Chapter 59

Hunter hates her. He hates her—she saw how the anger and disappointment washed over his face when he asked her if she still loved Ethan. She saw the loss of hope weakens from his body when he asked if she loved him but she couldn’t answer him. She couldn’t even answer with a yes or no. She just froze to her spot, spewing her eyes out and her body told him her answer. She still has feelings for Ethan.

He tried to hide his emotions but couldn’t veil it. He was hurt by her silence and how she had just showed him she still preferred someone that ditched her to die rather than the one that was ready to sacrifice his life to get her, her favourite flower.

She had never seen him this sad. She had never seen him this distant—not even when she treated him like crap. Maybe because he now has hope in them working out. Maybe because he looks at her as his lover or maybe because she’s factually living in his home as his mate.

She thought she was completely over Ethan, but seeing him now had just brought back old memories—the good ones. It reminded her of his sweet words, his kind gestures and how he used to be all about her.

He was back now and mystifying her. It meant he wants her back?

He just punched one of the strongest men she knows that could tear him in two without even using his werewolf form. Ethan just did that for her to show that he still wanted her. Or he doesn’t? Or he did it to prove a point?

She was too perplexed. She strode back and forth in her room, fiddling with her fingers as she thought of a way to confront Hunter again. She hasn’t seen him since last night they parted ways. She doesn’t know whether he wanted to talk to her but she wants to talk to him.

She hates that she just woke up in the morning it wasn’t his kisses or tempting touches that brought her to wake. She hates that his cologne or aroma of his breakfast wasn’t the first things that she smelt. She hates that his face wasn’t the first thing she saw when she opened her eyes. She hates that the first thing she heard wasn’t his husky voice that always finds its way to her stomach.

She doesn’t want this to be her new norm. She doesn’t want to get used to waking up on her own. Her body was longing for him but her heart was elsewhere. She doesn’t even know how she truly feels about Hunter. Was she into him because he has a body of a Goddess or was she obsessed with his erotic actions. Whichever it was, she doesn’t want it to stop. Maybe she sounds too selfish or maybe it would look as though she was using him just to keep getting treated like she was the only thing that mattered.

She didn’t have to think twice on this, she stepped out of her room and marched toward his room. She wouldn’t stop feeling the guilt eating her up if she doesn’t talk to him. It even felt way worse when she recalls why she’s coming to him at the first place. She didn’t want him to stop treating her the way he does. She feels abashed for showing him that Ethan still hers her heart, but she can’t lie. Even if she does, he’d find out, because he can read her like a book.

She knocks on the door, improvised to face him. She doesn’t even know whether he was home or not. She just knew she hasn’t heard any movement from him. She had checked the kitchen earlier and it was sparkling clean. The house was silent which meant either he had gone out before she woke up or he was still in his room.

She hears the door unlock and he opened it. Her heart drops when their eyes locked. Her lips part to speak but failed. He looks even more exhausted than when she last saw him last night. He rubs his eyes wearily and motions her inside.

She walks in and the first thing that hits her nostrils was his cologne all over the room. She inhaled, her stomach agitating with mixed feelings. She rarely comes to his room unless she needed his attention and he was teasing her. She had never slept in here but it definitely looks comfortable to her though his interior was black and grey. It suits his physique and his identity. It made him look more powerful like he rules the world, not just a pack.

She watched him perch down on the edge of the bed and held his head between his palms. It was obvious he didn’t want to look at her and he most certainly didn’t want to talk to her.

She pursed her lips—she was hoping he’d be the first to speak up, at least ask why she was in his room. She was so used to having him doing things her way that it feels like she had just lost him by her injudicious, egocentric interests.

“Can we talk?” She spoke lowly but he heard her loud and clear, possibly a little bit too loud by the way he chuckled dryly and shakes his head.

“Isn’t that why you’re here?” He throws her the question. She exhales and nod her head as his deep voice flashed through her entire body.

“Yes…” It has occurred to her how unprepared she was not that he was sitting before her. She pressed her lips together and brushed her palms over her dress. She has never seen him this way and it made her feel more obnoxious to know she’s the reason of his downfall.

She has to fix it.

“Could you at least look at me, please? I want to apologize,” she said contritely. Maybe if he looks at her, the words would come out and she’d tell him everything he wants to hear—everything he needs to hear. Maybe she’d find the right words to apologize to him.

He lifts his tired eyes and fixed them on her. She tilts her head, gripping on her tightened chest. Seeing him this miserable was enough to tell her how much she means to him. It hadn’t been twelve hours since the incident but he was already looking despondent and morose.

“I shouldn’t have acted that way. I shouldn’t have made you feel like you didn’t mean something to me.”

He shoulder-shrugs her words as if they were nothing. As if he doesn’t believe her.

“So, you’re apologizing…” He takes his eyes off her before she could see what was written in his eyes and stared out the blank space.

Her eyes widen with hope as her lips curl into a grin. “Yes, I’m so sorry.”

Hunter releases a heavy breath and let his head fall. He doesn’t even know how he was feeling, he doesn’t even know what to think of or how to handle the pain and misery that she had led him into. Maybe he trusted her too soon, maybe he shouldn’t have put his hopes high on her and maybe if he starts putting himself above everyone’s needs, he wouldn’t be treated this way.

“Ok.” He nods his head. “I don’t forgive you.” He raised his head to look at her and he saw the disappointment clearly written all over her face. She shakes her head slowly, rejecting what he had just said to her.

“But… I said I’m sorry.”

“Yeah, I heard you but I do not forgive you.”

She stood there for a couple of seconds, staring at him in scepticism. A little part of her was hoping he’d laugh it out and tell her he was joking. A bit of her wanted him to get on his feet right now and take her into his arms, and tell her how he loves her they should bury their past with a large cup of ice cream while they chatted away.

He didn’t do that. He just stared back at her with a look she wasn’t sure what it meant. She clenched her fist and hold it up to her chest. The erratic beat of her heart and the rapid expansion of her lungs to make room for more air were the only two things she could focus on right now.

She was even afraid to speak again because it might upset him. It was the last thing she’d want to do now after she had already screwed up her chance with him.

And if she were really going to be honest with herself, she doesn’t exactly even know what she wants from him. All she knows is if he forgives her now, she’d feel less guilty for stupidly choosing Ethan over him.

“Look, just because you asked me if I still love him and I show signs that I may still do, it doesn’t mean that I’m going back to him.” A lone tear gushed out. She hates how cheap her tears were. She’d cry her eyes out whether it was a happy moment or a sad moment like this one.

He hummed and nod his head. He didn’t look at her—he just looked ahead for a moment before he chuckled dryly and shook his head. It scared her that he just did that because right now, she doesn’t know who he is. She has never seen this side of him.

“I’m not going to hold you back if you decide to go back to him, Elise. It’s up to you. If you decide to go back to him, I promise you; you will never hear from me again. I will get out of your hair and that will be it.”