Chapter 8: Fractured Reflections (Evelyn's POV)

I woke to the sound of knocking; sharp, insistent, already inside my dreams before dragging me out of them.

My eyes cracked open to find weak morning light filtering through the gauzy curtains of the Rosewood Inn. The connecting door stood open, just as Daniel had left it. Through the gap, I could see his room empty, the laptop closed, case files stacked in precise towers on the desk.

The knocking came again, this time from the hallway door.

"Evelyn? It's Daniel. I'm coming in."

I sat up as he entered, carrying two paper coffee cups and a folder tucked under his arm. His hair was damp from a recent shower, his gray eyes alert despite the early hour. He'd changed into a fresh button-down, sleeves rolled to his elbows, revealing forearms marked with faint scars I hadn't noticed before.

"What time is it?" My voice came out rough with sleep.

"Seven-thirty. You've been out for about twelve hours." He set one of the coffee cups on the nightstand. "Black, two sugars. I took a guess."

I reached for it gratefully, the warmth seeping into my cold fingers. "You've been watching me sleep?"

"I've been working. Occasionally checking to make sure you were still breathing." He pulled the desk chair over and sat, placing the folder on his lap. "We need to talk about the forensics report."

Something in his tone made my stomach clench. "From the blood on my mirror?"

"Yes." He opened the folder, scanning the top page with a frown. "The results came back faster than expected. I called in some favors, expedited the processing."

"And?"

He looked up, his expression carefully neutral. "The blood is human. Type AB-negative, which is rare, only about one percent of the population. The DNA analysis flagged a match in the system."

I set down the coffee cup before I could drop it. "A match? To who?"

"Margaret Anne Cross. Your mother." He watched me closely as he said it. "Born 1965, died 2005. Dental records, fingerprints, DNA sample taken during autopsy—all on file."

The room tilted sideways. "That's impossible."

"That's what I said when I got the results." Daniel leaned forward, elbows on his knees. "I've requested a re-test, but the lab is confident in their work. The blood on your mirror contains DNA that matches your mother's genetic profile. Not similar to it. Identical to it."

"My mother has been dead for twenty years."

"I'm aware."

"So how does her blood end up in my bedroom?" My voice pitched higher, panic threading through each word. "Did someone preserve it? Store it somehow? Break into the morgue or..."

"Evelyn." Daniel's tone cut through my spiraling thoughts. "Blood degradation begins immediately after death. Even with perfect storage conditions, DNA starts breaking down within hours. What we found on your mirror wasn't degraded. It was fresh."

I stared at him, trying to process what he was saying. "Fresh blood. From a woman who's been dead for two decades."

"According to the forensics, yes."

"That's insane."

"That's impossible," he corrected. "Which means we're missing something. Either the DNA database is corrupted, the sample was contaminated, or..." He trailed off, jaw tightening.

"Or what?"

"Or someone is playing a very elaborate game designed to make you question your sanity."

I wrapped my arms around myself, suddenly cold despite the coffee. "Who would do that? And how? You'd need access to my mother's medical records, her DNA profile, the ability to fake forensic results..."

"Or access to stored biological samples from her autopsy." Daniel pulled another page from the folder. "I made some calls this morning. The county morgue keeps tissue samples for thirty years in cold storage. Your mother's samples are still there, theoretically secure. But security protocols from twenty years ago weren't exactly Fort Knox."

"You think someone stole samples of my mother's tissue?"

"It's one explanation that doesn't require us to believe in ghosts." He set the folder aside, his gray eyes locked on mine. "The alternative is accepting that fresh blood from a deceased woman appeared in your room by supernatural means. And I don't operate in supernatural."

"What about the message?" I asked. "The words from her suicide note. How do you explain that?"

"Information," he said simply. "Suicide notes are part of the public record in some jurisdictions. And if someone close to your family knew the wording, Jonas, for example, or Mrs. Henderson, they could recreate it."

"Jonas wouldn't..."

"Jonas is in love with you." Daniel's voice was flat, clinical. "He's also bitter about your departure, possessive of your attention, and has unrestricted access to your childhood home. That makes him a viable suspect regardless of how you feel about him."

I flinched at the bluntness. "He's not a killer."

"You don't know that. You've been gone ten years. People change."

"Not Jonas."

"Everyone changes, Evelyn. Especially when they're hurt." He stood, moving to the window to look out at the parking lot. "The question is whether his hurt made him dangerous."

I wanted to defend Jonas, to insist that the boy I'd known could never become the kind of man who would terrorize me. But I couldn't reconcile the Jonas of my memories with the bitter sheriff who'd accused me of abandoning him, who'd touched my face with equal parts tenderness and resentment.

"What do we do now?" I asked quietly.

