Chapter 19: Shared by my Ex’s friends 2
The upstairs hallway was narrow and dim, lit only by the soft yellow glow of a single lamp. The party below had dissolved into silence, leaving behind the faint hum of the old refrigerator and the occasional whisper of wind against the windows.
Elena stumbled as Logan pushed her forward. Cyrus followed behind her like a shadow, his fingers brushing against the small of her back. Dean closed the distance at her side, his hand firm around her wrist. Their steps echoed on the hardwood floor, slow and steady. The lake outside pressed its darkness against the house like a weight.
She tried to breathe evenly, but the air felt heavy. Her skin burned where their hands had touched her on the deck. She told herself to scream, to fight, to do something. But her voice stayed trapped somewhere in the back of her throat.
When they reached the guest room, Logan pushed the door open.
The room was warm, smelling faintly of smoke and cedar. A single lamp lit the space, throwing soft shadows on the cream-colored walls. There was a large bed against the far wall, the sheets rumpled from some other careless use earlier in the night. The window overlooked the lake. No neighbors. No help.
Dean closed the door behind them with a soft click.
Logan turned to face her, his grin slow and deliberate. “Take off your jacket.”
She shook her head. “I want to go home.”
Cyrus leaned against the doorframe, arms crossed, watching. Dean stood close enough that she could feel his breath on the side of her neck.
“You walked in here,” Logan said. “You came to the party. You knew who we are.”
Her throat tightened. “That doesn’t mean—”
Logan cut her off by stepping closer, his hand sliding up the front of her jacket. He didn’t pull. He waited. He watched the panic flicker across her face, then the way her breath hitched when Dean’s fingers slid into her hair from behind.
“You can tell us no,” Logan whispered, leaning down until their faces were inches apart. “But you know it won’t matter now.”
Her stomach knotted. “Please.”
He tilted his head. “Please what?”
Cyrus’s voice came from the doorway, low and smooth. “She still thinks she’s in control.”
Dean’s hand curled around the back of her neck. “She’ll learn.”
Logan finally yanked her jacket down her arms, letting it fall to the floor. He dragged his fingers down her chest, pausing at the hem of her dress. She tried to slap his hand away. He caught her wrist midair, twisted it gently, and pinned it against the wall.
Dean stepped closer, his lips brushing her ear. “You always looked at him like we didn’t exist. You shouldn’t have done that.”
“I didn’t—”
“Liar,” he murmured. “We saw it. All those nights you were here with Nathan. You stared at us like you wanted to know what we’d do if you let us touch you. Now you will.”
Her pulse roared in her ears.
Logan slid his hand beneath her dress, fingers warm against the inside of her thigh. She gasped, jerking against his grip. Dean’s hand tightened on the back of her neck. Cyrus moved away from the door, silent, controlled, like a predator that didn’t need to make a sound to own the room.
“Stop,” she whispered.
Logan’s mouth curved. “You don’t want me to.”
She hated that a shiver betrayed her. Hated it more when Dean’s thumb stroked her jaw as if he’d felt it too.
Cyrus walked to her other side, his height forcing her to tilt her chin up to look at him. He ran the back of his knuckles down her cheek. “We’ve wanted this for a long time. Nathan just didn’t know what to do with you. But we do.”
The hem of her dress was at her hips now, bunched in Logan’s hands. Her skin burned under their stares. The silence wrapped tighter and tighter around her like a rope.
Logan pressed his mouth to the base of her throat. The scrape of his teeth made her gasp. Dean turned her face toward him and kissed her. It was rough, claiming, nothing like the soft, sweet kisses she used to know. His tongue slid against hers. He tasted like whiskey and heat.
Cyrus’s hands slid down her sides, over her hips, slow and deliberate. She flinched at every new touch but couldn’t push them away. There were too many hands. Too many bodies. Too much control.
Logan lifted her up suddenly, making her back hit the wall. Her legs bent instinctively, wrapping around his hips before she could stop herself. The warmth of his body pressed hard against her, his breath against her collarbone.
“See?” he murmured against her skin. “You fit right where I want you.”
Dean bit her lower lip and laughed softly when she moaned. Cyrus leaned in and kissed the spot under her ear. Every nerve in her body was on fire. She didn’t know where one of them ended and the other began.
She shook her head, breathless. “Don’t do this.”
Logan’s grip on her thighs tightened. “We already are.”
He lowered her to the bed, letting her land on the soft sheets. They surrounded her again. Cyrus at her side, Logan at her feet, Dean climbing onto the mattress behind her. Their shadows merged on the walls, stretching long and crooked in the lamplight.
Dean’s hands slid under the straps of her dress, peeling it down slowly. He kissed the back of her shoulder, his voice a whisper against her ear. “You can fight, but it won’t matter. We’ll still make you feel everything.”
She tried to twist away, but Cyrus grabbed her wrists and pinned them above her head, his weight pressing into her arm. He wasn’t rough. He didn’t need to be. He had her.
Logan’s hands trailed up her calves, over her knees, spreading her legs apart with quiet authority. She whimpered, turning her face toward the pillow, but Dean’s fingers caught her chin and forced her to look forward.
“Eyes open,” he said softly.
The sound of fabric tearing filled the room.
Her dress.
Logan’s mouth found the inside of her thigh. Dean’s breath ghosted against her neck. Cyrus held her wrists, his gaze locked on her face. They moved like they had done this a hundred times before. No hesitation. No rush.
Just taking.
Her body trembled uncontrollably. The heat coiled lower, twisting into something she couldn’t name.
“You’re shaking,” Logan murmured.
She bit her lip hard. “I hate you.”
Dean’s laugh was low. “You don’t.”
Cyrus leaned down, his forehead brushing hers. “You’re burning.”
Their voices blurred into the rhythm of their hands, their mouths, their breath against her skin. The room tilted. The ceiling spun. She stopped knowing where she was, stopped knowing how to say no loud enough to break the air.
The first touch wasn’t gentle.
It wasn’t romantic.
It was heat, breath, and the sound of her own heartbeat breaking against the quiet of the house.
And when it was over, they hadn’t finished.
They had only begun.