Chapter 51: One twin is dead
Inside the mansion, the surviving twin lay still pale, almost ghostly on Jesse’s bed.
Alina sat beside her, eyes narrowed, mind racing.
She studied the faint rise and fall of the girl’s chest. Her lips, parted slightly. Still alive.
But something was wrong.
“You saw the video,” Alina whispered, almost to herself. “What did you see in it, Molly? What did you remember?”
The girl didn’t stir.
But Alina wasn’t convinced she was fully unconscious.
From the annex, Erika stared at her reflection, fingers curling tightly against the sink. She hadn’t spoken to Nathan that morning. She didn’t need to. The silence was louder than any conversation.
And Jesse?
She had never truly trusted him.
Not since Maya.
Not since that night in the hallway when blood and water mixed on the tile, and he said, “She slipped.”
Erika pulled on her running shoes and stormed out into the cold.
She ran with force, her breath harsh and rapid, pounding the dirt with her sneakers. Her ponytail whipped behind her, and her thoughts unraveled in knots.
Everything was wrong.
Everything.
She wasn’t just surrounded by secrets anymore. She was buried in them.
And then—
By the front gate, a figure.
Still.
Waiting.
Julian.
He leaned against the stone wall, arms crossed, his blonde hair tousled, his face unreadable.
Erika slowed down but didn’t stop. She tapped the gate console.
“Craig,” she said, “open it.”
The gate creaked, yawning open like the mouth of something ancient.
Julian stepped forward. Erika watched him carefully.
“Is there a problem?” she asked.
His eyes flickered with a mixture of anxiety and irritation. “Quinn,” he said. “I came here with her. Three days ago. She hasn’t returned any of my calls.”
Erika’s chest tightened. But her face remained calm.
“Quinn?” she echoed, feigning confusion.
“My ex,” Julian said. “She came because her sister sent her a weird message. Said she was in danger. Then nothing. No word. Just… silence.”
Erika blinked slowly, a hundred scenarios spinning in her mind. She could lie. Deflect. Push him away.
But instead, she met his eyes and said, “Quinn is fine.”
He stepped closer. “Can I see her?”
“Not at the moment. No strangers allowed inside the premises.”
He frowned. “Why not?”
“What’s your name again?”
“Julian.”
Erika nodded. The wind picked up, brushing her face with cold clarity.
This man… could be her leverage.
Someone from the outside. Someone untainted by the estate’s rot. She needed that.
“You mind giving me your number?” she asked casually. “For updates. For… Quinn.”
Julian narrowed his eyes but handed it over.
“When can I come back?”
“Tomorrow,” Erika said after a pause. “But I’ll text you.”
The gate slowly began to close. Julian raised his hand in a small wave. Erika didn’t return it.
As she turned back toward the estate, something inside her had shifted.
She wasn’t part of the scheme anymore.
She was now the one standing apart from it. Watching. Calculating.
Waiting to burn it down.
Back on the estate, Erika jogged up the wooded path near Calvin and Maya’s old cabin, but stopped dead in her tracks.
Nathan and Jesse were there.
And they were throwing something heavy into the brush near the lake. She didn’t need to guess.
They turned at the sound of her steps.
“Sorting things out,” Jesse said flatly.
She didn’t reply. Her eyes scanned the tarp, the disturbed earth, the water darkening beneath.
Nathan tried to read her expression. “You okay?”
Erika’s gaze was blank. Hollow.
But Jesse… Jesse knew. She was slipping away from them. Her silence wasn’t shock, it was strategy.
And when she walked away without another word, they both felt it.
She was going to turn.
The house was silent.
Quinn’s bare feet padded against the cool wooden floor as she crept down the hallway. Her body still ached bruises bloomed purple beneath her sweater but her resolve was returning with every breath she took.
At the foot of the stairs, the early morning light fell in strange patterns across the tiles. She turned to the panel embedded in the wall, Craig’s console. The red sensor blinked.
She leaned in, speaking just above a whisper. “Craig?”
“Yes, Quinn?”
Her voice cracked. “I want to see what’s behind that locked door. The one upstairs near the attic stairwell.”
There was a pause, a faint mechanical hesitation.
“That area is not within my authorized access.”
Of course it wasn’t.
Quinn sighed and turned back toward the stairs. She moved slowly, touching the walls as she climbed, as if grounding herself in the structure of the house. When she reached her room, she closed the door, stood in front of the tall mirror, and peeled off her clothes.
No tattoos.
Her fingers ran across the flat of her back, just to be sure. She stared at herself in the mirror, chest rising and falling. You’re not her, the reflection seemed to whisper. You never were.
On the table beside the mirror sat a small silver frame, the photo of Molly smiling beside a younger Jesse and Chloe.
Quinn reached for it, held it in her hands, and whispered into Craig again, barely audible.
“Craig… What was up on the ceiling? During our fight... Molly said someone was watching us from there.”
Craig’s voice flickered with static. “My surveillance systems do not cover that space. It was sealed by Mr. Gary prior to my installation.”
Quinn clenched her jaw. The house was layered in secrets. Every corner felt like it whispered back. Watching.
Outside, on the annex patio, Erika sat cross-legged with a mug of cooling tea. Her gaze was fixed, unblinking, toward the distant path leading from the woods.
Jesse and Nathan emerged, slightly disheveled. Their boots were caked with damp earth. She didn’t move.
When Jesse approached, Erika didn’t even look at him.
“You knew,” she said coldly. “You knew she had a twin. You knew everything.”
Jesse’s tone was practiced, exhausted. “What happens on my side and what happens on yours… that’s not the same thing, Erika.”
Her head turned slowly. Her eyes cut into him like ice. “It is when you disappear into the woods with Nathan to throw a body into a lake. That becomes my business. Because he’s involved.”
Jesse tensed. “Don’t start.”
She turned to Nathan. “Tell me, then. What were you doing with him?”
Nathan’s lips parted. His jaw tightened. Then—
“Don’t,” Jesse warned, sharp and low.
Erika stepped forward. “No, let him speak. Or are you afraid I might finally see who both of you really are?”
Nathan opened his mouth. Then I closed it.
“Coward,” she muttered, backing away.
Jesse exhaled, annoyed. “You want to know? Fine. Floyd is dead. He knew too much. And he was about to tell Sofia.”
Silence.
Erika swayed, as if the words physically hit her.
She blinked hard, gripping the iron railing of the patio.
“You… you killed him?”
Nathan stepped forward. “We didn’t have a choice—”
Erika shoved his hand off her shoulder.
“No,” she snapped. “He made this mess. Jesse made this mess. And now we’re all stuck in it.”
Jesse tried to hold her stare, but she turned away—eyes glassy but dry.
She whispered, more to herself than to them, “You buried a man. You shot him like an animal and tossed him into dirt. You think there won’t be a reckoning?”
Without waiting for an answer, Erika walked past them, her boots crunching the gravel path as she disappeared toward the estate’s edge, where the trees whispered secrets and wind carried voices the house tried to bury.