Chapter 20: Shared by my Ex's friends 3

The house had gone completely still.

Downstairs, the music had long stopped. The few lights still glowing cast soft shadows along the walls, stretching across the wooden floor like dark hands. Outside, the lake lay black and unmoving, holding the night like a secret.

Elena lay on the bed, her breath still uneven, her hair damp against her forehead. The men hadn’t left. They moved around the room with quiet precision, their steps unhurried, their presence pressing in on her from every direction.

Cyrus stood near the window, watching the treeline like a sentry. Logan sat at the foot of the bed, his elbows resting on his knees, a grin that wasn’t playful lingering on his mouth. Dean knelt beside her, fingers running down the side of her neck like he was tracing ownership.

She turned her head toward the door. It was closed.

Her voice came out small. “Please. I want to go home.”

Dean tilted his head. “There’s nowhere to go.”

Logan leaned back on his hands. “Even if you scream, no one’s coming. It’s just us here.”

Cyrus didn’t speak. He didn’t have to. His silence said more than words ever could.

Elena sat up on her elbows. “Nathan—”

Logan laughed under his breath. “He’s not here. He left hours ago. He knew exactly what would happen.”

Her chest tightened. “You’re lying.”

Dean traced his thumb over her bottom lip. “No. He’s just not the kind of man who stays to watch.”

Her pulse pounded against her throat. She wanted to run, but her legs trembled. Her heart screamed at her to fight, but her body wouldn’t move. Every inch of her still remembered their hands, their mouths. The way they’d looked at her like prey.

Logan rose from the edge of the bed, walking slowly toward her. His shadow stretched long behind him, swallowing the soft light. “You can keep pretending, Elena. But we’ve already seen you. We know how your body reacts when you stop thinking and start feeling.”

“Stop,” she whispered.

He reached her in two steps, his hand sliding through her hair, tilting her chin up. “No one’s stopping anything tonight.”

Dean moved behind her, his hands sliding up her arms. She shivered as his breath touched the back of her neck. Cyrus finally turned away from the window, closing the curtains with one hand. The sound of the lake disappeared completely.

Then she felt it — the soft brush of fabric.

Dean held a black silk blindfold in his hands.

“No,” she breathed, shaking her head.

Logan’s fingers tightened in her hair. “Yes.”

She tried to turn away, but Dean caught her wrists and pulled them gently but firmly behind her back. His movements were slow, deliberate, as if they’d done this before. Her pulse pounded in her ears as the silk slid over her eyes, plunging the world into darkness.

The moment the light disappeared, everything else grew louder. The sound of their breathing. The creak of the wooden floor. The rustle of clothes. The sound of her own heartbeat.

Dean’s hands moved from her wrists to the rope. It wasn’t rough rope, not like the ones used for work. It was soft, but firm enough to hold. In seconds, her wrists were tied together behind her back. She struggled against it, but the knot held tight.

“Easy,” Dean whispered near her ear. “No one can hear you out here.”

A tremor ran through her chest.

Someone — Logan — tugged at the hem of her dress, pushing the fabric up. Fingers brushed the inside of her thighs. Without sight, the touch felt sharper. Hotter. She jerked back against Dean’s chest, but his arms locked around her waist.

“Breathe,” Logan said. “Let it happen.”

She bit her lip hard, but the sound that left her throat wasn’t the word no. It was a soft, broken moan.

Logan knelt in front of her, his hands sliding higher. Dean held her still. Cyrus walked closer, slow and silent, until she could feel the heat of him standing just beside the bed.

“This is what happens,” Cyrus said finally, his voice low. “This is what it means to belong to us now.”

Logan’s mouth brushed the inside of her knee. She gasped. Dean’s lips grazed the curve of her shoulder. Cyrus’s fingers trailed along her jawline, tilting her head slightly toward him. She was surrounded.

“Tell me something,” Logan murmured against her skin. “When he touched you… did it ever feel like this?”

“Stop,” she whispered again, though it sounded weaker this time.

He kissed higher, slow and punishing. “You’re shaking. Not from fear.”

Her legs trembled against the edge of the bed.

Dean whispered against her ear. “Do you feel that? That’s your body telling the truth.”

The rope dug into her wrists as she struggled against the flood of heat crawling up her spine. She could feel every breath, every movement. The blindfold turned the world into nothing but sensation.

Fingers. Mouths. Heat.

Cyrus’s hand slid beneath her chin, guiding her face toward his. She couldn’t see him, but she could feel his mouth hovering close. The air between them burned. His lips finally touched hers, slow and deep, drawing out a sound she didn’t mean to make.

Dean’s hands roamed lower, pulling at the straps of her dress. Logan pushed her knees apart with quiet control. She felt like she was floating, like the world outside the room had stopped existing.

“Good girl,” Cyrus whispered against her mouth.

She jerked at the words. “I’m not yours.”

Logan’s laugh rumbled against her thigh. “You will be before the sun comes up.”

Her breath caught as his mouth replaced his fingers. Dean held her tighter. Cyrus tilted her head back with a firm hand, claiming her mouth again. The world dissolved into touch.

Every moan. Every gasp. Every tremor became their language.

Her mind screamed that this was wrong. But her body — warm, desperate, trembling — betrayed her with every pulse.

Logan’s voice came again, rougher now. “Say it.”

She shook her head, the blindfold damp with sweat.

“Say it,” he repeated.

She gasped against Cyrus’s mouth as another wave of heat rolled through her. Her wrists ached from the ropes. Her legs shook under their hands. She didn’t even know who was touching her where anymore.

And that was exactly how they wanted it.

Dean whispered against her neck. “You’re not going anywhere, Elena.”

The night outside stayed silent. The lake did not move. No car lights flashed on the dirt road.

No one came.

And upstairs, in that warm, dark room, they kept taking what they’d decided was already theirs.