Chapter 169
The silence in the interior of the car was deafening.
Derek sat in the driver’s seat, his hands gripping the steering wheel at ten and two, his knuckles white. He didn't start the engine. He couldn't. He just stared through the windshield at the darkened street, the image of Olivia—angry, trembling, and utterly broken—burned into his retinas like a solar flare.
“I fell for you. Hard.”
The words looped in his brain, a jagged, beautiful record skip. She had loved him. While he was playing it cool, while he was hiding behind the "nothing serious" shield he’d built to protect his own pathetic heart, she had been drowning. And he hadn't reached out to save her.
He let out a jagged, hollow sound—half-sob, half-laugh—and finally turned the key. The engine roared to life, a mindless, mechanical beast that didn't care about the wreckage he’d left behind.
He drove aimlessly through the city, the neon lights of the midnight streets blurring into streaks of garish color. He didn't want to go home just to be alone with his thoughts. Every red light felt like a physical barrier, every green light a taunt. He found himself checking his phone at every stop, hoping for a text he knew would never come. A text telling him to come back. Telling him that she forgave him for being so selfish and ignorant of her feelings. Anything would be better than this hollow, vibrating vacuum in his chest.
“How could you be so blind, you asshole?”
He deserved every syllable, because indeed he'd been blind to her feelings. He’d been so worried about Jack—a ghost, a shadow of a man who didn't even deserve to breathe the same air as her—that he’d missed the living, breathing woman right in front of him. He’d been so busy guarding the exit that he hadn't realized she was already inside, trying to find a reason to stay.
He drove aimlessly for a long time before he finally pulled into the driveway of his building and cut the engine. The silence rushed back in, suffocating and cold. He couldn't even bring himself to go inside… Not yet. He leaned his forehead against the cool leather of the steering wheel and let the air out of his lungs in a long, shaky breath.
He had the truth now. He had everything he’d ever wanted to hear from her, except he was too late. And he’d paid for it with the only thing that mattered: her trust.
—----------
Olivia stood in the living room, her back pressed against the cold, hard wall. Her legs felt like they were made of water, and her chest ached with a physical pressure that made every breath a chore.
He was gone.
The silence he’d left behind wasn't the peaceful quiet of a sanctuary; it was the ringing, empty silence of a tomb. She stared at the spot where he’d stood—where he’d loomed over her, eyes dark with a hunger that had turned into a weapon.
She could still feel the phantom heat of his hands on her thighs, the rough friction of his lips against hers. Her skin felt electric and raw, a map of a war that neither of them had won.
With a shaky hand, she reached out and touched her lips. They were swollen, stinging from the salt of her tears and the ferocity of his kiss. A penance, she had thought. He had been punishing her, but in the end, they were both bleeding.
She moved away from the wall, her heels clicking hollowly on the hardwood. She didn't turn on the lights because she didn't want to see the space where they had just dismantled each other. Instead, she wandered into the kitchen, her movements robotic, and leaned against the counter.
The anger was gone now, replaced by a crushing, leaden weight of exhaustion. She had finally said it. She’d laid it all out—the love, the fear, the reason she’d run. She had stripped herself bare in front of him, and all she had left was the cold air of her own apartment.
A fresh sob caught in her throat, sharp and sudden. She bit her lip, trying to force it back, but it was no use. The dam had broken. She sank to a chair, and buried her face in her hands. She cried for the girl who had been too afraid to stay. She cried for the man who was too broken to see her. But mostly, she cried for the "mistake" she knew she would make a thousand times over if it meant she could have just one more second where they were happy in each other's presence and he looked at her like she was the only thing in his world.
The truth was out. The secret was dead, and as she sat there, Olivia realized that the truth hadn't set her free. It had just left her alone.
____________
"So, my parents have officially fled the country for their vacation," Isabella announced, her voice echoing slightly in the quiet of her living room. She was sprawled bonelessly across the velvet sofa, staring at the ceiling as if the blueprints for her holiday survival were hidden in the crown molding. "The foundation’s year-end gala is over, the decorations are up, and I have absolutely no strategy for Christmas Eve. Or Christmas Day.”
She rolled her head to the side, her gaze swinging between Olivia and Tessa. "Does anyone have a suggestion that doesn't involve us sitting in our respective apartments, slowly being reclaimed by the upholstery?"
Tessa, perched on the edge of an armchair with her phone clutched in her lap, gave a non-committal shrug. "Well," she started, a small, traitorous smirk tugging at the corner of her mouth. "I actually met someone. So, I don’t think I’ll be joining the 'Lonely Hearts Club' this year."
Isabella bolted upright, her eyes widening. "Wait—what? You’re going to abandon us? For a man?" She grabbed a decorative throw pillow and launched it with mock ferocity. "Traitor! Who is he? When did this happen?"
Tessa caught the pillow with practiced ease, tucking it firmly beside her like a shield. "I'm not abandoning anyone, Izzy. It’s just... early stages. But he invited me to his family’s brunch, and I think I'm actually going to go."
The room fell quiet for a beat, the celebratory news of Tessa’s romance highlighting the vacuum in the rest of the group.
Olivia, who had been staring out the window at the gray, winter sky, finally let out a long, weary sigh. She looked uninterested, or perhaps just exhausted by the effort of pretending to be okay.