Chapter 168: One night 5 men 1
The mountain road ended where the monastery began. Stone walls rose like the ribs of some ancient beast, half swallowed by pine and mist. Elias stepped from the taxi with nothing but a small leather case and the weight of twenty-nine years of restraint pressed against his sternum. The driver did not wait. Tires crunched away down the gravel, leaving only the wind and the iron clang of the bell tower marking the hour of None.
Father Luca was waiting at the gate.
He was taller than Elias expected, broad across the shoulders, silver threading the black hair at his temples. The older priest’s eyes were the color of winter river ice and twice as unforgiving. He did not smile. He simply inclined his head and said, “You are late, Father Elias,” in a voice that curled low in the belly like smoke.
Elias bowed. “The roads were poor.”
“They always are. Sin finds a way to delay us.” Luca turned and walked. Elias followed, sandals slapping cold flagstones, the scent of incense and damp stone already clinging to his skin.
They passed through cloisters where younger monks glanced up from their work and then away again, as though Elias carried something contagious. No one spoke. The rule of silence hung thick until Luca pushed open the heavy door of the chapel and the hush inside felt different, heavier, like drowning in velvet.
The confessionals stood at the far end, two oak boxes carved with scenes of torment and mercy. Luca gestured to the penitent’s side.
“Begin when you are ready,” he said, and disappeared behind the lattice.
Elias knelt. The kneeler was worn smooth by centuries of sinners. He folded his hands, stared at the grille, and felt his pulse in his throat.
“Bless me, Father, for I have sinned,” he started, the words tasting like rust. “It has been four months since my last confession.”
Silence answered him. Then Luca’s voice, close enough that Elias could smell the faint cedar of his soap through the screen.
“Four months is a long time to carry poison, my son. Speak it all.”
Elias swallowed. He had rehearsed this on the train, on the taxi ride, in the dark of his parish bedroom when his hand had strayed beneath the sheets and he had bitten the pillow to keep from crying out. He had planned to confess small things: impatience, envy, the occasional glass of wine too many.
But the chapel was empty. The lattice was dark. And something in Luca’s waiting silence pulled the truth up like a hook through the ribs.
“I dream of men,” Elias whispered. “Not love. Not tenderness. I dream of being taken. Forced. Used until I forget my own name.” His voice cracked. “I wake wet and aching and hating myself for wanting it again the moment I open my eyes.”
The grille creaked. Luca had leaned closer; Elias could see the shadow of his profile now, the strong line of a nose, the curve of a mouth that did not smile.
“These are not dreams,” Luca said quietly. “They are invitations. Tell me what you see when you close your eyes and touch yourself.”
Heat flooded Elias’s face. He tried to look down, but the kneeler forced his gaze forward, toward that shadowed face.
“I see hands holding me down,” he said, the words tumbling faster now. “Mouths on me. Cocks inside me, one after another, until I’m nothing but the place they put their pleasure. I beg them to stop and I beg them not to, and when they finish inside me I come harder than I ever have in my life.”
His breath shook out of him. Shame and relief twisted together until he could not tell one from the other.
Luca was silent so long Elias feared he had fled the box entirely. Then the older priest spoke, low and deliberate.
“Stand up.”
Elias blinked. “Father?”
“Stand. Remove your cassock. All of it.”
The command landed between Elias’s legs like a fist. He rose on trembling knees. Fingers fumbled with buttons. The black fabric slid from his shoulders and pooled at his feet. Cool air kissed bare skin. He wore nothing beneath but the simple white briefs required by his order, already tented and damp at the tip.
“Now the rest.”
Elias hooked his thumbs in the waistband and pushed them down. His cock sprang free, flushed and leaking. He stepped out of the pile of cloth and stood naked in the confessional, arms crossed over his chest as if that could hide anything.
Luca’s shadow moved. The confessor’s door opened. The older priest stepped into the penitent’s side, filling the tiny space with heat and the scent of wool and male skin. He was still fully robed, the black cloth doing nothing to disguise the power in his frame.
“Hands at your sides,” Luca said.
Elias let them fall. His cock jerked under the scrutiny, a bead of fluid sliding down the underside.
Luca studied him the way a butcher studies meat. Then he reached out and wrapped one large hand around Elias’s throat, not squeezing, just holding him still.
“You will finish your confession,” he said against Elias’s ear. “Every filthy detail. And while you speak, you will stroke yourself. Slowly. If you come before I give permission, I will tie you to the altar and leave you there until morning mass. Do you understand?”
Elias’s answer came out a broken whimper. “Yes, Father.”
Luca released his throat and stepped back, folding his arms. “Begin.”
Elias wrapped a shaking hand around his cock. The first touch made him gasp. He began to move, slow drags from root to crown, while words spilled out of him like blood from a fresh cut.
“I imagine them laughing at how eager I am… how I open my legs the moment they touch me… how I cry when they call me a whore and thank them for it…”
His hips rocked forward into his fist. Luca watched without blinking.
“They hold my mouth open and piss down my throat just to see if I’ll swallow… and I do… I always do…”
A low sound rumbled in Luca’s chest. He reached down and unfastened his cassock in one practiced motion. Black wool parted. Beneath it he wore nothing. His cock rose thick and heavy, veins dark along the length, the head already slick. It was bigger than Elias had imagined in his darkest moments, ruddy and intimidating.
“On your knees,” Luca ordered.
The stone floor bit into Elias’s skin as he sank. Luca stepped closer until the head of his cock brushed Elias’s lips, leaving a wet streak.
“Open.”
Elias opened. Luca fed himself in slowly, letting Elias feel every inch stretching his jaw, sliding over his tongue, nudging the back of his throat. When Elias gagged, Luca simply held him there, fingers tangled in his hair, until the reflex eased and Elias’s throat relaxed around the intrusion.
“Good,” Luca murmured. “Now confess with your mouth full.”
He began to move, shallow thrusts at first, then deeper, using Elias’s mouth like a sheath. Saliva dripped from Elias’s chin. His own cock wept steadily, untouched now, aching against his belly.
Between thrusts, Elias managed choked fragments.
“I want… to be broken… want them… to ruin me… for God… for anything… but this…”
Luca’s rhythm grew harder. The confessional creaked with each snap of his hips. His breathing roughened, the only warning before he buried himself to the root and came with a guttural groan. Heat flooded Elias’s throat in thick pulses. He swallowed frantically, eyes watering, until Luca pulled back and the last spurt painted his lips and chin.
Luca tucked himself away, calm as if he had merely taken communion. He looked down at Elias kneeling naked and marked, chest heaving, cock still painfully hard.
“Your penance begins tonight,” he said. “You will not touch yourself again until I allow it. You belong to this house now. And this house takes what it wants.”
He stepped over the discarded cassock, opened the confessional door, and was gone.
Elias stayed on his knees in the dark, tasting salt and sin, the echo of Luca’s cock still throbbing in his throat. Somewhere in the monastery a bell rang for supper, but he did not move. He smiled, small and secret, lips swollen and shining.
The retreat had only just begun.