Chapter 9: Unwelcome Artifacts (Evelyn's POV)
The knock came exactly three minutes after Daniel's car disappeared from the parking lot, like whoever was outside had been counting the seconds.
I froze on the bed, Daniel's warnings still echoing in my head. If Jonas shows up, you call me immediately.
"Evelyn?" Jonas's voice filtered through the door, quieter than I'd ever heard it. "I know you're in there. I saw Ward leave."
My phone sat on the nightstand, Daniel's number already pulled up on the screen. One tap and he'd come racing back, turn this into another confrontation, another accusation. Another moment where Jonas looked at me like I'd chosen someone else over him.
I stood slowly, moving toward the door. "You shouldn't be here."
"I know." A pause. "But I need to show you something. Something I found in your father's house."
"Daniel said I can't..."
"Daniel isn't here." Not angry, just stating fact. "And what I found... it belonged to your mother. I think she'd want you to have it."
My hand hovered over the doorknob. Every rational instinct screamed at me to call Daniel, to follow the rules, to stay locked inside like a good protected witness. But the mention of my mother pulled at something deeper, something that remembered Jonas as the boy who'd held my hand at her funeral, who'd never once blamed me for running.
I opened the door.
Jonas stood in the hallway holding a leather-bound book, its cover cracked with age and stained with something that might have been water or might have been darker. He looked exhausted, his sheriff's uniform rumpled, shadows under his eyes that matched my own.
"You've been watching the parking lot," I said.
"I needed to talk to you without Ward hovering like a guard dog." He glanced past me into the room. "Can I come in? Just for a minute. I promise I'm not here to hurt you."
I stepped aside, letting him enter. He moved past me carefully, maintaining distance, and set the book on the desk with surprising gentleness.
"I've been going through your father's things," Jonas said. "The house is part of the crime scene now, but Ward gave me access to help catalog personal effects. I found this hidden in your mother's old sewing room, behind a loose board in the closet."
I moved closer, drawn by the book despite myself. The leather was worn smooth by years of handling, the edges gilded in tarnished gold. No title marked the spine, but I could see faint impressions where something had been stamped into the cover, symbols that looked like the Cross family sigil, circular and intricate.
"What is it?"
"A diary. Your mother's, I think. Maybe your grandmother's before her." Jonas opened it carefully, revealing pages filled with handwriting that shifted and changed, different hands, different inks, different decades bleeding into each other. "It goes back generations. All the Cross women, documenting... something."
I reached out to touch the page, then pulled back. "Why bring it to me? You should give this to Daniel, let forensics..."
"Forensics will lock it away as evidence and you'll never see it again." Jonas turned to face me fully. "Evelyn, I read some of it. Not all—it felt wrong, like reading someone's confession. But enough to know it's important. Enough to know it might explain what's happening."
"What did it say?"
He flipped through pages, stopping at an entry near the middle. The handwriting was my mother's—I'd recognize it anywhere, the careful loops and precise slants. "Read this. From about six months before she died."
I leaned over his shoulder, close enough to smell his familiar scent—coffee and pine and something uniquely Jonas. The words swam into focus:
March 15, 2005. The dreams are getting worse. Every night, the Hollow calls to me, shows me what it wants. It wants Evelyn. My beautiful girl, my firstborn daughter, the one I was supposed to give to it on her sixteenth birthday. The bloodline demands a sacrifice, it always has. My mother tried to run and it dragged her back. Her mother tried to fight and it consumed her slowly. There's no escaping what we are, what we owe. But I won't let it have her. I won't.
My throat closed up. "She knew. She knew something was coming for me."
"Keep reading," Jonas said quietly.
April 3, 2005. I've tried everything. Salt circles, iron nails, prayers to gods that stopped listening to the Cross family generations ago. Nothing works. The Hollow is patient. It will wait until Evelyn comes of age, and then it will take what it's owed. Unless I give it something else. Unless I offer myself instead.
"No." The word came out broken. "No, she didn't..."
"There's more." Jonas turned another page, his jaw tight. "From the day before she died."