Daniel turned from the window. "We operate on evidence. I'm having the mirror photographed and removed from the scene, the blood samples re-tested by an independent lab. I've requested security footage from the neighbors' Ring cameras, phone records for anyone with keys to your house. We build a case based on facts, not fear."

"And if the facts don't make sense?"

"Then we look harder until they do." He moved back to his chair, picking up the folder again. "There's something else we need to discuss."

The shift in his tone made my pulse quicken. "What?"

"Your legal situation." He pulled out another document, this one official-looking with a government seal. "As of this morning, you're a material witness in an active federal investigation. Three murders, all connected to your family history, all occurring after your return to Hollow's End."

"You think I'm involved."

"The timing is suspicious. I think your presence is a common variable in all three deaths. And I think the evidence, circumstantial as it is suggests you're either a target or a trigger." He set the document on the desk between us. "Which means you can't leave."

The words landed like a physical blow. "What?"

"You're not under arrest. You're not being charged with anything. But you're also not free to leave the jurisdiction while this investigation is ongoing." His expression was impassive, professional. "If you attempt to flee, it will be interpreted as consciousness of guilt and I will have no choice but to issue a warrant."

"You're keeping me here." My voice came out hollow. "In the town that wants me dead."

"It's where I can protect you and monitor the situation." He softened slightly, though his eyes remained hard. "If you're a victim being targeted by someone using your mother's death to torment you, leaving makes you vulnerable. If you're somehow connected to these murders even unknowingly, leaving makes you look guilty. Either way, you stay."

"I don't have a choice."

"No," he said simply. "You don't."

I stood abruptly, needing to move, needing to feel like I had some control over my own body even if I'd lost control of everything else. "So what am I supposed to do? Sit in this hotel room and wait for the next person to die?"

"Cooperate with the investigation. Answer my questions honestly. Stay where I can reach you." He stood as well, blocking the path to the door, not threateningly, but deliberately. "And you're supposed to trust that I'm trying to keep you alive."

"Trust you?" I laughed, the sound bitter. "You've suspected me of murder since the moment you arrived. You think I'm either a killer or crazy or both."

"You're scared and traumatized and hiding something." His voice dropped lower, almost gentle. "But I don't think you're a killer. Not yet."

"Not yet?" I repeated. "That's supposed to be reassuring?"

"It's the only honest answer I can give you." He moved closer, his presence suddenly overwhelming in the small space. "I don't deal in comfort, Evelyn. I deal in facts. And the fact is that you're connected to these deaths whether you want to be or not. Something about you—your bloodline, your return, your presence—is triggering events that are getting people killed. Until I understand why, you don't get to run."

"I'm not running. I'm surviving."

"Then survive here. Where I can see you." His gray eyes searched my face, looking for something I wasn't sure I could give. "Because if you disappear, the next body we find might be yours. And I'm not interested in adding you to the casualty list."

The intensity in his voice surprised me, a crack in the professional facade.

"Why do you care?" I asked. "If you think I'm connected to the murders, if you think I'm dangerous, why not just lock me up and be done with it?"

"Because locking you up doesn't solve anything." He stepped back, creating distance again. "It doesn't stop the killings. It doesn't break whatever pattern is unfolding. And it doesn't answer the question that keeps me up at night."

"What question?"

"Whether you're the victim or the weapon." He picked up his coffee cup, taking a long drink. "Someone is using your history, your guilt, your mother's death as a tool. The blood, the messages, the timing of the murders—it's all designed to break you. But I don't know if they're breaking you to hurt you or to turn you into something else."

I sank back onto the bed, exhaustion crashing over me again. "I don't know either."

"Then we figure it out together." He moved toward the connecting door. "I have meetings this morning. County sheriff, medical examiner, federal prosecutors. You stay here, door locked, phone on. If Jonas shows up, you call me immediately. If you hear whispers, you call me. If anything—and I mean anything—feels wrong, you call me."

"I'm a prisoner."

"You're protected." He paused in the doorway. "There's a difference."

"Is there?"

He didn't answer. Instead, he pulled the connecting door almost closed, leaving just a crack of space between our rooms. "I'll be back by noon. Try to eat something. The stress is eating you alive."

Then he was gone, his footsteps retreating down the hallway, leaving me alone with cold coffee and the suffocating weight of my own uncertainty.

I looked at the mirror above the dresser, studying my reflection. Pale skin, dark circles under my eyes, hair tangled from restless sleep. I looked haunted. I looked guilty.

I looked exactly like my mother in the weeks before she died.

The thought sent ice down my spine. I turned away from the mirror, unable to face my own eyes.

Outside, I heard Daniel's car start and pull away. The sound of the engine faded into morning traffic, and suddenly the silence was deafening.

I was alone. Trapped. Suspected.

And somewhere in this cursed town, someone was watching me unravel.