Chapter 37

My back hit the wall of the pool house, Cain’s mouth descending on mine in a fevered, desperate kiss that set fire to every inch of me.

I gripped his shirt collar, pulling him roughly against me.

Our hands roamed, his disappearing under my dress to cup my ass, mine threading through his short brown hair and tugging hard, making him groan against my mouth.

“There’s no way you like it rough when you’re with my brother,” he said, pulling away, eyes narrowed.

I bit my bottom lip, my chest heaving, and shook my head.

His expression darkened and his hard body collided with mine, teeth biting my neck.

“The perfect little princess with Kyle,” he said against my throat. “The kinky brat with me.”

I shoved at his chest but it barely registered, a wicked grin spreading across his face.

“So, you do like it rough.”

I rolled my eyes. “Enough with the commentary.”

He smirked before our mouths fused again, heat searing through me. He had me pressed against the wall so hard I was in danger of melding with it, but I wasn’t going to tell him to stop. I wanted him. Had wanted him for as long as I

could remember and I was finally having him.

But only behind closed doors.

In the real world, the cocky former captain of our high school’s basketball team liked to pretend he hated me.

Just like I pretended I wanted his brother more.

That was until moments like this—hidden in the shadows at a party to celebrate the latest successful joint business venture between our families—with our mouths fused and Cain’s hand up my skirt.

That same hand moved to the front of my dress, fingers slipping into my white lace panties, but I gripped his wrist to stop him.

“I have to go,” I said, pushing him off me and re-adjusting my dress.

He scowled as I headed for the door. “What the fuck?”

“I have to get back to the party.”

“To do what? Go find your cheating weasel of a boyfriend?”

I crossed my arms over my chest. “He’s your brother,

Cain. You shouldn’t talk about him like that.”

Even if what he said was true. Kyle had cheated on me last year, but my parents had forced me to stay with him anyway.

Cain stalked towards me, closing the space between us. “My brother is a joke. You know you don’t want him or you wouldn’t be in here with me.”

His hand closed around my hip, guiding me towards him.

“I can show you a good time right here, and you know it.”

He leaned down, mouth seeking mine again and I wanted to kiss him so badly. Only I couldn’t. I couldn’t let him win this power game he loved to play or it would ruin everything.

If Cain ever found out how much I wanted him—how much I wanted more with him—our hook-ups would be over faster than I could say “dirty little secret”. Cain only wanted me because he couldn’t have me. I was his secret addiction. And the fastest way to one-up his brother.

In public, he all but ignored me. And if he bothered to look my way, it was to deliver some cutting remark about what a good little girl I was for always obeying my parents or what a total bore I’d become. Which was why I always made sure to pull away first during our secret hook-ups. To leave him wanting more of what he shouldn’t even have. I knew it drove him crazy, which is exactly why I did it. I had to stay one step ahead in this little game of secrets and lust or I’d lose the only boy I’d ever truly cared about.

I pressed my fingertips to his lips, stopping his mouth before it could meet mine.

“You’re right. I know all about the good time you’ll show me. I’ll slide off my thong so you can fuck me against the wall and the moment we’re done, you’ll go back to the party and pretend I’m nothing to you. Or better yet, you’ll go back to college and forget I even exist.”

Cain’s heated gaze roamed my body, his hand sliding from my hip to my ass. “What did you say? All I heard was thong and now I need to see it.”

His hand slid under the hem of my dress again, but I pushed from his grasp, knowing how monumentally pissed my rejection would make him.

“I don’t feel like being fucked and then fucked over,” I said over my shoulder as I reached the door.

He tipped his head back and groaned at the ceiling. “Fuck

Daphne, come on.”

“Have a good night, Cain.”

I pulled the door shut behind me, fighting a smile. The sudden music and chatter of the party overwhelmed me after the quiet of the pool house.

It had been three weeks since Cain had been home from college for the weekend and we’d last hooked up. And I’d hated myself every second that I’d spent thinking about him while he was gone. My stomach had knotted every time I’d passed his former basketball teammates in the halls at school or I was over at the Cashman house with Kyle. Even when Cain was home, he usually acted as though I barely existed and hooked up with every girl who so much as breathed near him, while I pretended I didn’t care.

Yet we inevitably found our way back together.

