Chapter 21: Temptress

We quickly got up and bolted for the bathroom.

Juniper and Jeremy came stumbling into the room, one of them giggling at what the other one said.

"Oh fuck, what are we going to do?" I groaned and placed my back against the bathroom door.

Finley kept staring at me with bedroom eyes, clearly with his mind on other matters and not the current one that was burning right in front of us.

"We could just pick up where we left off and finish in here. They're drunk and in their own world."

He caged me in with his arms against the bathroom door and placed his face into the crook of my neck, sucking slightly on my skin.

I closed my eyes and moaned, gripping Finley's shoulders to keep myself from collapsing.

"Is someone in the bathroom? Evie are you in there? Are you okay?"

My eyes shot open and I pushed Finley away from me.

"Uh, yes! Sorry, I drank too much and don't feel well."

Finley gave his signature smile and crossed his arms over his chest. God that chest was stunning, I just wanted to lick it, touch it, claim it as mine.

"Do you want me to help you? We can go get you like a gatorade or something?"

If I could get Jeremy and Juniper out of the room, that would give Finley plenty of time to leave.

"Yes! That would be great! And could you get me a small snack maybe?"

"Um sure, are you sure you're okay? You sound weird."

"Totally fine. Just the drink and snack if you could, please."

"Alright, we'll be back."

I sighed and slouched on the door. I looked up at Finley and gave him a dirty look.

"What! I didn't tell them to come back!"

"Let's get you out of here before you cause me more problems that you already have."

I peeked out the bathroom door to make sure that they were gone. Finley stepped out and quickly put his shirt on.

As I was getting a tshirt and shorts on, the door swung open again.

I froze as Juniper looked between me, then Finley, and then back at me. She gave me a toothy grin, "Actually Jeremy I found it!"

Juniper started closing the door, but not before mouthing 'we'll talk later' and a wink towards Finley.

Great, my secret almost hookup was no longer a secret.

I groaned while Finley gave a heavy laugh.

"That wasn't funny! She's going to grill me all night now thanks to you."

"Thanks to me?? You were the one being the temptress, I was just the poor soul who fell into your trap."

Finley grinned and made his way over to me.

He wrapped his arms around me and planted a kiss to the top of my head.

"I don't regret it for a second though short stack. We can role-play you being my temptress any day of the week." He winked while I started pushing him away.

"You're gross. Go home so I can go to sleep!"

"That's not what you were saying not even 15 minutes ago! What was it that you said...'it feels amazing'?"

I rolled my eyes and made my way to the door. "See you later cocky, time's up."

He strolled towards the door and stopped just before passing the threshold. He spun on his heel and looked down at me.

"See you tomorrow Evangeline." Finley gave my lips a quick peck before turning and leaving down the hall.

I shut the door and put my back up against it. My lips still tingled from where he just kissed me, even if it was the lightest kiss in the world, he still left his mark on me.

Eventually Juniper and Jeremy came back. Juniper of course knew who had just been in our room while Jeremy was clueless as ever.

"Alright babe, I'm really tired and I'm sure Evie isn't feeling great still so we should call it for tonight."

"Oh, uh, okay. Just call me tomorrow then? I hope you start to feel better Evangeline." Jeremy set the bag down on my desk and left the room quickly.

Before the door even shut Juniper was on my bed and in my face.

"Tell. Me. Everything!!" I winced at how loud she was.

"Calm down! Nothing even happened because YOU interrupted us!" I jabbed my finger at her and she backed up, leaning back on her legs while still staring at me.

"I know something happened, you're cheeks are flushed and your hair is crazy."

I brought my hands up to my cheeks. They were warm, but I also had a pound of makeup on from the party.

"We just kissed."

"Liar."

"Maybe a bit more."

"Come on Evie, spill the details! What's that man look like without a shirt on!"

I flopped back onto my bed. "So hot. Too hot. Should be illegal hot. Like came straight out of a magazine hot. His abs could probably cut glass and my god his arms, ugh!" I let out a long sigh. That man was definitely every girls wet dream.

Juniper laid down beside me and we both stared at the ceiling.

"Text me next time and I'll stay over at Jeremy's so you can get lucky. I'll always support you getting those needs fulfilled girl, especially if it's getting filled by Finley, if you know what I mean." She winked and gave me a nudge.

"You're gross. I doubt there will be a next time."

"That boy likes you Evie, you're the first girl he's ever showed interest in since Lily."

My mind went blank after she mentioned Lily. I hadn't forgotten the story she told me. Maybe getting this close to Finley was too dangerous. Letting my clouded judgment lead the way probably wasn't the best idea.

"Stop overthinking it. If you're thinking about Serenity, just remember what he told her at the party. I might've been drunk off my ass but I will always remember her face after he said that to her. Priceless."

Serenity being knocked off her post was satisfying to watch, but that didn't mean she was going to go down without staying true to what she told me before.

Either way I knew I was screwed.

"Let's go to bed! I'm still tipsy and I'm sure you might be too."

Juniper hopped of my bed and headed to the bathroom to undress for the night.

I stayed where I was, staring at the ceiling. I couldn't help but let my mind wander to all of the endless possibilities of where this could all go.

Wherever it went, I knew I would have to watch my back at every turn.