Chapter 169: One night, 5 men 2
Sleep never came that night.
Elias lay on the narrow cot in his cell, window cracked open to the pine-scented dark, every swallow reminding him of the thick spend that had coated his tongue hours earlier. His cock throbbed against the coarse sheet, untouched as ordered, leaking a steady wet patch that cooled and clung to his skin. When the bell rang for Lauds at four, he rose like a man drugged, dressed in a clean cassock that felt obscene against his naked body, and drifted through the prayers with Luca’s taste still in his mouth.
Breakfast was silent, bowls of watery porridge and black coffee. Matteo sat across the refectory table.
Brother Matteo was thirty-three, broad as a barn door, sleeves rolled high enough to show prison tattoos licking up both forearms: a crucifix made of knives on one, the Virgin Mary weeping blood on the other. His shaved head gleamed under the lamps, and a thick black beard framed a mouth that looked built for grinning and cursing in the same breath. Rumor said he had killed a man in Napoli before the Church claimed him. No one asked questions. No one needed to. The way he moved said everything: lazy power, like a tiger deciding whether to nap or eat you.
When the meal ended, Matteo caught Elias’s eye and tilted his head toward the corridor. A single jerk of the chin. Come.
Elias’s stomach flipped. He followed.
They wound down stone stairs that grew colder and damper with every turn. The air thickened, rich with yeast and fermented grape. At the bottom, a heavy door stood ajar. Matteo pushed it open with one shoulder and stepped aside.
“Wine for the bishop’s visit,” he said, voice rough as gravel. “Cases are too heavy for one man. You look strong enough, little priest.”
Elias stepped into the cellar. Torches guttered in iron sconces, throwing long shadows between rows of barrels taller than a man. The door thudded shut behind them. The key turned with a deliberate click.
Matteo leaned back against the door, arms folded, studying Elias the way a butcher studies a side of beef.
“You still taste him?” he asked.
Elias’s breath caught. “What?”
“Father Luca. I can smell confession on you. Thick as incense.” Matteo pushed off the door and prowled closer. “He always starts with the mouth. Says it teaches humility faster.”
Elias backed up until his shoulders met a barrel. The oak was cool through the cassock. Matteo stopped an inch away, heat rolling off him like a furnace.
“Take it off,” Matteo said.
Elias’s fingers were already moving, buttons slipping free before shame could catch up. The cassock dropped. He stood naked again, cock half-hard and rising fast under Matteo’s stare.
Matteo’s grin was slow and filthy. “On the table.”
A low worktable ran along one wall, scarred oak stained purple over decades. Elias climbed onto it and lay back, the wood cold against his spine. Matteo moved between his thighs, spreading them wide with rough hands.
“Look at you,” he murmured. “Prim little hole, already twitching for it.”
He dropped to his knees without ceremony and dragged Elias’s hips to the edge. The first touch of Matteo’s tongue was a shock, broad and wet and merciless. He licked a long stripe from balls to tailbone, then circled the rim with the flat of his tongue until Elias’s legs shook. When Matteo pointed his tongue and speared inside, Elias cried out, the sound echoing off stone like a gunshot.
Matteo ate him like a starving man, beard scraping tender skin, nose buried between his cheeks. He sucked and stabbed and growled, two days’ worth of repressed moans ripping out of Elias in broken sobs. Every time Elias’s hips tried to chase more, Matteo pinned him down with one massive hand splayed across his belly.
“Stay still, puttanella. I decide when you get fed.”
He worked a thick finger in alongside his tongue, then two, scissoring roughly, opening Elias with spit and brute force. The burn made Elias’s eyes water, but his cock leaked a steady stream across his stomach, betraying him.
Matteo stood abruptly, wiping his mouth with the back of his hand. His monk’s robe was already tented obscenely. He unbelted it and let it fall.
His body was a map of violence and devotion: scars crossing his chest, a thick treasure trail leading down to a cock that made Elias’s throat dry. Heavy, uncut, flushed almost purple, a fat vein running the underside. Bigger than Luca by far.
Matteo spat into his palm and slicked himself once, twice. Then he notched the head against Elias’s hole and pushed.
No pause. No mercy. One long, brutal thrust that buried him to the root.
Elias screamed. The sound tore out raw and animal, bouncing off the barrels. Matteo clamped a hand over his mouth and started fucking him in earnest, hips snapping hard enough to rock the table. Each thrust punched the air from Elias’s lungs, the thick cock dragging over his prostate again and again until pleasure and pain blurred into one bright, unbearable wave.
“Take it,” Matteo snarled against his ear. “Take every inch like the greedy hole you are.”
Elias’s legs wrapped around Matteo’s waist of their own accord, heels digging into muscle, urging him deeper. Matteo laughed, dark and triumphant, and angled his hips to hammer that spot relentlessly. Elias’s vision whited out. He came untouched, cock spurting across his own chest in thick ropes, body clamping down so hard Matteo groaned like he’d been punched.
But Matteo didn’t stop. He fucked Elias through the orgasm, through the oversensitive aftershocks, until Elias was sobbing into his palm, tears and snot smearing the calloused skin.
“Again,” Matteo ordered, voice ragged. “Milk me with that slut cunt. I’m close.”
He pulled out suddenly, fisted his slick cock twice, and aimed. The first jet hit Elias’s open hole dead center, hot and thick. The second striped across his balls, the third painted his taint. Matteo growled, shoved back in while he was still coming, and ground deep, flooding Elias from the inside with pulse after pulse.
Elias felt it, every spurt, the warmth spreading low in his belly. When Matteo finally stilled, plugged inside him, Elias’s legs were jelly, his chest painted with his own spend, his hole fluttering around the cock keeping everything in.
Matteo leaned down and bit Elias’s lower lip hard enough to bruise.
“Good start,” he rasped. “But I’m not done.”
He pulled out slow, letting Elias feel the drag, the wet slide. Cum followed, a thick river down Elias’s crack onto the table. Matteo scooped some onto two fingers and pushed it back inside, fucking it deep with short, possessive thrusts of his hand.
“Hold it,” he said. “Don’t let a drop fall. You walk upstairs with my load inside you like a good boy.”
He stepped back, robe already belted, looking for all the world like a simple monk again. Only the wet shine on his beard and the bulge still half-hard under wool gave him away.
Elias slid off the table on shaky legs. His hole clenched, trying to keep Matteo’s spend where it belonged. The cassock felt heavier when he pulled it on, fabric sticking to the mess on his chest and belly.
Matteo unlocked the door and held it open.
“After you, little priest.”
Elias walked up the stairs one careful step at a time, feeling the slow trickle anyway, the warmth sliding down his thighs beneath the robe. Behind him, Matteo’s low laugh followed like a brand.
At the top, sunlight poured through an archway. Matteo paused, leaned in close enough that Elias felt the words against his ear.
“Tell the others I warmed you up,” he whispered. “They’re impatient.”
Then he was gone, swallowed by the corridor, leaving Elias alone with the taste of wine and sin on his tongue and a stranger’s seed dripping steadily from his ruined hole.
The day had barely began.