1280

Alice nodded in satisfaction, hopped off my lap, and looked at the next closest girl, who happened to be Mari seated on the near side of the 3-cushion couch. "You're next."

"Umm, what?" Maris face was the definition of deer-in-the-headlights.

Alice rolled her eyes. "Nevermind. Neevie?"

Naimh didn't hesitate and quickly bounced to her feet. The busty redhead eagerly slid into my lap and attacked my face, devouring me, really. This time I returned the kiss with intense fervor, and our lip-lock went on and on and if it never ended, that would've been fine with me. But Alice was beside us, tapping Naimh's shoulder impatiently. And we finally broke the kiss, staring at each other with goofy, giddy expressions.

Alice was impatient. "You have to ask him the two questions now."

"What? Oh. Uhhh..." Naimh stammered.

Alice sighed and led her, "Are you in love..."

"Right, right." Naimh collected herself and smiled primly. "Uh, Matty? Are you in love with me?"

I gave her an apologetic look. "I'm sorry, but no."

"Are you in lust with me? Do you fantasize about throwing me onto a bed and fucking the shit out of me?" She grinned.

"Yes, that, totally." I grinned, too.

"Ahem," Alice cleared her throat and gave us a pointed look.

"Right, right." Naimh schooled her face and asked, "Are you saving your virginity for me?"

I shook my head slowly. "No. I mean, I wouldn't mind, but no."

Naimh smiled. "An acceptable answer."

"Whatever," Alice said impatiently and snapped her fingers. "Next!"

Zofi went next, followed by Sam and then Mari. I kissed each girl, assured her I wasn't in love with her, and confirmed I was not saving my virginity for her.

Last was Belle.

Everyone looked at us curiously as she climbed into my lap. Belle had always been an active participant in the group teasing, perfectly content to bend over at the waist and make me check out her ass, or sit in my lap and rub my naked chest while letting me explore her body a bit as well. There was even that one afternoon all six of them lined up in front of Matty's Chair and raised their bikini tops to flash me simultaneously. And there were a few times she would cuddle up to my side on the couch during a movie, her hand rubbing the bulge in my shorts.

But... See, Belle and I had never really kissed. I'd made out with all the other girls at one time or another. Even Mari had given the inside of my mouth a tongue scraping a half-dozen times, most recently after one of my famous poolside massages back in August. But not Belle. Letting her fondle me like all the other girls did was one thing. Kissing me, though, like a real kiss with tongue and everything, would be... intimate. And I'd never been able to bring myself to do it.

That afternoon would not become the first.

The petite strawberry-blonde squirmed a little in my lap, adjusting herself until she got her crotch positioned just right. The succession of five hot girls making out with me one after the other had definitely been arousing, and the iron bar in my shorts was proof positive. Sam had gone so far as to unbutton her blouse and mash my face into her bra-clad cleavage while she dry-humped herself on my erection. She got close to getting herself off while doing so, too. But when I'd replied in the negative when she asked if I was saving my virginity for her, she'd looked a little disappointed, stopped grinding, and got off my lap.

Mari's kisses and lush tits had maintained the erection while the lovely Latina similarly rode my cock like a rail, although she didn't linger as long. And now Belle, my sweet little Annabelle, was moaning in my lap while grinding her clit against my bone.

Her spoken fantasies about me filled my head, but I did my best to ignore them. Belle hadn't attempted to kiss me yet, too focused on dry-humping my dick through my shorts. So I took matters into my own hands, cradling her head gently and bending down to place a tender peck on her forehead. "I'll always love you, B, like the little sister I never had," I said gently. "But I'm not in love with you. And I'm not saving my virginity for you."

Belle looked up at me in surprise.

I gave her a tight smile and started to lift her out of my lap.

"Hey, wait! We didn't even kiss!" she complained, visibly aroused.

"And we're not going to," I stated evenly, placing her light body back on her feet on the floor beside me. Bracing my hands on the armrests, I pushed myself up to a standing position and turned to face all the girls. "Now that that's out of the way, can we PLEASE let everything go back to normal? I love you all, but I'm not in love with any of you. How and when I lose my virginity should be up to ME, not just set up when Sam decides to throw a hot girl my way, alright? I really, really just want my friends back. Capisce?"

The girls all looked at each other for a moment. Sam muttered defensively, "I didn't throw Holly at you. She asked permission and we said it would be okay with us. Even though we all went through the exercise of agreeing you're not our boyfriend and we're not going to get jealous, girls don't know that, and they're gonna keep asking us if it's okay. Do you want us to NOT give permission the next time a girl asks if she's allowed to fuck you?"