May 19, 2005. Tomorrow is Evelyn's birthday. Tomorrow, the Hollow comes to collect. But I've made my choice. If I give myself willingly, maybe it will be satisfied. Maybe it will release its claim on my daughter. Maybe she can leave this cursed place and never look back. I'm not strong enough to fight it. But I'm strong enough to die for her. I hope that's enough. I hope she never comes back. I hope she never knows what I did.
Tears blurred my vision, hot and sudden. "She didn't kill herself because she was sick. She killed herself to save me."
"She tried to save you," Jonas corrected gently. "But you came back anyway."
"Because my father died. I had to come back for the funeral."
"Or something pull you back Make it impossible to stay away, even though every instinct told you not to come?"
I thought about the phone call from the lawyer, the overwhelming compulsion to return despite my terror. The way I'd found myself booking a flight before I'd consciously decided to come. "I don't know."
"The diary talks about that too. About how the Hollow binds its chosen. How running makes it stronger, makes it hunger more." Jonas moved to the window, looking out at the morning light. "Your mother's sacrifice bought you ten years of freedom. But the curse doesn't end. It just waits."
"That's impossible."
"You've heard the whispers. You've seen the blood that shouldn't exist. People are dying, Evelyn, and every death is marked with your family's sigil. How much more impossible does it need to get before you stop pretending there's a rational explanation?"
"Daniel says..."
"Daniel doesn't understand this town. He doesn't understand what lives in these woods, what feeds on pain and betrayal." Jonas's voice roughened with frustration. "He thinks he can solve this with evidence and logic, like it's just another case. But some things don't care about facts. Some things are older and darker and hungry."
"You believe in the curse."
"I've lived here my whole life. I've seen what happens to people who dismiss the old stories as superstition." He moved back to the desk, placing his hand on the diary. "My grandfather was sheriff before me. He investigated a series of deaths in the seventies—same patterns, same symbols, same connection to the Cross family. He called it a serial killer. Two weeks later, they found him in the woods with his heart cut out."
I wrapped my arms around myself. "Why didn't you tell me this before?"
"Because you left. Because I thought if you stayed away, maybe the curse would forget about you. Maybe you'd be safe." His eyes met mine, filled with old pain. "But you came back. And now people are dying again."
"You think it's my fault."
I reached for the book, my fingers brushing his. The leather was warm, almost alive beneath my touch. "Daniel won't want me to have this."
"Daniel wants to control the narrative. Control you." Jonas didn't let go immediately, holding my gaze. "But you're not his suspect or his witness. You're Evelyn. The girl who taught me to skip stones on Larkin Lake. The girl who kissed me behind the bleachers and swore we'd leave this place together someday. You're allowed to make your own choices."
"Even bad ones?"
"Especially those." A ghost of a smile crossed his face, there and gone. "I've missed you. The real you, not this scared version who jumps at shadows and lets federal agents tell her who she can talk to."
"I've missed you too," I admitted. "But Jonas, if there's really a curse—if my being here is making people die—maybe Daniel's right. Maybe I should be locked up somewhere safe until..."
"There is no safe. Not for you. Not from this." He finally released the diary, stepping back. "Read it. All of it. Then decide who you trust—the man who's known you for three days, or the man who's loved you for twenty years."
"Ward's on his way back." He moved toward the door. "Hide the diary. Don't let him take it. The answers you need are in those pages, but only if you actually read them."
"Jonas, wait..."
He paused at the threshold. "I meant what I said. I love you. I never stopped. And I'll do whatever it takes to keep you alive, even if that means going against Ward, against the whole damn investigation." His voice dropped lower. "Even if it means believing in monsters."
Then he was gone, slipping out into the hallway just as I heard a car pull into the parking lot below—Daniel's rental, arriving faster than should have been possible.
I clutched the diary to my chest, my heart hammering. Jonas's words echoed in my head, tangling with my mother's written confessions, with the weight of secrets that suddenly felt heavier than I could carry alone.
The knock on my door came hard and official.
