Chapter 21: Shared by my Ex’s friends 4

The blindfold was still tight around her eyes.

Elena had lost all sense of time. She didn’t know how long she had been in that room, surrounded by them. The world outside no longer existed. It was just the sound of their voices, their breaths, the weight of their hands. Her wrists throbbed against the rope, the knot digging deeper into her skin every time she moved.

Someone had turned off the lamp. The air felt heavier in the darkness, thicker. The sound of the floor creaking told her that at least two of them were still moving around her. The third had barely spoken since the blindfold went on.

Logan’s voice finally broke the silence. “You’re so quiet now.”

She tensed. His voice was closer than she’d expected.

Cyrus laughed low near the door. “Not so bold without your eyes, huh?”

Dean’s fingers grazed the back of her neck. “She’s learning.”

“Learning what?” she whispered. Her voice sounded small, foreign.

Logan’s hand slid up her thigh, forcing her legs apart slowly, like he was testing how much resistance was left in her. “That this is our game now.”

She twisted against the rope. “Let me go.”

Dean brushed his lips against her ear. “No one lets go in this house.”

Logan’s touch became firmer. Cyrus moved closer, the sound of his footsteps slow and deliberate. She could smell the whiskey on his breath before his fingers touched her jaw. He tilted her chin upward, making her face the direction of his voice.

“We’ll make it simple,” Cyrus said softly. “You play along, or we make you. Either way, you’re staying right here.”

“I hate you,” she spat, though it came out shaky.

Logan chuckled against her thigh. “You’re shaking too much to hate us.”

Dean tugged gently on the blindfold but didn’t remove it. “She’s better like this. She can’t pretend anymore.”

Her breath caught when Cyrus’s mouth brushed her lower lip. The softest touch. Almost kind. It made everything worse. Her legs trembled. She hated the way her body betrayed her, the way every nerve reached for more even when her mind screamed no.

“Let’s play,” Logan said.

The bed dipped as they shifted their weight. Her heartbeat filled the silence. Hands slid up her arms, down her waist, over her hips. She couldn’t tell who was touching her anymore. Their movements were coordinated, practiced. Someone tilted her head back. Someone else lifted her leg, dragging her to the center of the mattress.

“Here’s the game,” Dean whispered against her ear. “We ask. You answer. If we like it, we give you what you’re already begging for.”

“I’m not—”

Logan’s hand slipped between her thighs, cutting off her protest. She gasped. Her back arched against the mattress.

“You are,” he said softly.

Cyrus’s thumb brushed the corner of her mouth, smearing the moisture at her lip. “What do you want, Elena?”

She shook her head. “Nothing.”

Dean tightened his grip on her wrists, pulling them slightly upward. “Wrong answer.”

Logan’s fingers slid higher. Her breath hitched, coming out in shaky bursts.

Cyrus leaned closer until his breath warmed her ear. “Try again.”

She bit down on her lip.

Dean’s voice was low and calm. “Say it. Or we’ll keep going until your body says it for you.”

She whimpered, her voice breaking. “Stop.”

Logan’s touch only grew slower, crueler, like he enjoyed watching her unravel inch by inch. Cyrus’s mouth brushed the side of her throat. Dean’s hands tightened on her wrists.

“Say it,” Cyrus whispered.

Her body shuddered. Her mind told her to hold on. But the heat pressing against her made it impossible. The blindfold stripped away everything she could use to fight back. All that was left was sensation.

She let out a broken sound. “I want—”

Logan’s grin could be heard in his voice. “Good girl.”

Dean kissed the curve of her shoulder. “See? That wasn’t so hard.”

Cyrus’s thumb dragged over her bottom lip again. “Now beg.”

Her breath trembled. “Please.”

They moved like they’d been waiting for that word. Logan slid lower, his mouth finding the inside of her thigh. Dean loosened the ropes just enough to pull her arms down, only to pin them against the mattress again. Cyrus tilted her chin up and kissed her hard, deep, taking the sound from her mouth.

She arched under them, trapped between their heat and their hands. The world narrowed to the way they breathed, the way they whispered her name like a curse they owned.

“Good girl,” Cyrus murmured again. “Just like that.”

Logan’s tongue traced a line up her skin, making her whimper. Dean pushed her legs wider. Cyrus kissed her until the air itself seemed to vanish.

“Say it again,” Logan ordered.

“Please,” she gasped.

Her voice was raw. Her legs trembled. Her wrists ached from the rope.

Dean leaned down, his mouth against her ear. “Louder.”

She moaned the word this time. It echoed through the room, swallowed by their breaths.

“That’s it,” Logan growled against her skin.

The game didn’t stop there. They took turns pulling words from her, making her beg for what they were already doing, making her say things she’d never said out loud before. Each whisper, each touch, each demand pulled her deeper under their control.

Cyrus kissed the corner of her mouth, slow and claiming. Logan pushed her further with his mouth, his hands anchoring her in place. Dean held her wrists like he was holding the last piece of her.

She tried to fight the rising tide in her chest, the way her body pulsed and burned. But it was useless. The more she resisted, the harder they pushed, their voices a low, relentless chorus.

When her cry finally broke through the dark, it wasn’t defiance anymore. It was surrender.

Dean kissed her temple. “See? This is what happens when you stop pretending.”

Cyrus untied her wrists but didn’t let her move. Logan’s mouth slowed, drawing out the last tremors until the world went quiet again.

She lay there, shaking, blindfold still on, breath coming in broken waves. She could feel them around her, their heat pressing in from all sides. She didn’t know when they would stop.

And part of her already knew they wouldn’t. Not yet.