"I'm sorry, that came out wrong." I sighed. "Of course I want you to give her permission. I mean, in an ideal world, girls wouldn't feel the need to ask your permission in the first place, but I get that my membership in the BTC presents unique challenges to my dating life."

"You mean lack of dating life," Zofi remarked. "If you want to really convince us you're not saving your virginity for one of us, go on a date for the first time in a year."

"Is that what you really want?"

"Yes!" Zofi exclaimed while Naimh simultaneously said "No!"

Everyone turned to look at Naimh, who blushed pink and exclaimed, "What? I rather like having Matty all to ourselves. Do you all really WANT him to find a girlfriend, commit to her, and start spending all his time with her instead of us? You wanna have some girlfriend start bitching at you when you get the urge to sit in his lap and grind yourself?"

"No, of course not," Sam said. "But in all fairness, we all know Matty would never stop one of us from meeting a boy and going out on a date."

"It doesn't matter," I interrupted. "It's a moot point, because I'd never do that to you. I love you all and I love being part of the club more than anything else in the world. I would never risk losing you girls by dating someone else."

Belle frowned. "So you ARE saving yourself for us."

I hedged, "It's not that I'm expecting one of you to take my virginity. Truly, I'm not. I'm just saying I know that if I'd actually banged Holly, it would have affected my relationships with all of you."

Sam shook her head. "Didn't we all agree we'd be fine with it? Or do I actually need notarized affidavits?"

"No, no." I laughed but then took on a serious look. "Thing is, I've been watching all of you for years now. I've seen you get crushes on boys and listened to you complain about what they do or don't do, and the fact is you all say stuff doesn't bother you when it actually does. Notarized affidavits or not, my sleeping with Holly would have bothered a lot of you."

"It wouldn't have bothered me," Zofi stated matter-of-factly. "You're our friend, not our boyfriend. Although I do admit the idea of you being my boyfriend would be nice. It would certainly get my Mom off my back about my lack of dating life."

"I don't mind if you tell your Mom I'm your boyfriend." I shrugged and looked at the others. "But before the rest of you start trying to reaffirm me sleeping with Holly wouldn't have bothered you, don't... uh... well, don't bother. I know you better." I gave Alice and Mari in particular serious looks.

It was looking at those two that actually put the next realization into my head, and I explained, "Right now, all the teasing is fun and games because most of us are virgins. It's a level playing field. We're all messing around and feel safe doing what we're doing because we haven't crossed that line yet, or at the very least, -I- haven't crossed that line. But if I had nailed Holly, you'd wonder just a little if I was going to start losing control and want to nail you too."

"You already want to nail us," Naimh commented.

"True," I admitted. "And the feeling's mutual. But I'm not going to lose my virginity in some rushed encounter taking advantage of one of my friends and ruin the whole BTC."

Sam chimed in, "You're disproving your own statement that you'd lose control and want to nail us just because you weren't a virgin anymore."

"It's not about him losing control," Alice put in. "It's about us losing control, or me, at least. Matty is my safe guy friend. I know we're both virgins, and I know I can mess around with him without worrying whether or not we'll stop ourselves from doing anything serious. On the other hand, if he'd fucked Holly, I would have felt pressure to... well... let him do stuff to me too... just to keep his attention. I mean, why would he waste time letting me rub his package on the couch when he could find some other girl willing to let him pork her?"

"Me, too," said Mari. "That sort of thing has already been happening for years. It's peer pressure, not from him but from the rest of you. You guys started making out with him with plenty of tongue, so I figured I'd have to just to keep up. You all started talking about what his boner felt like through his shorts, so of course I had to try it for myself. Sam and Neevie started flashing him their tits over the summer, and set up that whole six-girl titty lineup that one time, so I felt like I had to go along."

Sam made a face. "Okay, I get where you guys are going with this. I know I said I personally wouldn't be bothered if he'd slept with Holly, but I can understand feeling pressure to put out for him to ensure he liked me as much as her. I'm not a virgin and it feels like it wouldn't be such a big stretch for me to bang him just to feel like I'm his favorite."

Zofi elbowed her best-friend. "You're such an attention-whore."

I looked across everyone. "So there you have it. I can't lose my virginity yet."

Belle stamped her foot. "But it's not FAIR. Not to Matty. All six of us are allowed to have sex but he's not? If you ask me, maybe it's finally time we let one of US fuck him."

"I call dibs!" Naimh squealed immediately, thrusting her hand up into the air.

"NO," Sam stated emphatically. "The Rule is The Rule."

"Then you're asking him to remain a virgin just because we say so," Mari spoke up quietly. "Belle's right: that's not fair to Matty. He's not our boyfriend and we have no right to demand his chastity for the sake of the club."