"Evelyn. Open up."
Daniel's voice, clipped with barely controlled anger. I shoved the diary under the bed's dust ruffle, straightening just as the door opened—he must have gotten a key from the front desk.
He stood in the doorway, taking in my flushed face and defensive posture with a single sweeping glance. "Jonas was here."
"He left."
"I can smell his cologne." Daniel stepped inside, closing the door behind him with deliberate calm. "What did he want?"
"To talk."
"About?"
"My mother. The town. Old memories." I forced myself to hold his gaze, to not look at the bed where the diary lay hidden. "He apologized for how he's been treating me."
"And you believed him."
"Why wouldn't I?"
Daniel moved deeper into the room, his eyes scanning every surface, every corner. "Because Jonas Hale is either a suspect in an active murder investigation or dangerously close to becoming one. Because I specifically told you to call me if he showed up. Because you're hiding something."
"I'm not..."
"Don't." He cut me off, his voice dropping to something cold and dangerous. "Don't lie to me, Evelyn. I can see it in your face, in the way you're standing like you're protecting something. What did he give you?"
My pulse spiked. "Nothing."
"Then you won't mind if I search the room."
"You can't do that without a warrant."
"I can if I believe you're concealing evidence relevant to a federal investigation." He pulled out his phone. "One call and I have a team here in twenty minutes. Or you can tell me the truth and save us both the trouble."
We stared at each other, the air crackling with tension. I could feel the diary under the bed like a living thing, pulsing with secrets Daniel would never understand. Secrets I wasn't sure I understood myself.
But Jonas's words haunted me: Decide who you trust.
"He brought me a book," I said finally. "From my mother's things. A diary."
Daniel's expression didn't change, but something flickered in his eyes. "Where is it?"
"Under the bed."
He crouched down, pulling out the leather-bound volume with latex-gloved hands I hadn't noticed him putting on. He must have gloved up before entering, already knowing what he'd find.
"Did you read it?" he asked, still examining the book.
"Some of it."
"And?"
"And my mother believed in the curse. She thought something was coming for me. She killed herself trying to stop it." The words tumbled out, defensive and angry. "That's what you wanted to hear, right? More evidence that my family was delusional?"
Daniel stood slowly, tucking the diary into an evidence bag he'd pulled from his jacket pocket. "What I want is the truth. What I'm getting is a witness who's being manipulated by a suspect with a clear emotional agenda."
"Jonas isn't manipulating me."
"Jonas is in love with you. Love makes people do desperate things." He sealed the evidence bag with sharp, precise movements. "This diary is now evidence. It will be photographed, analyzed, and stored according to protocol. If it contains information relevant to the case, I'll share what I can."
"It's my mother's diary. It belongs to me."
"It belongs to the investigation." His gray eyes were flat, unyielding. "And you're going to stop having private conversations with Jonas Hale. That's not a request."
"You can't tell me who I can talk to."
"I can when that person is compromising an active investigation and your safety." He moved toward the door, then paused. "I came back because the medical examiner flagged something in Sarah Kellerman's autopsy. But now I'm wondering if I can trust anything you tell me, or if Jonas has already poisoned the well."
The accusation stung more than it should have. "I haven't lied to you."
"You've omitted. You've hidden. You've let a suspect into your room and accepted contraband evidence without reporting it." He opened the door, the diary clutched in his other hand. "That ends now. You don't talk to Jonas unless I'm present. You don't accept anything from anyone without clearing it with me first. And you definitely don't keep secrets that could get you or someone else killed."
"Or what? You'll arrest me?"
"Or I'll stop being able to protect you. Your choice, Evelyn. Trust the process, or become part of the problem."
He left without waiting for a response, taking my mother's words with him.
I sank onto the bed, fury and frustration warring with the sick feeling that I'd just made everything worse. The space under the bed felt empty now, violated. Jonas had trusted me to keep the diary safe, and I'd given it up within minutes of Daniel's interrogation.
Decide who you trust.
But what if I didn't know how to trust anyone anymore—including myself?