Chapter 50: Killing the witness
They crashed into a support beam. Then the window.
A soft cracking sound echoed.
The old frame gave way.
Alina reached the top, panting. “Stop it!”
But the floor gave way beneath them.
The twins grabbed each other mid-fall, flailing, screaming. For a moment, it looked like they’d both fall to their deaths.
And then
Only one scream cut short.
Only one body hit the spike of the broken sculpture beneath.
The other hit the gravel Unconscious but breathing.
Alina screamed from above, clutching her mouth.
In the moonlight, she couldn’t tell who had survived.
Molly?
Or Quinn?
Her lips trembled. “Craig... Craig, who is it?”
But Craig didn’t answer.
Inside the house, the silence returned.
The mansion held its breath once more.
The scream still echoed in Erika’s ears as she sprinted through the mansion gates, heart pounding. The wind cut sharp against her cheeks, the air bitter with frost and blood.
She reached the front of the house—then stopped.
Two bodies lay sprawled in the gravel beneath the shattered attic window.
Erika froze.
One sister, barely breathing.
The other, impaled through the stomach, limbs twisted unnaturally, blood pooling around a jagged piece of sculpture jutting from the earth.
“No…” she whispered. “What the hell happened here?”
For a second, Erika didn’t move. She could barely breathe. The two women—identical. One alive. One not. But she hadn’t even known there were two of them.
Alina emerged from the shadows of the stairs, barefoot, her breath fogging in the cold. “I saw them fighting,” she said in a low voice, glancing up at the broken attic window. “Molly pushed her. No… maybe it was Quinn. I don't know anymore.”
Erika stumbled back a step, confused. “Wait. What are you talking about? Molly has a twin?”
Alina nodded slowly. “Her name’s Quinn. She came here a few days ago. Jesse brought her in… Erika, we didn’t know what to do.”
Erika clenched her fists. “Craig,” she snapped, “sounded the emergency alarm. Get Jesse here now.”
From the depths of the house, a high-pitched siren began to blare.
In the garage, Jesse had his back arched, his hands against the cold steel of the tool table, breath ragged. Nathan thrust behind him, eyes half-lidded, lost in the rhythm. Their moans filled the metal-and-oil silence—until the alarm exploded through the air.
“Shit!” Jesse gasped.
Nathan pulled back immediately. “What the hell—?”
“Go,” Jesse muttered, tucking himself back into his pants. “Stay here.”
He ran, sweat on his chest, heart beating for reasons other than lust now.
But as he reached the mansion’s side entrance, he didn’t notice the beam of a small flashlight flashing in the woods nearby. Flyod stood behind a tree, eyes cold, watching.
He had seen everything.
Back in front of the house, Erika crouched beside the bodies, hands shaking as she checked for a pulse.
The one on the gravel, alive. Barely. The other, lifeless.
Jesse burst through the door. “What happened?!” he yelled, breathless, eyes wild. Then he saw the blood.
His knees buckled slightly. “No—no, no, no... which one is it?”
“We don’t know,” Erika snapped. “They’re dressed the same. I didn’t even know she had a twin!”
Jesse stepped forward, but Erika slapped him across the face so hard it echoed.
“You’ve gone too far,” she said through clenched teeth. “This isn’t a game anymore, Jesse.”
“She jumped! It’s not my fault!”
“No?” Erika growled. “And what about Maya, huh? What about Calvin? You’re still hiding bodies like a coward, and now one of them is dead. If Sofia finds out, you’ll be expelled from this entire operation. Or worse.”
“We can remove the body—no one has to know.”
“You said the same thing when Maya was shot,” Erika said, eyes blazing, unaware Alina had stepped closer behind her, listening. “And I helped you. But not again. You clean this mess up yourself. And tomorrow, we meet. Everyone. No more lies.”
She turned and walked back into the night, leaving Jesse frozen in place, Alina looking from one sister to the other, unsure which one had just died.
Across the property, Flyod moved in the dark toward Calvin and Maya’s abandoned house, phone to his ear.
“Sofia,” he said into her voicemail, “I’ve seen something. Something... messy. There’s a new girl, looks like Molly. Twins. And those two, Jesse and the young one, Nathan, they’re in a relationship.”
He paused, watching the ground as he stepped through the garden.
“They were just talking about hiding bodies,” he continued. “I think they killed Maya and Calvin. I think they buried them right around—”
His voice cut off.
He had dropped to his knees and begun digging with his bare hands, brushing aside frozen leaves. His fingers scraped something soft, yielding.
Flesh.
A hand. Pale. Lifeless.
“Oh God,” he whispered.
Then—
Twang.
An arrow pierced his lower back.
He gasped, reaching for the shaft sticking out from under his ribs. Another arrow followed, striking his chest. His mouth opened in shock.
Blood sprayed across the soil.
Nathan stepped from the shadows.
Bow in hand.
“Wrong place, wrong time,” he muttered, pulling the phone from Flyod’s twitching hand.
It buzzed in his grip.
Sofia.
The call had connected.
Nathan stared down at the dying man, then slowly raised the phone to his ear.
From the speaker: “Flyod? I got your message. What is it?”
Nathan hesitated. A second too long.
Then hung up.
And crushed the phone under his boot.
Morning came grey and windless, a slow, low fog blanketing the estate like a shroud. Somewhere, a crow called, its voice raspy, foreboding. The events of the night hadn’t dissolved with dawn. If anything, the weight of them had grown heavier, more real.
Jesse stood waist-deep in the frigid lake, sleeves rolled up, hands slick with mud and blood. A black tarp floated beside him, its weight dragging it downward, tethered by stones and silent regrets. He didn’t speak. Didn’t pray. Just lowered the tarp, containing the broken body of one of the twin sisters, into the water.
Behind him, Nathan lit a cigarette, eyes scanning the trees. His voice broke the stillness.
“Flyod’s dead.”
Jesse glanced back. “You sure?”
Nathan nodded. “Shot him myself. He knew everything. About the cabin. About us. About the bodies.”
Jesse cursed under his breath, then turned back to the lake and let the tarp sink beneath the surface. “We clean up everything. No loose ends. That’s the rule.”