if trying to guess or figure out his next move.
Derek gave a slow, jagged nod. He didn't miss the skepticism in her eyes; he’d planted the seeds for it himself, and now he was forced to stand in the garden of his own making. He was a mess—a jagged collection of regrets held together by a lived-in shirt and the desperate need for her to look at him without flinching. He himself didn't know what his next move would be, but at the moment, he just wanted… needed her to forgive him.
“How are you?” Olivia asked.
The question almost pulled a ghost of a laugh from him, but it died in his throat. He was a mess. If he thought he felt terrible before, then it was even worst now, because the only thing worst than thinking she'd dumped him because she didn't feel something for him, was knowing that she had all along, and he'd had no fucking idea. Knowing that what he wanted had been right in front of him, and that he could have had it if he hadn't been too worried about the wrong things… That hit differently.
He couldn't bring himself to lie to her about being okay, and the truth was too ugly to dump on her, so he decided to skip answering her question. He took a single, instinctive step toward her, but the way her pupils blew wide and her shoulders hitched stopped him dead. He retreated that step immediately, rooting himself to the spot.
“Liv,” he began, his voice cracking like dry earth. “I just want to apologize…”
She was already shaking her head, her hands gripping the edge of the marble island until her knuckles almost turned the color of the onion skin. “Derek… It’s fine. You don’t have to.”
“Oh, but I do,” he countered, the desperation finally bleeding through. “I really do. So please… just let me say this. Please.”
The silence that followed was heavy, filled only by the low, domestic hum of the toaster and the frantic beat of two hearts out of sync. Olivia didn't look away or try to stop him again, and he took that as his only mercy.
“I’m sorry about the things I said… about Jack.” He closed his eyes for a second, his face contorting as if the memory physically pained him, ashamed of it. “Angry or not, it doesn’t matter. It was a low blow. It was wrong, and I hate that I let those words touch you.”
Olivia felt the first sting of tears. She didn't blink; she couldn't. Her appetite had vanished, replaced by a hollow ache that seemed to expand with every word he spoke.
“I’m sorry I started us off wrongly because I was terrified,” Derek continued, his gaze fixed on her with a starving sincerity. “I’m sorry I was so blind that I couldn't see what was right in front of me. I was so busy protecting my own ego that I didn't see…” He paused before he continued, “... that I didn't see you. I was selfish, Liv. I didn't want to give up control, and that's why it took me so long to admit to my myself how much you meant to me,”
He reached out, his fingers twitching as if to touch her, but there was too much distance between them, both physically and emotionally, and honestly, he didn't think that she'd have let him touch her if he was standing close enough, so he let his hand drop awkwardly back to his side like a lead weight.
“I don’t deserve your forgiveness. I know that, and I honestly won't blame you if you decide not to give it. I’m having a hell of a time forgiving myself,” he admitted, his voice dropping to a gravelly whisper. “But I had to tell you.”
Thump-ping…
The toaster finished its cycle, the smell of scorched bread wafting into the air, but neither of them moved. Olivia’s eyes were locked on his. She'd never seen him so open, at least not emotionally. Not this way. Their relationship had been mostly physical, and this wasn't the same Derek who had a smirk for every occasion or a sarcastic or funny comment to deflect any hint of real feeling. The "bad boy" armor had been stripped away, leaving something raw and painfully human underneath.
There was a deep, echoing sadness in his eyes that acted like a mirror to her own. It was a shared torture—the longing for a bridge that they both feared was permanently burned.
“You’re so kind, and sweet and so goddamn beautiful, Liv,” he said, his voice softening into a terrifyingly gentle caress. “And when I met you, I was… drawn to that energy and light in you. I know I'm apologising for so much, but I’m sorry I didn't know how to handle it. I hope you believe me. I really do.”
He waited. The seconds stretched, agonizingly long, as he searched her face for a sign—a softening of her jaw, a movement of her lips. But Olivia was paralysed by her emotions, her throat tight with a sob she refused to let break.
Derek misread the silence. He saw the shimmer in her eyes not as a beginning, but as a finality, or perhaps he understood that she still needed some time. He let out a long, ragged sigh that sounded like a surrender, then he straightened his shoulders and took one last, lingering look at her before he turned and walked out without another word.
Only when he left did the first tear finally escape, carving a hot path down her cheek to the cold marble below.