Chapter 170: One night, 5 men 3

The monastery slept under a thin blanket of frost, but the chapel never truly slept. A single red lamp burned before the tabernacle, throwing blood-colored shadows across the vaulted ceiling. Elias moved through the nave like a ghost, drawn by the low throb of the organ that should not have been playing at this hour.

He had spent the day in a haze of soreness and secret thrill. Every time he shifted on the hard refectory bench, Matteo’s load shifted inside him, a slow, warm reminder. Luca had watched him across the table with cool amusement. Matteo had not looked at him at all. The twins, Rafael and Ramon, had stared openly, identical smirks curling identical mouths, until Elias felt stripped all over again.

Now the organ called him. A single sustained note, then another, climbing the scale like fingers up his spine.

He climbed the narrow spiral stairs that led to the choir loft. The wood creaked under his bare feet; he had left his sandals in his cell, unable to bear anything touching skin that felt flayed raw. Moonlight slanted through the high lancet windows, silvering the dust in the air.

The twins were waiting.

Rafael and Ramon stood on either side of the great organ, shirtless despite the cold, lean olive torsos gleaming like statues brought to wicked life. Twenty-two years old, dark hair falling into darker eyes, cheekbones sharp enough to cut. They moved in perfect synchrony, as though one mind piloted two bodies.

Rafael played the pedals with bare feet, low bass notes rumbling through the floorboards into Elias’s bones. Ramon’s hands danced over the manuals, drawing out a slow, sensual chorale that felt like blasphemy made sound.

They did not speak when Elias appeared at the top of the stairs. They simply turned their heads in eerie unison and smiled.

Elias’s cassock was already unbuttoned. He let it slide from his shoulders and stood naked, moonlight painting him argent and crimson. His cock lifted toward them, shameless.

Ramon lifted one finger from the keys and crooked it. Come.

Elias walked forward until he stood between them. The organ bench was wide, built for four monks. They made room for none.

Rafael rose first. He cupped Elias’s jaw and kissed him, slow, filthy, tongue fucking his mouth in time with the music Ramon continued to play. When Rafael pulled back, Ramon took his place without missing a beat, biting Elias’s lower lip until he tasted copper, then soothing it with his tongue.

Four hands began to explore him. Eight fingers traced ribs, pinched nipples, weighed his balls, tugged his cock until he leaked steadily onto the ancient wood. They worked without hurry, as though they had all night and intended to use every minute.

Ramon broke the kiss and whispered against Elias’s mouth, Spanish accent thick with lust. “We’ve been watching you walk bow-legged all day, padre. Matteo brags too much. Time to see if you can take two at once.”

Rafael spun Elias around and bent him over the carved wooden railing that overlooked the chapel thirty feet below. The drop made his stomach swoop. Cold air kissed his exposed hole; he was still slick from the afternoon, Matteo’s spend dried in crusty streaks down his thighs.

Ramon stepped behind him, robe already discarded. His cock was long, slender, curved upward like a scimitar. Rafael stayed in front, thicker, straighter, a bead of precum dangling from the slit.

“Hands on the rail,” Rafael ordered. “Do not let go. If you fall, we will catch you, but you will regret it.”

Elias gripped the wood until his knuckles whitened.

Ramon entered him in one smooth glide, no resistance left in Elias’s body to offer. The curve of his cock dragged over Elias’s prostate on every stroke, relentless. Ramon set a lazy rhythm, hips rolling like a dancer, while his hands stroked Elias’s sides as though calming a spooked horse.

Then Rafael fed his cock into Elias’s mouth.

They moved together, perfect counterpoint. Ramon would pull back until only the head remained inside, and Rafael would sink deep into Elias’s throat until his nose pressed against trimmed curls. When Ramon slammed home, Rafael withdrew until only Elias’s lips circled the crown. Never empty. Never full for more than a heartbeat.

The organ had stopped. In the sudden silence their breathing echoed huge, wet sounds obscene. Elias’s moans vibrated around Rafael’s shaft; Ramon answered with soft Spanish curses that sounded like prayers.

Below, the red sanctuary lamp flickered as though scandalized.

Rafael tangled fingers in Elias’s hair and began to fuck his face in earnest. Saliva poured from Elias’s stretched lips, dripping off Rafael’s balls onto the floorboards. Tears tracked his cheeks, not from pain but from the overwhelming fullness in his throat and the unbearable pleasure sparking behind his eyes every time Ramon nailed his prostate.

Ramon’s rhythm stuttered. “Close,” he hissed.

Rafael pulled out of Elias’s mouth with a wet pop. “Together.”

They switched places in a heartbeat. Rafael’s thicker cock split Elias open anew, the stretch burning sweetly. Ramon tasted of Elias himself when he pushed into his mouth, salty and dark.

Elias lost time. There was only the railing biting his palms, the slap of hips against his ass, the cock in his throat cutting off his air in delicious bursts. His own cock swung heavy and untouched, dripping a thin string of precum that swayed like a pendulum.

Rafael’s thrusts grew savage. “Now,” he growled.

Both twins buried themselves deep at the same instant, Ramon down Elias’s throat, Rafael in his guts, and came with twin guttural cries. Heat flooded Elias from both ends, pulse after pulse, until he felt bloated with it. Ramon’s spend coated his tongue; he swallowed convulsively, but some escaped the corners of his mouth and ran down his chin. Rafael bred him so deep Elias swore he could feel it in his stomach.

They stayed locked like that, three bodies trembling, until the last spasm passed. Only then did they withdraw. Cum poured from Elias’s hole the moment Rafael pulled free, pattering onto the floor like thick rain. More trickled from his lips when he gasped for air.

The twins were not finished.

They turned him around and pressed him to his knees between them. Four hands worked slick, spent cocks back to hardness with practiced efficiency. Elias watched, dazed, as they jerked themselves over his upturned face.

“Open,” Rafael said.

Elias opened his mouth, tongue out like an altar awaiting host.

They came again quickly, marking him. Stripes across his cheeks, his closed eyelids, his tongue. One final spurt from Ramon landed in his hair and stayed there, cooling slowly.

When they stepped back, Elias knelt in moonlight and semen, chest heaving, body shaking with aftershocks. His own cock still throbbed, untouched and aching, but he had not been given permission to come.

Ramon crouched, tipped Elias’s chin up with two fingers, and kissed him softly, tasting himself on Elias’s swollen lips.

“Beautiful,” he murmured. “Tomorrow the baths. Silas is impatient.”

Rafael was already pulling his robe on. He paused to drag a thumb through the mess on Elias’s cheek and paint it across his mouth like gloss.

“Sleep well, little priest,” he said. “You will need strength.”

They left him there, descending the stairs without a backward glance. The organ remained silent now, but the chapel bells began to toll for Matins, slow and solemn.

Elias stayed on his knees until the final note died. Only then did he crawl to the railing and look down at the empty nave, red lamp still burning.

Cum cooled on his skin. More leaked steadily from his gaping hole, pooling beneath him. He smiled, lips sticky, and whispered to the dark.

“Thank you.”

Then he gathered his cassock, did not bother to put it on, and walked naked back to his cell, leaving wet footprints all the way down the spiral stairs.

The night was far from over, but his body already knew it belonged to the monastery now, every bruised, dripping inch.