Chapter 18: Shared by my Ex’s friends 1

The lake house glowed against the night like a beacon. Strings of golden lights draped across the deck and stretched down to the dock, their reflection glittering on the water’s surface. The forest surrounding the property was pitch-black, the kind of dark that swallowed sound. It was quiet out there, away from the music, away from the laughter that leaked through the open windows.

Elena hesitated at the foot of the deck steps. She could already hear their voices. Loud. Confident. Drunk. Her fingers gripped the strap of her small bag as if it might shield her. She didn’t know why she’d come. Maybe to prove she wasn’t broken after the breakup. Maybe to show that seeing him again wouldn’t undo her.

She was wrong.

The moment she stepped through the door, her chest tightened. The house smelled of expensive whiskey and cigarette smoke. Someone had spilled beer on the rug. Laughter cracked through the air like glass.

He was there.

Nathan.

Her ex-boyfriend leaned against the kitchen counter, a bottle of whiskey in his hand, grinning at something one of his friends said. He hadn’t even noticed she’d walked in.

But they had.

Three of them stood near the couch — tall, lean, the kind of men who were used to getting what they wanted without asking. Logan, with his messy hair and lazy smile. Cyrus, all muscle and cold blue eyes. Dean, quiet but always watching. They weren’t strangers. She’d spent months around them when she dated Nathan. She’d laughed with them once. Trusted them.

Tonight, their eyes weren’t friendly.

“Look who finally showed up,” Logan called out. His voice was smooth, too smooth, like velvet stretched over something sharp.

Nathan didn’t turn. He was too busy letting some girl whisper in his ear.

Dean lifted his drink and tilted it in her direction. “Brave of you to come.”

Cyrus just stared. No smile. No expression. Just that cold, steady gaze that crawled up her spine and made her skin prickle.

Elena forced a small smile, the kind that hurt. “Just came to say hi. Won’t stay long.”

“Sure,” Logan said, his eyes glinting. “We’ll make sure you feel welcome.”

She wanted to turn around. She should have. But a group of partygoers stumbled in behind her, blocking the door. The house swallowed her whole.

She wandered toward the kitchen, pretending she didn’t feel their eyes following her. Nathan glanced at her once, his smile fading for a heartbeat, then turned back to the girl at his side. That hurt more than she wanted to admit.

She poured herself a drink just to have something to hold. The music pulsed through the floor. The air grew warmer. People were pairing off in corners, disappearing into dark rooms.

Then a hand touched the small of her back.

She stiffened.

Logan’s voice slid against her ear. “Still playing innocent?”

She turned, stepping out of his reach. “I’m not playing anything.”

His grin widened. “Good. Because we’re not either.”

Before she could answer, Cyrus appeared on her other side. Dean leaned against the counter behind her. They had her surrounded without ever making it obvious. She felt it. A net closing slowly, quietly.

“Why are you here, Elena?” Cyrus asked, voice low and even.

She lifted her chin. “It’s a party. I was invited.”

“By who?”

She hesitated.

Logan smirked. “Not Nathan. He’s already busy.”

She hated how her throat tightened.

Dean’s hand brushed her wrist as he took the cup from her. “You don’t belong here anymore. But since you came…”

Her pulse spiked. “Since I came what?”

He leaned down, his breath hot against her ear. “We’re going to make sure you remember this night.”

She jerked away. “You’re drunk.”

Logan laughed quietly. “No, sweetheart. We’re very sober.”

The crowd thinned out after midnight. Cars left in twos and threes. The music grew lower, fading into a bass that matched her heartbeat. She found herself alone on the back deck, breathing in the cold night air. Her phone had no signal. She should have called someone before coming.

The wooden boards creaked.

She turned.

They were there again. Logan. Cyrus. Dean.

Nathan was nowhere to be found.

“Where’s Nathan?” she asked.

“Gone,” Logan said. “Which means you’re ours now.”

She laughed nervously, stepping back until her spine met the railing. “That’s not funny.”

“It’s not a joke.”

Cyrus moved first. His hand caught her wrist, pulling it down to her side when she tried to raise it. Dean stepped closer, fingers curling around the other. Logan leaned forward until his breath touched her face.

“You always looked at him like he owned you,” he whispered. “But he didn’t. We saw the way you blushed around us. We saw how your legs pressed together when we stared too long. Don’t pretend.”

Her heart slammed against her ribs. “Let me go.”

Dean’s hand slid from her wrist to her hip. “No.”

She twisted, but they were faster. Cyrus pushed her back against the railing, their bodies forming a wall around her. The lake stretched behind her in darkness. No one would hear her if she screamed.

“Stop,” she breathed. “This isn’t—”

Logan pressed a finger against her lips. “You should have stayed away, Elena. You came here. You walked straight into the wolves.”

Her hands trembled as they slid up her sides. Not rough. Not gentle either. Just certain. Cyrus’s mouth brushed her neck, hot and steady. Dean’s fingers slipped under the hem of her dress, curling against her thigh. Logan tilted her chin up, forcing her to meet his eyes.

“Say no if you want,” he murmured. “We’ll still take what’s already ours.”

Her breath caught.

“Please,” she whispered. “Don’t.”

His smile didn’t fade.

Logan kissed her.

It wasn’t soft. It wasn’t slow. It was ownership — a mouth that didn’t ask. Her lips parted out of shock and he swallowed the sound she made. Cyrus’s hand dragged higher up her thigh. Dean’s grip tightened on her waist. The night blurred into heat and hands and the creak of the wooden railing beneath her.

Her body trembled, her heart thrashing against her chest. Every nerve screamed at her to run, but her legs wouldn’t move. Their scent — smoke, sweat, whiskey — wrapped around her. Their touch pulled everything tighter until the night itself felt small.

Logan pulled back, his mouth grazing her ear. “Welcome to the real party.”

Dean whispered against her shoulder. “He didn’t deserve you.”

Cyrus’s voice rumbled low against her throat. “We’ll make sure you never forget us.”

Her dress slipped off her shoulder. Cool air bit into her bare skin.

And the lake stayed silent.

No one heard. No one came.

The deck lights flickered once, as if the house itself had decided to look away.

And Elena understood, in that breathless, terrifying moment, that she was not leaving the same way she came.