Chapter 16: Monster of the Sea
Hence these jump cuts which, were it not Nicolas Ray shooting, would be gross, preposterous editing blunders10: across the
canyon a mine has exploded and Johnny is looking down while,
in all logics, he should have
looked up. A straight cut
and the shadow of the rider
on the right (F7) is to be
found on the left, (F8)
which more than an ellipsis
may signify a discordance
in the treatment of time11, as
well as in the treatment of
8 Or a "ficelle", a "function",
"an artful expedient for mere consistency of form," to use Henry
James's terms in his Preface to The
Ambassadors.
9 Thinking of Magritte's The
Treason of Images…
10 Much too gross not to make
sense, though we have in mind
Truffaut, considering the editing
"deplorable."(Cahiers du Cinéma,
n°46).
Vienna and the others "because it's not real"
53
t&f
space, when from one shot to the next, Johnny is unexpectedly
caught in a storm. To say nothing of the subjective shot on Vienna’s
saloon (F9), just as fake, since Johnny can’t possibly be within view
of Vienna’s from where he stands, as attested by the next shots.
And yet, something does need to be said (F10) about this alleged
subjective shot which gets wedged in what could have been one
shot on Johnny at a stop, looking and clearly seeing nothing but a
whirl of dust infolding Vienna’s saloon. More than an internal focalisation in which what is presented escapes the focalizer, this long
shot on Vienna’s saloon
might well be conjured up
by an “external ocularizing”
as François Jost calls it, as “it
seems to come from outside
or be autonomous”12. In that
respect, it might be some
off-the-field image.
Leaving aside the de-realising effect within the fiction of its
exact repetition 15 seconds later –its first occurrence signifying the
emptiness of a setting13, diegetically reinserted when Johnny rides
in. Or the obvious break in some idealized mimetic continuity –in
that case a flashforward which can’t possibly be generated by the
character and, as such, uncovers the fabric of the fiction. Leaving
aside then these two readings, without discarding them, one enticing alternative or next step would be to regard this most irrational shot as that which signifies the outside like the ellipsis in a
jump cut, that which has been left outside –the sense of time–
and yet has never ceased to work from within the chain of images. With
this irrational shot, it is as if the outside –what Deleuze calls “the interstice”14, i.e. within a sequence, a white or black screen the vacancy of which
signifies a direct presentation of time –had been filled in or rather staked
out. So that not only would the diegetic continuity be broken up by this
sudden and autonomous incoming shot, but so would be the sense of the
outside, the sense of time.
Time, in its chronological and meteorological movements (where’s
that storm coming from?) that time of beginnings and ends, of hierarchical celestial orders, would find itself eclipsed by and endowed with a
new sense: the sense of an assemblage consisting in non-chronological
11 In that case there's a lot in
Johnny Guitar. See the straight cut
among many others between the
scene on the bridge at dusk (55.54)
after her arrival from the bank.
(55.53). Or that dissolve in which
what seems to be the afternoon at
the lair, Dancing Kid, outside, brooding over the valley, fades out
(40.57) for Vienna to fade in walking down the stairs of her saloon
late in the evening. (40.58).
12 Quoted by Gilles DELEuZE
in L'Image-Temps (Paris: Minuit,
1985), p. 296.
13 And so will be the inside of
the saloon, and even the credits
whose lyrics at the end can be said
to give sense to the music of the
beginning.
14 DELEuZE, 1985, 232.
Jean-Louis Brunel
54
t&f
time relationships, as such, entailing a causality of some sort,
less substantial than simulated, less ethic than aesthetic. A
new sense of the outside in the name of Vienna, i.e. nothing
but a subdivision of the inside, a time on her side: To one of
her croupiers reading last-month paper “to know,” says he,
“what’s happening outside,’ (F11) she snaps back: “There
will be plenty going on here soon. Just worry about that.”
(06.15) If anything is to be known then, it won’t be pursued
and purveyed out there, outside, but in here, inside, drawn
and dealt by Vienna only.
Behold the woman (F12), shot up from below, aesthetically dominant and powerful, lordly should we say, looking
upon that world in her own image, downstairs, where she
“sell[s] whisky and cards.” (14.01) That’s the place Johnny
opens his eyes on. He’s just stumbled his way in, helped out
of the reeling and blinding dust of the storm by Old Tom15.
A subjective shot, this time right, of where the story starts, jingled into action by a croupier who starts spinning the wheel no
sooner has he seen Johnny… and us. Strange for a first shot of a
saloon, to have left the bar out of the field. Strange and significant
in its obliquity as its composition originates in a decentered point
of view or, as it puts the center at stake16, aesthetically and thematically: at the center is the roulette –game at the expense of whisky.
And then, following the straight economy of the perspectival
construction, our eyes glide along the orthogonals drawn by the
edge of the gaming tables in the foreground and the alignment of
the pillars supporting the beam on the right17, pushing on towards
the rock face of the cliff in the background, the basis of which
seems to have been smoothed out into a stage where a virginal
stands: its vanishing point.
If the vanishing point conditions the sense of perspective, the
sense of the shot is to be looked for then in the background, in the
paradoxical consistence of that contrast between the rock face and
the stage –both conjuring up a sense of reality vanishing away in
appearances and signs.