Chapter 60
She closed her eyes; the tears cascade down. She clenched her chest tighter, hoping the sharp pain she was feeling would go away. It didn’t—it only nurtured, because she didn’t like what he just said. It’s not what she wants, she doesn’t want to end things with him. She never wants to end things with him.
“It’s not that simple, Hunter. You have to understand…”
“Understand that I don’t mean shit to you. Understand that you still love him even after he treated you like garbage. Or, understand that you never loved me?” His voice was hard to describe at the moment. But his strong narrowed eyes had confirmed to her what she needed to know.
“No… don’t say that. Don’t put words into my mouth…”
“No!” He sprung up. His eyes seethe with rage as he points a finger at her. “You can’t even look me in the eye and tell me you love me! You can’t even say it back to me whenever I confess,” he bellowed angrily as he clenched his first angrily.
Elise took steps back because this was the first time she had witnessed him being so angry with her. She doesn’t know what he’s capable of—she can’t take any chances of getting herself hurt by him. She could feel a searing pain in her heart.
“Just because I don’t say anything, it does not mean that I don’t feel the way that you want me to…”
“Bullshit!” He cursed out, pacing back and forth. It was the only way he could calm himself from turning his room into garbage. “That’s bullshit, Elise. I see the way you look at him.” He was now walking towards her. She walked backward but it didn’t stop him from walking forward. Her back hits the wall and she had no choice but to face him now. He stood tall just few inches away from her. She could feel his warm, fury breath fanning her face. She closed her eyes shut, the fear creeping up from her feet to her head.
“I love you, Elise. I love you so much that I had to just stand there and watch you cry over some asshole that never sees you the way I do. Do you know how shitty that feels? To watch the person you’re dying to be with keep going back to a shitty, toxic lover who only wants to use them?”
Her eyes search his—they held nothing but misery and hopelessness. He’s broken… she broke him.
“You messed me up, Elise. You really did. I lay awake at night, trying to imagine how it could have been if you just had a little bit of spark for me like you did for him. I always thought of what I did wrong, why did I meet you, why did life put you in on my path for you to just keep stabbing my already wounded heart. What exactly do you want me to realize after what you do to me? That I make mistakes or that I get attached too quickly? I don’t regret my mistakes…”
Her heart was beating wildly because every single word that spews out of his mouth cuts her open like a wasted animal. It hurts her to know how much pain she has caused him while all he wanted her to do was to love him.
The fear in her eyes made him to shake his head and shift back until he was sitting on his bed again. He held his head in his palms and breathes air to calm the storm.
“I’m hard to love… I warned you,” she mumbled. The tears had finally stopped and she had finally found her voice again.
She hears him chuckle and it scares her to think what it meant. It was definitely not a pleasant one. Hunter wouldn’t laugh at a situation like this. He’s angry… broken.
“Maybe I should be the one apologizing to you…” He looks up and his brown eyes remained glassy for a moment. “I’m sorry for hoping. I’m sorry for feeling happy whenever I was around you. I’m sorry for thinking it was something good. I’m sorry for feeling loved whenever I kissed you. I’m sorry for ever thinking we were a thing and things were going to work out. I’m sorry for thinking life was giving me a break and I am sorry for caring…”
She abhors that he has lost hope. She abhors that she took away his pain just to smash him back to the excruciating ground he got up from but just worst. She abhors that she was now someone that causes pain to him when she used to be the one thing he gets excited about.
How was she ever going to recover from this? She knew she meant so much to him but not as much as she thought.
“You’re hurting…”
“No, I just need you out of my room.” His words were now malice to her ears and heart. The more he opened to speak, the more hurt and weaker she gets.
She came here to fix things but ended up wrecking it more. He probably hates her now and doesn’t want anything that has to do with her. He’d probably move on if she decides to also leave instead of pushing to fix things.
Someone might make him forget her—Ethan would never make her forget him because Hunter makes her feel things she never knew she could develop in her. He was so easy to love. He made her feel safe. When he held her hand, it was like she was flying. When he kissed her face, you felt like she could fly. He made crossing the road feel like an adventure; with his hand on the small of her back. He laughed at things easily, he was soft, gentle, kind. He understood when she was quiet, when she was loud. He listened. He listened to her words, and he listened to her silence. ‘Come here,’ he would say, with his arms open wide, and she would go. ‘Stay,’ he would beg, and she would stay and she would stay and she would stay…
“I don’t want things to end…” She stood there, like a statue and with a sense of loss so powerful that her muscles wouldn’t respond to commands.
She watches him shake his head in disagreement. He takes his eyes away and duck his head again. He does that whenever he was about to say something really hurtful. “Just get out. You’re the last person I want to lay my eyes on right. Just don’t say a word and quietly leave my room because I don’t want to hear you say anything again. I don’t want to hear your voice again…”
He didn’t want to look her in the eye as he said those words to her because he didn’t want her to see the lies in his eyes. He wanted her to stay, he wanted her to hug him, kiss him and tell him he means everything to her but what’s best for the both of them was space—they needed space to think through what they wanted and if they still wanted to be together.
He hears her gentle footsteps followed by the door opening and closing. He closed his eyes shut at the sound of the door closing behind her as a sudden pain erupts in his chest—it was the same pain he felt when he realized he had lost Larisa and his daughter. Now he was feeling the same pain when Elise walked out of his room. It tortured him to lift his eyes and find out she had really left.