Chapter 15: The return to order

In the Alfonsine songbook, inserted every nine pieces, there is a more dogmatic praise song than the other hundreds of narrative pieces. The problem of the nature of Mary is expressed more strongly in these songs, but it is in the miracles and their illustration where the nuances of representation are best captured. We will now see how the image allows for a return to order.

The truth is that the illustrations do not exactly correspond to the text, as they introduce nuances that were foreign to its construction. We know that the miniatures are the work of monks, but we ignore which monks they are. However, we find Cistercian influence in the clarity of the background, the body itself, and the clothing of the Virgin in action. Michel Pastoureau explains this. If, for Suger, color is light, on the contrary, for Bernardo, color is matter that hides the paper or the first fiber, obstructing the transitus, the path of the man towards God through the image.

And if in these miniatures Mary remains the most important figure, other supernatural actors, the angels, populate her space (F7-F8). The frequency of their presence in the image far exceeds their mention in the text. They appear on more than 60 pages out of 210 and five times solely in the 192 texts illustrated in the Codex Rico. In the fifth vignette of the song 10, two angels with sharp wings inhabit the space delimited by the lower arches, seemingly aiding Mary in her role as protector while the text does not mention their presence. They wear white tunics similar to the long robes of the 13th century, they are fair-haired, and their diaphanous feathered wings capture the light. The angelic profusion opposes the uniqueness of Mary, deconstructing the cliché of singularity. Mary cannot exist alone; she is the unique mother of God, but her action is supported by several angels.

Maybe. Provided these role functions of mother and/or

enchantress immemorially assigned to the woman be read in the

perspective of the woman only and that movie which can’t be

but hers in its economy and poetics, and be reconsidered from

that notion of distance introduced from the start –the distance

made woman–, right from the first word –the name of the title–

right from the first shots –Johnny looking around: the distance of

a point of view which convokes and contests sense immemorially purveyed by that reason which is one, as it proceeds from

God, the father and the lordly man– what Derrida calls “phallogocentrism”5

.

Going to meet the woman (F3) without knowing she’s already there in

the facts and forms of that incipit; that’s Johnny and his self if

any, riding along the canyon, down to that valley where is

nested Vienna’s saloon. He’s covered an undefined distance

which, despite the machine blasting its way across the landscape, is not the measure of the man expected in a western, of

the real man, of the hero who is introduced on top of the hill,

shot up from below, aesthetically dominant and powerful,

lordly should we say, were it not the guitar and its anti-climactic effect –an “antilogos weapon,” Hélène Cixous might

have called it (880)6

.

He is Johnny Guitar, as the title has just told us, and like the

title, revealed and veiled7

. In the shadow. For lurking beneath, is

not so much Logan as Vienna and her story about to be told, the

story of a woman which has already started, which doesn’t mean

presence but pretense first and last. Twice pretending:

First, the name happens to actually refer to a characteristic

–guitar– at the expense of the character, the player going out and

the instrument coming in (F4). And that’s what he will be, an

instrument8

: the incidental hero for the purpose of the plot

(1.22.17).

Second, the name reveals itself as a mask behind which

there is yet another, or, boiling down to the same, a “hollow”

as the onomastics of “Logan” teaches us. Hollowed out, as he

is, of the expected properties of western manliness because

the declared gunslinger will be played out from the expected

Oxford History of the American West,

Clyde A. Milner II, O'Connor,

Sandweiss Eds. (Oxford: OuP,

1994), p. 695) And we won't fail to

mention what Truffaut said about

Ray's hero being "invariably a man

lashing out, weak, a child-man

when he is not simply a

child."('L'Admirable Certitude',

Cahiers du Cinéma, n°46, avril 1955,

written under the pseudonym

Robert Lachenay).

5 La Carte Postale (Paris: Flammarion, 1980), pp. 501-510.

6 Hélène CIXOuS, "The Laugh

of the Medusa". 1975. Trans. Keith

Cohen & Paula Cohen. Signs, (The

university of Chicago Press: Vol.

1, No. 4, Summer, 1976), p. 880.

7 A title which, for that matter,

turns out to be less thematic than

rhematic (cf. G. GENETTE. Seuils.

Paris: Ed. du Seuil, 1987) since it

insists-its duplicity being grantedon how the theme will be dealt

with more than on the theme

itself. The question is therefore

aesthetic, from the start.

Jean-Louis Brunel

52

t&f

final duel, hollowed out and filled in from the start by the sense of

Vienna –his better self to be found by Vienna. “Follow me,” she

says. To the mineshaft (1.21.50), to another sense.

It is the sense of what has none, logically, in that it loiters

away from the logos and looms large when its potency –the Word of God,

the stance of man– has run out. Or when, because of a guitar and also

maybe of pants tucked into boots (00.15.59), the full presence of Johnny is

deflated into a mere semblance. In the inchoative shadow of his name

and appearance is initiated therefore a series of images and forms in the

stead of a succession of facts and connectionsfor want of a settled and substantial beginning which would have shaped and showed the supposedly

prime and proper way.

Hence, this stagecoach attack (F5) under Johnny’s mocking eyes (F6),

which represents much less some catalytic event setting the plot in motion

–who cares who did it? it’s

just another pretense– than

a compulsory topos of the

western, and, in that sense

serving the genre more

than the plot and as such to

be regarded as a self-reflexive, metafilmic moment

which not only blows up

verisimilitude but ushers in the treason of a genre9 left down there

in the bottom of the canyon, and the idea that back up here on top

of the cliff might be just a western of sort.