Chapter 22: Shared by my Ex’s friends 5

The first light of dawn crept through the blinds, soft and pale, crawling across the floorboards like it didn’t belong in the same room where the night had happened.

Elena lay on the bed, her body limp, the blindfold still hanging loose around her neck. Her wrists burned where the rope had been. The sheets were a mess beneath her, twisted and damp with sweat. Her breathing came shallow and uneven, the ghost of every touch lingering on her skin like fingerprints she couldn’t wash away.

The room was quiet now. No more whispers. No more hands pressing into her. No more voices making her beg.

But they were still there.

Logan leaned against the wall, shirtless, arms crossed over his chest, watching her with that same crooked grin he’d worn all night. Dean sat on the floor near the foot of the bed, head tilted back against the mattress, his hair falling into his face. Cyrus stood at the window, staring out at the lake, the morning light cutting a sharp line down his back.

She swallowed hard, her voice breaking the silence. “Untie me.”

Dean’s head turned. “You’re not tied anymore.”

She looked down at her wrists. The rope was gone. She hadn’t even noticed when they removed it.

Her throat tightened. “Then let me leave.”

Logan stepped away from the wall, his bare feet silent on the floor. “Leave?”

“Yes.” Her voice shook, but she held his gaze. “This is over.”

His smile widened. “No, sweetheart. This isn’t over. This is where it starts.”

The door creaked open before she could answer.

Nathan walked in.

He was still wearing last night’s jacket, hands in his pockets, expression calm, almost bored. He didn’t look surprised to see her lying on the bed with three of his friends. He didn’t look guilty either.

The air in the room shifted.

Logan moved aside, giving him a clear view. Dean stayed where he was, smirking faintly. Cyrus didn’t turn away from the window.

Elena pushed herself upright, the sheet falling from her chest. She grabbed it quickly and held it tight against her body. “Nathan.”

He met her gaze. No warmth. No softness. Just a cold indifference that made the night sink deeper into her skin. “I see they didn’t waste time.”

Her chest constricted. “You knew.”

“Of course I knew.” His voice was calm. Almost casual. “This house isn’t a secret. Neither are they.”

Her grip on the sheet tightened. “You let them.”

Nathan shrugged. “You came to my party. You walked through the door. You were always curious about them.”

Tears burned behind her eyes. “You’re lying.”

Logan laughed softly. “He’s not.”

Dean rose from the floor, stretching lazily. “He’s the reason you were invited.”

Her stomach twisted. “Why?”

Nathan tilted his head. “Because I wanted to see what you’d do when someone else took what I didn’t want anymore.”

It hit like a slap. She felt it crack somewhere inside her, quiet and clean.

Cyrus finally turned from the window. “She’s not just someone else anymore.”

Nathan’s mouth curved. “I know.”

Elena’s voice came out hoarse. “You’re disgusting.”

Nathan took a step closer. She flinched before she could stop herself. He noticed. He liked it. “No, Elena. I just know exactly who you are now.”

The words landed heavier than his hands ever could have.

Logan sat on the edge of the bed, close enough that she could feel the heat of his body through the thin sheet. “You don’t have to pretend anymore. You belong to us now.”

“I don’t belong to anyone.”

Dean leaned down, his breath brushing her ear. “That’s what you said last night.”

Her body betrayed her again, shivering at the memory. She hated that they saw it.

Cyrus stepped forward, his fingers brushing the side of her throat where their touches had left marks. “You can leave, Elena. But you’ll never forget what happened here. And neither will we.”

Nathan watched from the doorway. “She won’t leave.”

Logan tilted his head. “You sure?”

Nathan’s eyes locked with hers. “She’ll walk out into the world with our fingerprints all over her. And no matter where she goes, she’ll remember exactly how this night felt.”

She hated that he was right.

She hated that her body still ached in a way that wasn’t only from pain.

She slid off the bed slowly, clutching the sheet against her. Her legs trembled as she tried to stand. Dean brushed his fingers over her hip as she passed, a touch so casual it made her flinch harder than if he’d grabbed her.

“Goodbye, Elena,” Logan said softly, as if they’d shared something gentle instead of something cruel.

She walked past Nathan. For a second, she thought he might stop her. He didn’t. He stepped aside and let her go.

The hallway outside was washed in early light. It felt too bright, too clean, as if it belonged to a different world than the one she had just lived through.

She walked barefoot down the stairs, her heartbeat loud in her ears. The living room still smelled of smoke and liquor. The door at the end of the hall stood open, showing the lake beyond.

Her feet touched the cold grass. The morning air wrapped around her bare skin. The world was quiet. Birds had started to sing. The lake looked calm, untouched, as if nothing had happened.

But something had.

She looked down at her wrists. The rope burns. The faint bruises. Her throat felt tight beneath invisible hands.

She knew she would carry it forever.

Somewhere behind her, the door clicked shut.

The house went silent again.