Chapter 22: Keep my Distance
Finley P.O.V.
I left Evangeline in her room and along with her, lots of regrets. I didn't regret taking her home, or helping her take her clothes off, but I know what storm this may bring to her and I was going to regret it.
When I first saw Evangeline in the dining hall, I was immediately captivated. Her brown hair fell in all the right places, her eyes were a beautiful forest green that I could easily get lost in. The outfit she had on showed a peek of her skin that was slightly tan and smooth.
Everything about her pulled me in, so when Richards asked if someone would help her during archery, I knew it had to be me.
Her face was priceless that day. The way her lips turned into a scowl every time was adorable.
Serenity had approached me that day, demanding to know who she was and why I was showing her an ounce of attention.
This girl annoyed me to no end. There was nothing left there after we broke up 3 months ago but she was still obsessed with keeping my attention to herself.
As much as I wanted to invest myself in Evangeline and get to know her, I always stopped myself when I remembered Lily. I never saw her again after that party, and I was determined to keep Serenity away from Evangeline to prevent the same outcome.
At the party, I knew what Serenity was doing. Her hands on me felt wrong, like every place she touched I would need to scrub clean later. The thing was, I wasn't allowed to entertain anyone else, but I knew what she was up to around campus, or more who she was up to. She was seriously deranged.
I had to watch Evangeline be taken away by her friend as I peeled Serenity off of me. She begged to go upstairs, but my mind was on someone else, and there was no way I wanted to be Serenity's sloppy seconds or hundreth of the day.
I eventually found who I was looking for, tangled up in a mess with some guy who was clearly as drunk as she was. The way her cheeks flushed and her eyes widen when she saw me will forever be engrained in my mind. She was beautiful, in every way. The small dress she worse hugged her in all the right places, and her heels let her stand just a bit taller.
Walking her back to her dorm was honestly the closest I wanted to get to her. I didn't want to further any issue that Serenity had with her or cause any more drama to spiral out of control. But I couldn't help myself. She asked me to help her with her dress and I knew it was over. Until her friend came back and interrupted us.
After leaving her dorm, I walked back to the house. I could've just taken her upstairs to my room, but I knew there was a chance Serenity was already in there half naked like she had been doing for the last week.
I made it upstairs and pushed open my bedroom door. As expected, Serenity was laid out over my bed in lingerie.
"Get out." I said to her flatly.
Her smile faltered and she stood up off the bed.
"Why can't we just have a bit of fun tonight! You used to always love me showing up like this." She pouted and gave that fake look that used to work on me honestly.
"Because Serenity, we're over, just like I've told you the other thousand times. Now get out." I moved to open the door so I didn't feel trapped in the room with her. I didn't feel lust or desire like I had just felt with Evangeline, I felt hatred, disgust, and the stuffiness she brought to the room.
"It's because of that girl isn't it? You like her, just like you liked Lily." She didn't move from the spot she was in. A smug look crossed her face as she looked me up and down.
"You're like a love-sick puppy, but does it ever work out for you Finley? I'm the only person that's ever been able to give you what you need and you know it."
I stayed silent. I wasn't going to let her rile me up like she had done in the past.
"You may not want me now, but you always come crawling back. Evangeline will leave you just as Lily did. She doesn't want you, you know that. You're chasing a ghost."
"Get out Serenity, and don't come back here. Don't speak to me, don't come looking for me. You honestly disgust me at this point. Now leave."
She stayed in her place for a couple more seconds saying nothing. I could tell I was getting under her skin by the way her skin was turning red. I didn't care anymore. She wasn't going to continue to play with me like I was one of her dolls.
Eventually she huffed and stormed out of my room, slamming the door in the process.
I heard another knock on the door and let out a heavy sigh.
"I told you, don't come back-" I opened the door to find Jake standing in front of me.
"Oh hey man, sorry I thought you were someone else."
"Yeah I know, I just heard her run out of the front door, literally run."
I just shrugged and opened the door wider for him to step inside.
"So what was that all about?"
"I'm done with her man, she's been really pissing me off lately with all of her shit."
Jake's expression went from neutral to shocked like he never expected me to say those words.
"Are you for real this time? You guys have been at it for months like this."
"Yeah, times are changing dude. I've been telling her it's over over for a few weeks now. Then she shows up here in my room and expects me to take her back or something? Nah, I'm over it."
"Is this about Evangeline? I saw you leave with her and so did Serenity."
I said nothing. Part of it was because of Evangeline, but not in the way he's implying.
"You know Serenity isn't going to stop messing with her right? She's probably going to push harder now."
I still stayed quiet. I knew that. I was afraid of that. I enjoyed spending the little time I did with Evangeline, but I knew I couldn't let it continue if it meant putting her in harms way. Even if Serenity wasn't going to physically hurt her, she would mentally tear her down. I had faith in Evangeline, she was tough, but I didn't know how far Serenity would take it.
"I'll just keep my distance from Evangeline."
"Are you going to be able to do that?"
"Yes."
But could I?