Always in places like the pool house or his car or a bathroom, which had happened at the annual Corona Del Mar Tennis Club casino night fundraiser two months ago.

I wasn’t about to strip down for him now because he was half drunk, horny, and none of his usual basketball bunnies were interesting enough.

I’d never imagined growing up with the Cashman brothers that I’d one day find myself caught between them— Kyle as my boyfriend and secretly hooking up with Cain whenever he deigned to look my way.

But if it were my choice, Kyle and I would have broken up a long time ago.

Only… I didn’t get a say in who I dated. Didn’t get a say in much of my own life thanks to my parents. The Cashman and Montaigne families—and our money—were too deeply entwined for me to jeopardise any kind of relationship with the Cashmans. Both sets of parents saw Kyle and I being together as another way to solidify their business deals.

What or who I wanted was never a consideration.

“There you are, babe,” Kyle said, pushing through the party guests. He slung an arm around my shoulders and dragged me across the pool deck with him. “I’ve been looking for you. A few of us are hanging out by the hot tub. We’re about to do shots.”

I screwed up my nose. I hated shots. Hard liquor screwed with my training. Our tennis coach always ripped us a new one when he suspected we’d been out partying, making us run suicides up and down the court until we puked.

Kyle knew that, he just didn’t seem to care.

But I slipped back into my role as his doting, docile girlfriend, letting him shepherd me towards a group of kids from school whose parents had been important enough to warrant an invitation to the Montaigne-Cashman celebration of the season.

“Here she is! Thank fuck for that,” Pacer—one of Kyle’s football buddies—said as we approached, lining up a bunch of shot glasses on a tray and filling them with bourbon. “Kyle wouldn’t let the real party start without his ball and chain by his side.”

I forced out a wan smile at Pacer’s dig. Kyle’s teammates had about as much respect for me as I had for them. They saw me as an inconvenience Kyle insisted on parading everywhere with him, and I saw them for what they were — useless jocks who hated women.

I pitied the girls who threw themselves at these boys just because they were footballers. I couldn’t imagine they left the bedroom with much more than a few hickeys and a disappointing story. Not that I’d ever voice that. It was my job to keep Kyle happy.

Pulling me down on the bench seat beside him, Kyle thrust a shot at me. “Here, drink this.”

I wrinkled my nose. “No, thanks.”

“Come on, Daph. It’s one shot, don’t be such a buzzkill.”

Ignoring Kyle, my gaze snagged on Cain making his way through the party, adjusting the collar on his light blue button-down shirt that I’d pulled askew in the pool house.

I swallowed, pressing my thighs together at the memory of his mouth on mine and his hands under my dress.

He was so frustratingly hot, with his caramel-colored hair, golden-hazel eyes and toned, athletic basketball body. It didn’t help that when I looked at him, I felt the same hum of affection I always had for the boy who had been my best friend when we were kids and who had watched out for me growing up. For me, that feeling had slowly morphed into something so much more the older we got.

For Cain, not so much.

He didn’t mind fucking me in secret, though. Even now, when he’d moved on to college and I was still a high school senior.

When we weren’t hooking up, Cain looked at me with narrowed eyes and a cruel twist of his mouth, like the very sight of me riled him.

He claimed a seat at the table across from us, several of his former teammates slapping him a hello. I worked hard to ignore the way Jennifer Rutledge leaned towards him, draping her impressive cleavage over the arm of his chair. Cain and Jennifer had hooked up last year and had been doing it semi-regularly, whenever they were back home in Corona Del Mar.

I only knew they’d been hooking up last year because I’d accidentally walked in on them “studying” in the kitchen one afternoon when the Cashmans had been out. Cain had been sitting at the table with his head thrown back, while Jennifer was on her knees beneath Mrs Cashman’s antique dining table. I’d tried to quietly back out of the room, but Cain had seen me, staring straight at me with hooded eyes while Jennifer blew him.

I couldn’t understand how my life had ended up this way. Stuck in a relationship I hated, while I watched the boy I really wanted flirt with every girl between here and LA, only speaking to me when it was to groan against my throat while he thrust inside me.

I had no claim to Cain, at least not publicly. But it didn’t stop the jealousy that seared through me at the sight of him and Jennifer together.